Jeff Capel hasn’t always been willing to entertain the notion the ACC’s best years are behind it. But on Monday morning, a man who had played and coached in the league for decades couldn’t ignore that, at least this season, the ACC has lagged well behind its peers at the power-conference level.

Is the ACC suffering through a “down year”? For Capel, the answer is definitively yes. That was clear to him very early in the season, and now the conference’s collective shortcomings are going to hurt member schools’ pursuit of NCAA tournament bids, perpetuating a prolonged backslide for one of Division I basketball’s most storied collections of teams.

“That’s the reality. I’m not going to give you coach speak,” Capel said. “And a big part of it is what happened in the nonconference. Now, I think teams have gotten better since then, but it seems like, in college basketball now, what counts the most is what you do in the nonconference.

“I think it’s easy to beat up on us, our league, because that’s been the narrative the past few years.”

Advertise with us

The signs of a “down year” for the ACC are easy enough to see. When the latest AP poll was released, the ACC had just three teams ranked, trailing the SEC’s eight and five each for the Big 12 and Big Ten.

KenPom keeps a running tally of each Division I conference’s collective net rating, and as of Monday morning, the ACC was fifth. The net rating gap between the SEC, which owns the best mark of any league in Division I, and the ACC is roughly as large as the gap between the ACC and the 14th-place Western Athletic Conference (WAC).

Over the past five years, college sports have changed dramatically, and the ACC has lost position as one of the elite leagues in college basketball in the process. The expanded SEC is rolling through a historic season that could end with as many as 13 teams earning bids to the 68-team NCAA tournament field, and the Big Ten is also likely to send more than 10 teams to the Big Dance. Meanwhile, the ACC might have to settle for just three or four bids.

Capel saw how the SEC and Big Ten have made massive gains in total revenue by way of conference expansion and new media deals and how that money has been funneled into the name, image and likeness (NIL) war chests necessary to build elite teams. And it’s plain to him wealth is the biggest indicator of success on the court.

“As difficult as that may be to say or hear, it's where we are now,” Capel said. “I would challenge people to look at ... what each school in our league is spending on their roster compared to the other leagues. And it is talent acquisition. ... I think we have really good coaches in our league, but man, you’ve got to have good players, too.”

Advertise with us

The dramatic difference in talent was manifested in the results of the ACC-SEC Challenge, when the SEC won 14 of 16 games against ACC foes, with an average margin of victory of 15.9 points. Pitt itself was completely overwhelmed by Mississippi State in their leg of the event, falling by 33 points on the road.

Capel believes it doesn’t have to be this way. He pointed to how Louisville, ranked No. 14 in the latest AP poll, had turned around from two of the worst seasons in program history to become one of the country’s elite teams. And Capel claims they had to pay well to get this team, loaded with experience and talent from the transfer portal.

“The energy in that building, it was back to how it was when I first got this job at Pitt or when I was still at Duke and they were winning,” Capel said. “But they went out — and again, I think they spent a good amount — and they got really good players, good guys that fit what [coach] Pat [Kelsey] wants to do, and they’ve been able to change it very quickly.”

There’s no reason in Capel’s mind why the ACC can’t rebuild itself the way Louisville did, but it would require major investments from the administrators who lead these schools. He claims there are some schools and programs that haven’t been as willing to put the money necessary up to build elite basketball teams and only when everyone in the league decides to do so can the ACC become one of college basketball’s standard bearers again.

“I think, with the way this thing has gone, every school has been able to do what they want to do,” Capel said. “So it’s not like we’re handicapped by the league office or anything like that. I think some of this has been the individual schools and what they want to do and I think there’s been some arrogance there.

“Look at last week’s top 25, and I would bet you most of the schools on there have invested. And I don’t think the SEC has mandated teams do that. Schools have just done that.”