Rivalries are some of the best parts of sports, and Pitt has a ton of them. The Backyard Brawl in football. The hatred of Syracuse in basketball.
For the Panthers volleyball team, the biggest non-conference rivalry comes against in-state rival Penn State.
It’s a match we’ll see play out at 7 p.m. Wednesday in Petersen Events Center.
And it’s perfect timing for the game, as Pitt (6-0) sits at No. 1 and Penn State (8-0) at No. 3 in the country. This matchup, while early in the season, could be the difference for one of these teams earning a No. 1 seed in the NCAA tournament.
But it’s also much more than that.
It’s a match between an emerging program and one trying to re-establish itself, a showdown between two conferences. It’s an important game for volleyball in the state of Pennsylvania.
Read More
Wednesday’s match is bigger than which team gets its first loss of the season, who leads in kills or who will take over the top of the rankings. It’s a fight for state pride, a battle cry for resources and a chance to highlight a new crown jewel of the sport.
“Everybody in the country is going to be watching that match,” ESPN commentator Holly McPeak said. “Obviously, because they are the tops of their conferences, they're the teams to beat, and there's so much parity across the country that everybody's kind of watching everybody. I'm just excited to see what's going to happen.”
On the national stage
Only 11 programs have won a national championship. Stanford has the most titles with nine, followed by Penn State with seven. For a while, it was the same names over and over again at the top of the rankings — Hawaii, USC, Stanford, Nebraska, etc. It wasn’t until Kentucky in the spring of 2021 and Wisconsin in the fall that we saw new names.
The parity between Pitt and Penn State is interesting. You have one program — Penn State — trying to get back to the glory days. Then there’s Pitt trying to cement itself as a bona fide premier program.
It’s why the volleyball community was excited to see Pitt atop the rankings for the first time in program history. The Panthers have become a constant in the conversation for national championship contenders.
“Dan Fisher's done an incredible job building a culture there, getting the top recruits,” McPeak said. “Historically, Pitt was not getting the best recruits in the country, but the fact that he was able to create the culture and talk these players into coming and being a part of something and building, it says a lot about him as a coach and what they're building there.”
When Fisher started coaching at Pitt in 2013, it had been nine years since the Panthers made a postseason tournament. He led Pitt to its first NCAA tournament in eight years in 2016 and has been in the tournament every year since. In the 2020 season, with current players like Valeria Vazquez Gomez and Cat Flood on the roster, they made their first regional semifinal.
The following season, Fisher added Emmy Klika and Rachel Fairbanks, two highly touted recruits. Suddenly, the Panthers were in the Final Four.
Then they did it again.
And again.
“It's beyond what I certainly thought when I got here,” Fisher said. “Until we win a national championship, you're not going to be seen in the same light as Texas or Nebraska or Stanford until you win that.”
Which is why this season has the chance to be so special. They have all the pieces needed to win a national championship. All but the middle blocker core return from last year’s squad. Standout hitters Torrey Stafford and Olivia Babcock, who were only freshmen last year, are playing better than ever.
But the first major test comes against Penn State on Wednesday.
“I know what it means to Pitt fans to beat Penn State, to be above them in the rankings,” Fisher said. “Our goal is to win a national championship. And they’re clearly someone in our way.”
No one is surprised to see the Nittany Lions atop the AVCA rankings and starting off with an undefeated season. It was fewer than 20 years ago when they won four consecutive titles. It was just about 10 years ago when they went back-to-back.
But in recent years, it hasn’t been Penn State as the Big Ten powerhouse team — it’s Nebraska or Wisconsin. The Badgers are the ones who have knocked the Nittany Lions out of the NCAA tournament for the past two seasons.
“They're normally near the top of the rankings,” said Emily Ehman, a national college volleyball broadcaster. “But to be honest, for this Penn State team, they've been trying to get back there over the last, five, seven years or so. Not that they took a massive drop off -—they're still making Sweet 16s and doing well in the tournament. But this is a program that expects greatness.”
Third-year coach Katie Schumacher-Cawley returned to Penn State as an assistant a year after the team’s last Final Four appearance in 2017. She worked with legendary Penn State coach Russ Rose, who was with the program for 42 years.
Much like Pitt, the Nittany Lions truly believe this is the season they can get to the top of the mountain. There’s fifth-year talent in Jess Mruzik and Taylor Trammell. There’s an influx of talent both out of the transfer portal — Nebraska’s Maggie Mendelson and Caroline Jurevicius — and the No. 1 recruit from last year’s high school class in setter Izzy Starck.
“We have some really great players that are on the team now,” Schumacher-Cawley said. “It's been fun going through the process and trying to figure out what works best for us and, but, you know, we have a great group that works hard and embraces the challenges and competes, so they help it.”
