DURHAM, N.C. — Pitt football concluded its 2023 season with a 30-19 loss on the road against Duke on Saturday afternoon, ending the year with an overall record of 3-9. The defeat secured Pitt’s first winless season on the road since 2005 and worst record as a program since 1998.
While there is plenty to break down from Saturday’s loss, the bigger story is the season as a whole. Before we turn the page over to the offseason, let’s take one final look at everything that occurred in the past few months.
Here are my five takeaways from Pitt’s 2023 campaign:
Another portal mishap
Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me — that should be Pat Narduzzi’s mantra when reviewing his program’s decision to find its starting quarterback in the transfer portal. Following the departure of Kenny Pickett in 2021, Pitt chose to bring in Kedon Slovis from USC rather than going with Nick Patti, Pickett’s long-time backup.
After seeing that decision backfire, resulting in Slovis’ departure, Narduzzi once again looked to the portal to replace Slovis, bringing in Phil Jurkovec from Boston College to work with his former offensive coordinator Frank Cignetti Jr.
Read More
Jurkovec’s homecoming went worse than even the most pessimistic Pitt fans could have even imagined. After just five starts, when he led the Panthers to a 1-4 record, Jurkovec was benched and demoted to the team’s third-string signal caller. He then changed his position to tight end the day after the news of his demotion was made public.
It perhaps isn’t totally fair to blame Narduzzi for at least giving Slovis and Jurkovec a look. Both had a few factors in their favor that gave reason for some to believe they would be capable of performing at a respectable level. Neither, however, worked out well.
For a school like Pitt, where the concept of NIL investment is growing but nowhere near where it is compared to other elite programs, portal mistakes like this simply can’t happen in back-to-back years. What makes things worse is the fact that at the end of both the 2022 and 2023 seasons, Pitt discovered that it had a productive internal option on its roster (Patti and Nate Yarnell).
It went without saying that replacing Pickett would be a challenge, but it’s hard to imagine things going any worse than how it has played out in the two seasons since he switched over to the other football team in the Steel City.
An inverse of years past
Running the football, stopping the run, forcing turnovers and playing a clean game: That, for eight years, was Narduzzi’s winning formula. But this season, nearly every one of those aforementioned categories was not applicable to Narduzzi’s squad.
Pitt failed to establish any sort of identity this season — especially on the ground, where Pitt had just two 100-yard rushing efforts in 12 games. Its offense was so anemic that it entered nearly every matchup with legitimate questions as to how points would be scored, and its defense suffered from that lack of production.
Poor time of possession along with a few notable departures hurt the Panthers in the middle of the defense, resulting in a less stellar presence against the run. Poor quarterback play led to more turnovers than usual, creating easier scoring chances for the opposition, allowing the Panthers defense to wear down as games went on.
Turnover creation was there but not like other years, as Pitt finished with a negative turnover ratio (minus-5) for the first time since 2019. While there were flashes of “Narduzzi football,” such as the wins against Louisville and Boston College, it could be argued that those efforts were more of an anomaly than a standard.
Simply put: Pitt struggled to do well in areas it recruits, teaches and depends upon to win football games.
It wasn’t just the quarterbacks
I understand that the quarterback play was bad. Really, really bad. But while a good signal caller can often determine a team’s ceiling, this year’s 3-9 record falls on the shoulders of more players than just Jurkovec, Yarnell and Christian Veilleux.
Pitt was heavily hampered up front, starting 10 different offensive line combinations in 12 games. While in previous seasons the Panthers found a way to adjust when they suffered a major injury in the trenches, the losses of Matt Goncalves, Ryan Jacoby and others caused irreparable damage to the entire offense, both through the air and on the ground.
Meanwhile, on the other side of the ball, Pitt was simply without a playmaker that could change the game. Narduzzi was heavily criticized for his comments following his team’s loss to Notre Dame when he pointed out that his staff hadn’t done a great job at replacing last year’s departures, but the reality is, he was right.
Pitt needed players such as Shayne Simon, Bangally Kamara, Dayon Hayes, Javon McIntyre and M.J. Devonshire to have All-ACC caliber seasons this fall, and for one reason or another, none of them managed to do so.
The Panthers defensive unit as a whole was still solid overall, and some of those aforementioned names (Kamara, Hayes, McIntyre) could be back next year, which is a good thing. But as far as this year is concerned, Pitt needed a superstar to rally around on defense, and after searching for 12 games, it was unable to find one.
Major changes needed
The bulk of Narduzzi’s postgame press conference Saturday afternoon pertained not to his team’s loss to Duke, but rather what the upcoming offseason will look like. It’s safe to assume that Narduzzi will be making changes to his staff, especially on the offensive side of the ball, but even after Saturday’s loss, when his team failed to score more than 20-plus points for the sixth time in 12 games, he wouldn’t commit to any specific moves.
“We’ll digest this, watch the videotape, and the evaluation goes on yearlong,” Narduzzi said. “Every game, every Saturday, every Sunday, every Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday through Friday. We’ll just evaluate where we are and what we can do to get better. Again, it starts with the coaches, period.”
Narduzzi is known for his loyalty and his love for stability. Pitt’s staff didn’t see one change made last offseason, and some of his assistants, such as Tim Salem and Andre Powell, have been with him for his entire tenure in Pittsburgh. But a 3-9 season will put that loyalty to test.
This season could perhaps change Narduzzi’s desire to find an instant answer at quarterback in the transfer portal. The Post-Gazette asked Narduzzi if Yarnell, through two games, has shown enough to enter the offseason as Pitt’s established starter. Surprisingly, Narduzzi expressed that that was indeed the case.
“No question about it,” Narduzzi said. “I mean, he’s a guy who can win a lot of football games for us. He’s smart, takes coaching, he’s tough and he made some good plays out there and made his mistakes, too, but we have a lot of faith in him.”
With the quarterback room figured out — let’s not completely give up on Veilleux, either — Pitt will be able to use its resources elsewhere, bringing in players on both sides of the ball to address its notable depth issues.
More questions than answers
On Sunday afternoon, Cignetti was fired as expected. Now who will stay? Who will leave? Who is safe? Who else will be fired? What is the offensive vision moving forward? And what will the financial resources look like to address each one of these issues. All valid questions that all must be answered soon.
Narduzzi has had one other losing season during his career as a head coach, but that was prior to the transfer portal and NIL. In today’s world of college football, time moves extra fast. Within the next week, there will be numerous Pitt players entering the transfer portal, some of whom started numerous games for the Panthers over the past few years.
Narduzzi said Saturday that the time to figure out what his 2024 roster will look like begins Sunday, a day after his team arrives back from Durham. Pitt’s 2023 roster featured talent, as does its 2024 recruiting class, but can that talent be retained?
If so, will Narduzzi and Lyke be able to make the moves necessary to ensure its top players aren’t underutilized next fall, like we saw with Gavin Bartholomew and Rodney Hammond Jr. this season?
The Post-Gazette asked Narduzzi for his biggest takeaway for the 2023 season during his postgame presser Saturday afternoon:
“It’s a long list of things that we’ve got to clean up and just keep getting better,” Narduzzi said. “We’ve got a young team that’s played a lot of football. We played a lot of young guys all year and there’s a lot of takeaways and I probably don’t have time for them.”
With so much to fix in so little time, Pitt doesn’t have the luxury to sit around and dissect things for long. If it waits too long to act, the best players and coaches available will find a different team. Narduzzi must develop a vision and put that into action immediately, or another disappointing season could be on the horizon.
Noah Hiles: nhiles@post-gazette.com and Twitter @_NoahHiles






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.