SYRACUSE, N.Y. — Pitt’s 30-13 win over Syracuse on Saturday night served multiple purposes. It helped the Panthers keep pace at the top of the ACC standings, which become more crowded by the week. But it also gave the coaches plenty to study and critique on film. Perfection — or even high-quality — this win was not. But it is always easier to stomach criticism after a win than a loss, especially given the tough spot this team was backed into Saturday.

Here are three takeaways from a messy win over the Orange, one that felt much tighter for Pitt than the final score would indicate:

War of attrition

The first sign of trouble popped up on Friday night, when Rasheem Biles made a surprising appearance on that evening’s injury report. All told, Pitt ruled 14 players out for Saturday’s game at Syracuse. Seven more were considered game-time decisions as they battled nagging injuries.

Among those battling varying degrees of bumps and bruises were starting left tackle Jeff Persi, All-American tailback Desmond Reid, the ACC’s leading tackler in Biles, and a slew of bruises along the defensive line. And that injury accounting does not include Zach Crothers, Keith Gouveia and others who suffered injuries that will keep them out for the season.

Advertise with us

Pitt got some reinforcements, as safety Cruce Brookins and defensive end Joey Zelinsky returned to the field this week, but those additions were quickly marred by the loss of Kyle Louis, another 2024 All-American selection who left in the first quarter with an undisclosed injury and did not return. Throughout the game, Pitt defenders dropped like flies, whether to simple cramps or something more serious.

“There's a lot, but they play hard,” Pat Narduzzi said of his mounting injuries. “When you play hard, you play physical, it's a collision sport and those things happen. We’ve got to get some guys back healthy and roll.”

The sheer volume of injuries Pitt has been forced to navigate this season, especially on defense, is staggering. It’s admirable Pitt was able to survive this trip north with the limited numbers at its disposal. But as the largely poor execution against Syracuse demonstrated, it’s not something the Panthers can count on week after week.

The next two weeks leading into a bye feature a lower quality of opponent, but it’s imperative the Panthers get healthier before facing some elite competition down the stretch in November.

Protection problems

Mason Heintschel’s third career start was easily his worst — 13 for 24 passing, 166 total yards, one rushing touchdown and one interception. He certainly wasn’t blameless for Pitt’s struggles, but it’s hard to imagine a freshman quarterback thriving in a road environment when he is under duress as often as he was. Heintschel was sacked seven times on Saturday night, a season-high in sacks allowed for the Panthers.

Advertise with us

“Any time you get your quarterback hit seven times, it's not a good thing,” Narduzzi said. “We’ve got to clean that up, and we’ve got to do a better job as coaches and put them in a position to make plays. And we certainly didn't do that when you only have 260 yards total offense.”

A Pitt offensive line that played well last weekend at Florida State — and shut down some trash talk from their opponents — was unable to carry over its strong play into a new week. It wasn’t necessarily because of creative stunts or exotic blitzes being run by the Orange defense — Pitt’s linemen got straight beat more often than not.

Kendall Stanley, filling in for the injured Jeff Persi at left tackle, had a particularly rough night. Allowing pressure is one thing, but he allowed struggles in pass protection to affect his pre-snap operation. All told, Stanley was flagged five times — thrice for false starts, once for a hold and another for an unnecessary roughness penalty — one week after committing zero penalties in his starting debut at Pitt.

Stanley’s miscues are most easily documented, but it was a collective effort that led to the kind of pressure Heintschel faced. Pitt actually ran the ball fairly effectively — 152 total rushing yards at a 4.2 yards per carry clip (sack-adjusted) — but a team that wants to throw the ball as often as it does cannot afford for its offensive line to be this porous and undisciplined.

Freshman takes responsibility 

Whether or not the question demanded such an answer, Heintschel ended every answer in his postgame press conference with some version of, “I have to be better.” There was a lot working against the Panthers, injuries most prominently, but Heintschel himself was not as sharp as he had been in his first two starts against Boston College and Florida State, and he owned it.

Advertise with us

The rash of penalties (13 for 114 yards) that plagued Pitt all evening? Heintschel said he needed to be louder in a raucous road environment. The seven sacks he took? He took responsibility for them, too, since he didn’t get the ball out quick enough. Even in talking about his long touchdown run, Heintschel was self-critical, saying he needed to get the ball to his wideouts more since they blocked downfield for him so well.

As he scrambled up the seam toward the corner of the end zone, securing a 36-yard touchdown run on the Panthers’ opening drive, it seemed like everything would come easy for Heintschel and the Panthers on Saturday night against the Orange. But games are long and progress isn’t linear, so there were lowlights — adversity to overcome and new challenges to crack.

But through it all, Heintschel continues to show the right attitude and respond well. He’s resilient and reflective, which pairs well with talent. College football will continue to teach him hard lessons, but Heintschel has shown he’s ready to learn.