A Pitt athletics spokesperson announced Aug. 25 that Dior Johnson, a redshirt freshman on the Panthers basketball team, was no longer enrolled as a student at the University of Pittsburgh. The news came as a shock to some, even considering the controversial past tied to the student involved.
Despite a dark cloud of serious allegations leading to an arrest in 2022 and an entire season of inactivity that followed, everything on the surface suggested Johnson — a former five-star recruit who was Pitt’s highest-rated commit since Steven Adams in 2012 — would play a sizable role during the 2023-24 season.
After sticking around on campus throughout the summer, Johnson joined his teammates on a 10-day trip to Spain, where he participated in both of Pitt’s international contests. Then suddenly, a Friday night announcement had Johnson not only on the sideline again, but out of school completely.
So what happened? The Post-Gazette contacted numerous sources and combed through university documents to try to gain a fuller understanding of the situation.
How it all began
In October 2022, Johnson was arrested for his alleged involvement in a domestic incident that took place at his apartment in Oakland on Sept. 5 and 6 in the 3400 block of Forbes Avenue. A female told police that Johnson became angry after she got his phone wet, held her against her will at an apartment, slapped and punched her and pushed her face into a bed, making it difficult for her to breathe.
Following nearly a month-long police investigation, Johnson was charged with aggravated assault, strangulation, unlawful restraint, simple assault and false imprisonment on the evening of Oct. 6. He was arrested the next day and indefinitely suspended from Pitt’s basketball program.
While Johnson’s incident made him the latest of numerous former Pitt basketball players to have run-ins with the law, his case was viewed in a far more serious manner than others such as John Hugley IV and Ithiel Horton. Johnson’s interesting path prior to Pittsburgh, which included stops at 10 different high schools since his high school basketball career began in 2017 as a seventh-grader or his prior collegiate commitments to Syracuse and Oregon, also elevated the case’s public interest.
On Dec. 9, Johnson pleaded guilty to two misdemeanors at the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas in connection with the September incident. Judge Jill Rangos sentenced Johnson to a year of probation for the two misdemeanor counts of simple assault and strangulation. He was reinstated to the basketball team later that month.
Multiple sources informed the Post-Gazette that Johnson, who is 19 years old, caused no further issues following his reinstatement. In January, Johnson once again began taking classes at Pitt. He remained a part of Jeff Capel’s team but elected to redshirt, resulting in him not appearing in a single contest in the 2022-23 season.
Last week’s news of Johnson’s departure left many questions unanswered. Pitt fans were left to wonder if Johnson made the choice to leave on his own or if he was dismissed. If Johnson was indeed dismissed, who made that decision, and why was it made so close to the start of a new school year, nearly 10 months after the incident?
The Post-Gazette contacted the University of Pittsburgh with numerous questions about Johnson’s departure. The university did not give any specific details but replied with the following statement:
“The University of Pittsburgh has clear policies and procedures to address student conduct both on and off campus, including situations that result in arrest. These policies and procedures apply to all students, and they were followed in respect to Dior Johnson. The University’s policies and procedures are outlined publicly in our Student Code of Conduct.”
The code
Through this response, the Post-Gazette was able to confirm that Johnson’s dismissal was indeed a decision made by the university. A look into the Student Code of Conduct provided a further explanation of what exactly happened.
The start of Johnson’s punishment process began with the filing of a formal complaint. Per the student code of conduct, only two parties have the authority to file a complaint: the complainant, otherwise known as the victim, or the university’s Title IX coordinator.
The university was unable to say which of the two filed the complaint against Johnson, nor could it provide a date as to when the complaint was filed. The Post-Gazette also contacted Johnson and his representatives for this information, but both declined comment.
After a complaint is filed, the university must inform both parties involved. A written notice is provided to both parties at least five business days prior to any initial interview conducted by an investigator related to the formal complaint for parties to have sufficient time to prepare for the initial interview.
Following the interviews, an investigation typically takes place by someone appointed by the university. The student code of conduct says the person appointed cannot be the Title IX coordinator, the decision-maker and the appellate decision-makers.