There’s already so much parity in the sport right now, which makes the match between these two teams even more interesting.
“It's just been impressive to see the rise of Pitt and then obviously Penn State, trying to re-establish themselves,” McPeak said. “The fact that they're both in a really good place right now, it's incredible.”
The power of conferences
Fueling that success has been difficult non-conference schedules. Football and basketball may tend to avoid power conference teams, but that’s not the case for volleyball.
Pitt has played a pair of ranked Big Ten teams. Penn State has played a ranked ACC team and two ranked SEC teams.
The highest-ranked Big Ten team and the highest-ranked ACC team will be going head-to-head on Wednesday. It’s a chance for one of them to take the crown as the top volleyball conference, at least for the early part of the season.
Historically, the Big Ten sends more teams to the NCAA tournament than the ACC. It’s only recently that you’ve seen more ACC teams join the ranks of Pitt and Louisville, who have been in the conversation for at least the last decade.
In 2021, seven Big Ten teams qualified for the dance, and Wisconsin would go on to win the title. There were just five for the ACC. It was similar in 2022, with the ACC again sending five and the Big Ten sending six. Last year, it was even at five and five, but the Big Ten had two No. 1-seeded teams, whereas Pitt was the lone ACC team.
Through the early part of this season, you could argue that the ACC has the best top teams. Two of the top three are from the ACC — thanks to Stanford, at No. 2, joining the league. Louisville makes three in the top five. Expand it to the top seven, and the Big Ten has four, with the ACC at three.
“It's been a long time coming for a conference like the ACC, but now we've seen Pitt make the last three Final Fours,” Ehman said. “Louisville was in the last two of the three Final Fours. It's a conference that's getting better and better. Every single year, it feels like not only is the top getting better and pushing other national top teams, but the middle-of-the-pack ACC teams are doing incredibly well.”
A lot of it comes down to resources. The Big Ten and its members have invested in volleyball. Nebraska hosted a match at Memorial Stadium last season and drew a crowd of 92,003. Wisconsin sells out a majority of its home matches, with fans lining up hours before the matches.
That’s not to say the ACC and its teams aren’t trying. Pitt’s former athletics director Heather Lyke started the Victory Heights project as a way to invest in all of Pitt’s Olympic sports, with the plan to provide programs like volleyball with a shiny new 240,000-square-foot facility that will include a new home venue plus several other training facilities and offices for Pitt sports teams.
The volleyball program is the shining example of Olympic-sports dominance at Pitt with its sustained success over recent years. But the facilities project is facing new scrutiny after Lyke was removed from her position on Sept. 9. As of April 2023, Lyke said Pitt had raised around $12 million of the $240 million she said was necessary to complete the entire project.
It all created an unusual aura, as Pitt reached its first No. 1 ranking the same day her removal was announced.
“It's taken a lot of time for the ACC to kind of get teams and programs going,” Ehman said. “[The ACC] has been fighting for resources and the belief from athletic departments, and also just to get the conference as a whole to say, ‘Hey, we're actually really good at volleyball. We need more resources. Pay attention to us, give us better courts, give us better arenas, put more into programs and promote it and all of these things.’”
Beyond the battle between the conferences, we’ll get to see the styles of play battle it out. The Big Ten is known for its physicality and strength. The ACC brings a ton of hustle, finesse and gritty defense.
“You have two of the best conferences in volleyball really fighting it out,” Ehman said. “Whether these programs are thinking about it like that or not, it's essentially, ‘Is the ACC better than the Big Ten, or is the Big Ten better than the ACC right now?’ I think a lot of people are looking at this matchup like, ‘OK, who's going to win out?’”
In an ironic twist, before the season, ESPN chose to televise other, more traditional in-state battles — Kentucky vs. Louisville and Baylor vs. Texas — shifting Penn State-Pitt to the ACC Network.
It’s a nod to established volleyball hubs such as Southern California, Texas, or the Midwest … but it also acknowledges how quickly times are changing and how these two have an opportunity to direct even more attention our way.
Pitt officials anticipate a sellout. They already decided to put the match in Petersen Events Center as opposed to their usual arena of Fitzgerald Field House — an 8,000-seat difference in capacity.
Regardless of the outcome, the fact that national volleyball eyes are on Western Pennsylvania is a new and welcomed development.
“It continues to help grow the sport,” McPeak said. “By putting more eyes in Pennsylvania, our sport grows there, and it grows everywhere else. It gives young athletes something to look up to, which in turn helps grow the sport.
"More and more players want to be like Torrey Stafford or Olivia [Babcock]. They want to follow in their footsteps. These athletes are incredible, and it gives the young athletes something to aspire to be.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.