After playing a significant role in Pitt’s successful turnaround season, a key member of Jeff Capel’s coaching staff is receiving head coaching interest.
Multiple sources tell the Post-Gazette that associate coach Tim O’Toole is a candidate for at least one head coach opening — Manhattan College of the Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference (MAAC). Manhattan athletics confirmed to the Post-Gazette last week that O’Toole has applied for the head coach opening.
Former Jaspers head coach Steve Masiello, who served at the program’s helm for 11 years, left Manhattan just two weeks prior to the start of the 2022-23 season. The Jaspers finished with an overall record of 12-18 this year under interim head coach RaShawn Stores.
Numerous members within the Pitt basketball program have expressed O’Toole’s importance throughout the team’s rise from ACC bottom-dweller to NCAA tournament participant, citing his significant role not only in the staff’s success through the transfer portal and recruiting but also in helping establish the unified connection the 2022-23 Panthers displayed this season.
“Coach O’Toole plays a huge role in this whole program,” Pitt point guard Nelly Cummings told the Post-Gazette. “He’s an energy guy. He’s a guy you can always look to for an uplift whenever you need it. He’s played a big part in all the success we’ve had this season.”
Prior to coming to Pitt in 2018, O’Toole’s resume includes stops as an assistant at California, Stanford, Seton Hall, Duke, Syracuse, Iona, Army and Fordham. He is the only coach in college basketball history to serve as an assistant under both Mike Krzyzewski and Jim Boeheim. In 2013, O’Toole held the role of director of basketball operations at Syracuse, helping the Orange reach the Final Four.
Read More
O’Toole’s lone stint as a head coach took place from 1998 to 2006 at his alma mater, Fairfield. In his eight years with the program, O’Toole compiled a record of 112-120, earning MAAC Coach of the Year honors in 2004. The year prior, O’Toole took his team to the NIT, following an appearance in the league’s tournament championship game.
Although O’Toole was unavailable for comment when requested, a Pitt basketball spokesperson confirmed to the Post-Gazette that the 59-year-old O’Toole does have interest in being a head coach once again, should the right opportunity arise. Those within the program believe any team would be lucky to have him.
“Definitely, if his heart desires,” Pitt guard Jamarius Burton told the Post-Gazette. “He’s the oldest guy on our staff, so it depends on what he wants to do, as far as he and his family are concerned. But I could definitely see him being a head coach again because of his passion and commitment to this game.”
A source told the Post-Gazette that O’Toole had also received a call from Wisconsin-Green Bay about its head coach opening. However, Green Bay announced last week it had hired Sundance Wicks, a former assistant at Wyoming, to fill that vacant position.
Noah Hiles: nhiles@post-gazette.com and Twitter @_NoahHiles. Pitt reporter Christopher Carter contributed to this report.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.