Jordan Addison’s reported plan to transfer from Pitt to Southern California has roiled college football fans far beyond the confines of Western Pennsylvania.
Social media was awash in with concern late Friday into Saturday that a name, image and likeness deal — reportedly worth millions — has attracted the Frederick, Md., native away from the school where he won the Biletnikoff Award as the nation’s top receiver and helped lead his team to an ACC championship just five short months ago.
Experts and fans alike fear the move signals a paradigm shift that will allow the sport’s richest programs to simply buy the best players from their opponents by ponying up the necessary cash in NIL deals.
That would be a massive shift from the way the sport has done business for more than a century. And even advocates for new NIL laws that allow players to profit from their public profile have concerns about the way current rules can impact competitive balance. SiriusXM and CBS personalist Danny Kanell was chief among them.
Jordan Addison is most likely going to USC to take the $$$ that USC and Lincoln are bringing to the table. This is AWFUL for CFB. I'm all for NIL but there has to be some protection/regulation/opportunity for Pitt to match the offer and keep the player they developed.
— Danny Kanell (@dannykanell) April 30, 2022
Others speculate that the deal could not have been completed without some level of tampering. Under current NCAA transfer rules, programs are not supposed to be able to contact players under scholarship from other programs unless and until they formally enter the transfer portal.
As of Saturday morning, Addison had not taken that step, leading many to question how he could have lined up such a deal to head to Los Angeles legitimately.
Read More
Jordan Addison transferring to USC for a large NIL deal is a gut punch to College Football. Definite tampering going on. Leadership at the top is needed now more than ever.
— Big Game Boomer (@BigGameBoomer) April 30, 2022
The strangest thing to me about the Jordan Addison situation is that somehow everybody is able to report that he’s considering transferring to USC despite not even being in the portal yet.
— Tom Fornelli (@TomFornelli) April 30, 2022
Saban is right. The current status of college football is not sustainable. It’s too chaotic and lacks the structure needed for fair competition.
— Ralph D. Russo (@ralphDrussoAP) April 30, 2022
It will change and become more orderly.
We are living through evolution because nobody in charge got out ahead of what was inevitable.
The biggest firestorm generated by the news could be found on Reddit. As of Saturday morning, fans from across the country had commented more than 760 times on a thread on the popular r/CFB subreddit about the reported move. And the reaction was overwhelmingly negative among more than just Pitt fans.
“It kind of takes all the romanticism out of college football for me,” Michigan fan Lucky-view wrote. “It feels like watching European Soccer or something with the completely unregulated compensation and basically free agency. I support player empowerment, but this all feels so hollow.”
“The free transfer rule has to go,” added Oklahoma fan OU_DHF. “It was alright without NIL, but you can’t have both. And NIL is obviously going nowhere.”
The Panthers’ cause even found support among fans of West Virginia, their fiercest rival.
“On one hand, ha. On the other, this sport is ruined,” wrote user conchobor under his Mountaineers flair.
Let’s not overlook Pitt fans themselves, though. They were the most upset by the news for obvious reasons and compared the move to that of basketball player Cam Johnson from the Panthers to North Carolina a few years ago.
This whole Jordan Addison transferring to USC thing is everything wrong with college sports right now
— Brian Miller (@bdmiller95) April 30, 2022
I don't even blame Jordan Addison one bit. If it's a massive NIL deal then what's he and his family supposed to do? But college football has some massive problems heading its way, and this is really just the beginning.
— ForTheCity_412 (@JimStamm22) April 30, 2022
The 11 win ACC Conference Champ did basically everything right to keep Jordan Addison in the fold and to set him up for a fantastic last year before going to the NFL including getting one of the top transfer QBs AND NIL deals.
— JD (@Sta7ic) April 30, 2022
Top 5 program comes in with bags & it doesn't matter https://t.co/mqCSah8AoB
I don't claim Jordan Addison as a Panther, i don't care if I'm being harsh he's an absolute traitor who ruined his legacy in my book i do not care
— Yinzburgh Adam (@yinzburghsports) April 30, 2022
Me when I realize I don't have 2 million dollars to keep Jordan Addison at Pitt pic.twitter.com/PaM2b4nDHV
— Morgan Kenny Pickett Superfan. (@mport25) April 30, 2022
Jordan Addison to USC. Good for Addison to get his money like that, but I’m not really sure how that’s not tampering. I don’t understand the NIL I guess.
— Pitt Coverage (@PittCoverage) April 30, 2022
To reiterate, nothing is official at the time of this writing. Addison could still back out of the deal and remain at Pitt, where he caught 100 passes for 1,593 yards and 17 touchdowns in 2021.
But many seem to feel the conclusion is obvious: Pat Narduzzi’s team will lose its best player for cold, hard cash. And there’s little anyone can do to stop it.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.