Welcome to the Pitt mailbag. If you have any questions about the Panthers, send them to Christopher Carter and Stephen Thompson, and they may answer them in their weekly show. You can catch the full version on YouTube, with an edited transcript below:
Jim: How long will it take for the offense to be proficient in Kade Bell’s scheme?
Thompson: As I saw this question, I thought about something Branson Taylor said to me on the first day of training camp: “The only thing that gets you into football shape is football.” They're going to need to play another opponent before they even realize where their understanding of this scheme is and what it's actually capable of. So, to that end, it's really going to take some time.
There's another cliche about how teams grow the most between Weeks 1 and 2, and that certainly applies here. Coach Pat Narduzzi is going to generally want Pitt to keep its offense vanilla against Kent State in the opener because that’s what he's done traditionally when he hasn’t played a power-conference team. He tends to limit the playbook so teams further down the road can't see what they're doing. With Cincinnati and West Virginia on the horizon after Kent State, that’s what he’ll do.
And this is a really radically different system from what most of the players who are going to be featured in this offense have ran for most of their time at Pitt. I'd be surprised if we see them humming or even close to peak performance before the first bye week in Week 5.
Carter: You've got to assume that this is going to take some time. That doesn't mean they won't score, but we are just not going to see this team operating at full capacity for a while because the scheme is so radically different. They're not going to know what they've got until they actually step onto the field against another opponent for the first time, and also, there's different levels of opponents, right? Because Kent State ain't going to be the same as Cincinnati. Cincinnati's not going to be the same as West Virginia. None of those teams are going to be the same as Clemson when they face them later in the year.
Read More
I really think a lot of this will come down to if they can find their bread and butter. And by that, I mean a basic part of this offense that they can dial up when they need a big play, something to get a first down, a third down or to get in the end zone on a must-win drive. Can they develop things like that in this offense? If they can, great. But they've got to find those early on. They've got to hit the ground running early.
I'm not fully sure when we'll see them being proficient against top competition. There's a chance that they look good in that first game, then hit their bumps in the road like all teams do and all college teams do. But if I was to say “looking proficient,” I wouldn't be shocked if it was Week 7 or 8 before you saw this offense firing on all cylinders.
Tom: How have the wide receivers looked so far in camp? Has Konata Mumpfield secured the WR1 spot? Who do you think will be the top three pass catchers?
Carter: Yes, Mumpfield's been Wide Receiver 1. I don't think he secured that this camp — it's been secure all along. But the question really is: Who's Wide Receiver 2? Because Kenny Johnson was a guy who was looking really promising after his freshman year last year, but they've got C.J. Lee, they've got Poppi Williams, guys that are that are used to this system. They also got Daejon Reynolds. Where do you have the hierarchy of receivers beyond Mumpfield?
Thompson: After Mumpfield, it's kind of a big mixed bag. I'd say it's pretty obvious that Poppi Williams is that No. 2 guy right now. I don't think you can talk about the wide receivers with anyone on this team without them mentioning Poppi Williams, who’s been a really explosive player in camp. He seems to be the most consistent one outside of Mumpfield.
But other than that, it's really wide open. There are maybe as many as four guys fighting for that No. 3 spot. I'd throw Daejon Reynolds in there; obviously, Kenny Johnson, as well; C.J. Lee, too. Even some younger guys, like Zion Fowler-El, who has looked really impressive during fall camp.
And if you’re talking about that third pass-catcher spot, all of those guys I mentioned are fighting with Gavin Bartholomew for catches, too. Williams has separated himself, and Bartholomew will be a big factor, too. But for a team that wants to go maybe six, seven, eight receivers deep, there are a lot more snaps that are left up for grabs right now.
Carter: I would say you’ll likely see a mix of the transfers, Lee and Williams, with Kenny Johnson as the second and third guys in the receiver rotation, and then the fourth and fifth options, it would be more of those young guys like Lamar Seymore or Zion Fowler-El.
Cagy: Who has stood out on the defensive line in training camp?
Thompson: The first name that comes to mind is obviously Nate Matlack, but I don't think that one's really a surprise. He came in looking like he would be a starter as a graduate transfer from Kansas State at the defensive end spot. Francis Brewu is the other name that's really popped, as well. He landed on Bruce Feldman's “College Football Freaks” list because of his unnatural power for a true freshman, and he's got some quickness, too.
And if you're looking for another guy at defensive end, I'd say Chief Borders, the transfer from Nebraska who came in this summer. I think it's interesting that someone who was not a mid-year enrollee has kind of impressed his coaches so quickly.
The last name I would throw out there is Sean FitzSimmons. This is a bit more of a hunch. I can't tell you I've seen a ton in practice that tells me he’s ready for a huge leap, but I just have a feeling. I think he's got a great skill set, and I was really disappointed that injuries held him back last year. He’s a different-looking defensive lineman that’s shorter, quicker and maybe just a little bit more explosive off of the ball than what Pitt had last year.
Carter: I wouldn't sleep on Nahki Johnson. I think that's the good thing about this unit: There are a whole bunch of young players who could stand out in this group. You mentioned Francis Brewu. I mean, that dude looks stacked, man. And I say, “dude” because he’s only 18. He's a kid. He's literally just out of high school, true freshman. And when I see him, I'm wowed.
The other guy I'm looking at is Isaiah Neal. He seems to be taking on a presence at camp. For all the struggles they had last year, there were a lot of young guys who have high ceilings, and if they are realized this year, Pitt football becomes a lot better very quickly.
Stephen Thompson: sthompson@post-gazette.com and @stephenethom on X. Christopher Carter: ccarter@post-gazette.com and @CarterCritiques on X





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.