If a formal complaint contains allegations that do not constitute sexual harassment as defined in the student code of conduct or do not meet the requirements of the student code of conduct, the formal complaint or individual allegations therein will be dismissed. There can also be an informal resolution between the two parties and the university. However, neither of these occurred during the investigation connected to Johnson.
As the investigation unfolds, the investigator will gather evidence and witness statements related to the formal complaint. Both the complainant and respondent have the opportunity to provide their evidence and witness to be considered. Both parties are permitted one person to provide support when talking with the investigator.
Before the investigative report is finalized, the investigator gives both parties 10 business days to review all the evidence. Those 10 business days start when both parties receive the non-finalized investigative report.
Once the investigative report — which summarizes all allegations, relevant evidence and procedural steps to the investigation — is finalized, the report is then given to the decision-maker, as well as the complainant and the respondent. The University of Pittsburgh informed the Post-Gazette that it, like many other universities, uses neutral third parties as the decision-makers. Both parties have 10 business days to submit a written response about the investigative report to the decision-maker, which serves as official confirmation.
Following the 10 business days both parties are given to respond from the investigative report, a hearing will take place. The student code of conduct states that the decision-maker must be able to physically see both parties during the hearing, meaning they must be present either virtually or in person. Both parties are permitted to have an adviser during the hearing. Should one party not have an adviser, the university will assign one.
The hearing includes an opportunity for both parties to examine each other’s evidence and witnesses. After examining all evidence, the decision-maker determines whether the university’s policy was violated. If the policy is violated, the written determination of responsibility containing all information listed above, other than the sanctions, is then submitted to the appropriate chair, dean, director, supervisor, responsibility center head or designee to determine the appropriate sanctions.
Once sanctions are determined, they are then returned to the decision-maker, who incorporates them into a written determination of responsibility before distributing the same to both parties. The student code of conduct states that sanctions will not be imposed until the grievance process is complete. This includes, if applicable, until the time for an appeal of the outcome runs out or until a determination is made regarding any such appeal.
Possible sanctions include disciplinary reprimand, educational meetings, suspension, dismissal and/or termination. After the written determination of responsibility is provided to the parties, either party can appeal the determination. The complainant and respondent have 10 business days from the receipt of the written determination of responsibility to file a petition for appeal.
If an appeal petition is submitted, said sanctions will remain postponed through the University Review Board (URB) review of the appeal petition. Procedural irregularity, new evidence, conflict of interest and sanctions substantially disproportionate to the severity of the violation are the four grounds of which an appeal can be made.
How it applied
In Johnson’s case, the decision-maker found Johnson responsible for the actions filed in the formal complaint against him. Johnson’s sanction was dismissal from the university. Multiple sources informed the Post-Gazette that Johnson then appealed the decision.
When an appeal is made, a panel of three members of the URB act as the appellate decision-makers. One of the members of the URB serves as the moderator. None of the appellate decision-makers can be university students, the Title IX coordinator, the investigator or the decision-maker from the original hearing. The URB is generally given 30 business days to finish their part of the appeal process.
Johnson’s appeal was unsuccessful. Because sanctions are not imposed until the process is complete, Johnson remained an active student and member of the university’s basketball team, which explains why he joined the team on its 10-day trip to Spain last month.
On Friday, Aug. 25, the news of his dismissal from the university was made public.
From the moment his departure was made public, rumors on social media surfaced stating that Johnson’s dismissal came at the hands of the university’s new chancellor, Joan Gabel. However, the Post-Gazette’s examination of the University of Pittsburgh’s student code of conduct shows that Gabel had no connection with Johnson’s dismissal.
Multiple sources informed the Post-Gazette that though Capel was not in favor of Johnson’s dismissal, communication existed between the university and athletic department that allowed the coach to know Johnson’s dismissal was a possibility.
Since Johnson’s departure from Pitt, Capel and his staff have already taken steps to fill his spot on the team. On Friday afternoon, Pitt added Michael Hueitt Jr., a 24-year-old guard, to its roster from the transfer portal.
Noah Hiles: nhiles@post-gazette.com and Twitter @_NoahHiles. Christopher Carter: ccarter@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @CarterCritiques





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.