Recruiting is a 24/7, 365-day task every year for college football coaches, one that only becomes more complicated as the thin line between amateurism and professionalism is slowly torn down.

Every program wants to develop its players, but that process starts with recruiting the right players. And recruiting the right players in 2025 requires not only financial commitments but the proper allocation of limited resources.

In an exclusive interview with the Post-Gazette, Pitt football coach Pat Narduzzi detailed some of the ways his program is adjusting to the House settlement and the seismic changes it promises to bring.

At the conclusion of spring practices in April, Narduzzi revealed Doug Whaley, a former NFL executive, had been serving in a de facto general manager role for Pitt football for several years.

Advertise with us

“We're way ahead of the curve,” Narduzzi said.

General managers (some teams use the titles directors of recruiting or personnel instead) have become a vital part of recruiting staffs in the NIL era. The college is beginning to more closely resemble its professional counterpart, and Whaley brings NFL experience.

Whaley was formally employed by Alliance 412, the affiliated NIL collective, a Pitt spokesperson clarified after Narduzzi’s spring announcement, but had a hand in the construction of the roster going back “a couple of years,” Narduzzi said.

But heading into the 2025 season, Narduzzi said Whaley works in an “advisory role” and gave much of the credit for roster building to director of player personnel Graham Wilbert and recruiting director Adam Caltury, a pair of longtime Pitt staffers whom Narduzzi hinted could see title changes sometime soon.

“That [general manager] title, everybody wants to talk about the GM title, new title and all that. It's just restructuring recruiting offices,” Narduzzi said.

Advertise with us

“I don't deal with the day-to-day conversations of what [everyone is] going to make, ... but we have people in those roles to do that. Adam Caltury and Graham Wilbert are pretty much our GMs.”

Wilbert came to Pitt from Florida Atlantic, where he played quarterback, coached and began his career as a recruiting staffer. He worked as director of player personnel and external relations for the Owls from 2015-16.

Caltury, a native of Monaca, took his first job at Ohio State as a recruiting assistant. In 2016, he took over as director of recruiting at Rutgers, then as director of player personnel in 2018. Narduzzi said he brings expert knowledge of the local recruiting landscape in Western Pennsylvania.

Caltury and Wilbert oversee a scouting and recruiting department that has expanded this summer. Coaches still identify talent, establish relationships with players and “recruit” in a traditional sense.

But the introduction of direct payments from athletic departments to the players, plus an unruly and ever-changing NIL market, means the financial side of college recruiting is a full-time job, as well.

Advertise with us

Wilbert, Caltury and Whaley, all working in concert, are an extension of the coaching staff in matters of revenue sharing and NIL. They satisfy an important part of the recruiting process, something Narduzzi doesn’t think coaches should deal with.

“I think when a head coach gets involved with the financial part of it, it becomes different,” Narduzzi said. “I want to be the head coach. I want the players looking at me as a head football coach and a guy that coaches ball and runs a football team, not trying to do both.”

Narduzzi, like most college football coaches, wants as much control as possible. Control means certainty, and in a volatile sport, certainty is a priceless commodity.

That’s why, as Pitt tries to catch up, he wanted to maintain his preferred hierarchy, with the coach at the top.

A handful of FBS programs, including ACC peers Stanford and Cal, have upset that model, placing their general managers at the top of football programs instead of coaches. Some even have the authority to fire coaches themselves.

Advertise with us

“That would be weird. It's kind of like Jerry Jones,” Narduzzi said, referencing the atypically hands-on owner of the Dallas Cowboys. “Who’s in charge, Jerry Jones or Mike McCarthy? Who's running the team?”

That won’t be how Pitt operates. Whereas some programs have general managers making decisions for the program at large, Wilbert and Caltury act on the wishes of the coaching staff.

They read evaluations of recruits from the coaches, who also specify how high of a priority each player is on a scale of one to five. From there, they are expected to make sure the financial side of recruiting isn’t an impediment to the player committing.”

“I can't talk enough about how blessed I am to have those two guys running the [recruiting department],” Narduzzi said. “They're the day-to-day guys. I mean, Doug Whaley’s not in our office. Those guys are day to day, working on the 2026 class, 2027 class, 2028 class, getting the stuff our coaches need to evaluate.”

Narduzzi needs to trust the people he empowers to get recruits across the finish line and into the program. And with 12 combined seasons spent at Pitt, Wilbert and Caltury have certainly earned it.

Advertise with us

“Adam and Grant, those guys lead the show,” Narduzzi said. “I don't have to walk down to the recruiting office and say, ‘Hey, is everything going OK today? How are these guys doing?’ No, I know they're doing it the way I want.

“I know they're going to get it done.”