There were a number of reasons why Pitt was favored by more than a touchdown entering the 108th Backyard Brawl.
In a series that has seen six of the last eight contests decided by seven points or fewer, Pitt earned the backing of sportsbooks and bettors because it had a perceived advantage in star power, momentum and, above all else, continuity.
West Virginia was breaking in 80 new players and promoting a handful of backups to starting roles because of injuries. Pitt, on the other hand, had entered the regular season confident that returning its entire offensive coaching staff plus starters at quarterback, running back, offensive line and wide receiver would help it hit the ground running. After two thorough beatdowns of Duquesne and Central Michigan, the Panthers appeared correct.
But a raucous environment at Milan Puskar Stadium and Pitt’s first power conference opponent on the 2025 schedule poked holes in the notion that this unit was better prepared for the 2025 campaign than it was a year ago. All the training camp talk about how valuable continuity was for the Panther offense fell flat from the opening possession, and now the Panthers are back to square one.
“We lost that game,” quarterback Eli Holstein said. “Credit to them, they played a great game and they're a good football team, but I feel like we lost that game. We just didn’t do what we needed to do, didn't execute, didn't do the little things right that we had been doing those first two weeks.”
Pitt lost some key contributors from the 2024 team — leading receiver Konata Mumpfield, starting tight end Gavin Bartholomew and left tackle Branson Taylor chief among them. It’s also dealt with a rotating cast of running backs as injuries mounted during spring practices and fall training camp. But still, the Panthers ranked fourth among ACC teams and 17th nationally in football prediction guru Phil Steele’s preseason experience ratings.
Read More
Entering Week 3, Holstein cited that continuity as a primary reason why he was excited about the direction of the unity as a whole. Pitt committed only four offensive penalties during the first two weeks of the season and had every reason to believe that level of discipline would travel to Morgantown, W.Va.
Said Holstein last Tuesday: “Really excited about where our offense is right now. Feel like we’re on a roll. There are some things to clean up, obviously. But I think our offense is moving in the right direction. I can’t wait to see what we do Saturday.”
But the benefit of such continuity was nowhere to be found when the Panthers took the field at Milan Puskar Stadium on Saturday afternoon. Holstein’s first snap ended in a mercifully recovered fumble. There were repeated miscommunications between Holstein and top pass-catching option Kenny Johnson. He threw an interception when two receivers mistimed a rub route on the goal line. And pressure arrived early and often (on about a quarter of his drop-backs) when pass blockers struggled to handle blitzes and stunts.
And then there were the penalties — eight in total committed by the Pitt offense, four of which came in the red zone.
Three of those four red zone flags were thrown against senior offensive linemen. Lyndon Cooper cost his team 15 yards for an unnecessary roughness penalty in the first quarter, then Keith Gouveia almost singlehandedly kept a touchdown off the board for the Panthers with back-to-back false starts. Fellow senior Justin Holmes, known for his abilities as a blocking tight end, picked up a holding penalty in the red zone, as well, on Pitt’s second drive of the game.
In a game that took overtime to decide, Pitt left at least 14 points on the field because of its lack of discipline.
The Panthers did not make flashy transfer portal additions, choosing to invest in their returning stars. The newcomers were meant to be supplements for a roster that already had so much of what it needed to be successful, but the work of leading this offense was to be done by those who had been in the system before.
The first true test it faced this season should have been a moment when the chemistry the players and coaches had been touting all offseason shined. Instead, it wilted. Instead of seizing momentum heading into conference play, Pitt will have to dig itself out of a hole.
In the bigger picture, losing to West Virginia doesn’t have all that large of an impact on the ultimate goal. But Pitt named its continuity as a strength in the preseason, but those traits don’t show up when the lights come on. So it’s fair to wonder just how good this team can actually be.
“Every week is a different week. You know it is going to be an emotional game. We're gonna let it go and move on to the next one,” head coach Pat Narduzzi said. “We have Louisville next, we got an open week to get fresh, hopefully get our corners back, get Des [Reid] back and be healthy and go on an ACC run.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.