BROOKLYN, N.Y. — Shortly after his Pitt team’s 2021-22 season was ended by a 20-point loss to Boston College in the first round of the ACC tournament Tuesday, Jeff Capel lamented about what could have been.

Over the course of 32 games, he saw glimpses of what the Panthers could be at their best, but they didn’t do so consistently enough, the kind of trait that separates bad teams from mediocre ones. Why, exactly, did those alluring peeks not translate into something more lasting?

After Capel touched on a handful of factors that contribute to it, he got to the heart of the issue.

“We have to get better players,” he said. “I mean, that's the reality of it. It's not anything personal. We have to continue to add better players. We have to recruit better. All those things we have to do better. We have to continue to develop guys. We have to continue to help them reach their potential as players. Those are things that we have to continue to do.”

Advertise with us

The words would seem more biting if they weren’t true.

Capel’s fourth team in his tenure at the university was his least talented, a group short on many of the most critical elements for success in college basketball — shot creators, shot makers, strong one-on-one defenders and speedy dribble penetrators, among a slew of other things. Just five players averaged more than 3.4 points per game. Among 358 Division I teams, the Panthers were 282nd in 3-point percentage and 308th in 2-point percentage. In a historically weak ACC, they had the worst offense and third-worst defense, as measured by KenPom.com’s efficiency numbers.

There is, of course, a certain irony in Capel publicly acknowledging his team’s dearth of talent. Unlike their professional counterparts, who work in tandem with front offices and executives, college coaches have much more autonomy in determining whom it is they coach. Ultimately, Capel is the man who assembled the roster, who scouted, evaluated and offered scholarships to the players who, as a group, posted the second-worst single-season win percentage at Pitt since 1977.

The end of another forgettable season for a program getting increasingly accustomed to them raises questions about what comes next.

They’ll have at least two scholarships with which to work, with Mouhamadou Gueye and Onyebuchi Ezeakudo departing. Gueye’s absence in particular will be felt. The graduate transfer from Stony Brook made a pronounced impact in his lone season with the program, averaging 9.8 points, 6.8 rebounds and 2.1 blocks per game while regularly proving himself as Pitt’s best defensive player. By almost any measurement he was, at worst, the team’s second-best player.

Advertise with us

“I love the kid,” Capel said. “I wish we had him longer because you saw how much he's gotten better. He's an amazing kid to be around. He's a worker. Keeps his head down, comes into work every day. He's eager to learn, a really good listener. Takes constructive criticism, takes feedback, seeks it out. And he got better and better as the season went along.”

Gueye’s departure creates at least one glaring hole heading into next season. While finding a replacement for everything Gueye did will be next to impossible with a single player, the Panthers will need a starting-level power forward to play alongside star sophomore big man John Hugley, should he return. They’ll need a point guard, too, as sophomore Femi Odukale struggled as the team’s primary ball-handler, turning the ball over too often and not exhibiting the kind of speed needed to consistently beat defenders off the dribble. With only one returning player who shot better than 33% from 3 last season, at least another reliable shooter or two would be pivotal.

When asked Tuesday what areas of his roster need the most improvement this offseason, Capel said “every area.”

With no high school recruits committed or signed to Pitt in the 2022 class, and with the number of viable options dwindling at this late point in the recruiting calendar, it’s likely that the majority of Pitt’s additions for next season will come from the transfer portal, where they landed Gueye and guard Jamarius Burton in what proved to be a busier offseason than originally anticipated.

“Teams can drastically change if you are able to get the right guys,” Capel said. “In some cases you get lucky…You have to be able to develop. You have to be able to get the right pieces.”

Advertise with us

Then there’s what has been the biggest challenge of Capel’s four-year tenure — not recruiting talented players, but keeping them. Transfers affect any Division I program, but they’ve hit Capel’s in obvious, hurtful ways. After his second season in 2019-20, two of his top five scorers transferred. Before last season even ended, Xavier Johnson and Au’Diese Toney entered the portal. When Abdoul Karim Coulibaly followed suit a month later, the Panthers had lost three of their five starters.

In theory, Capel could have had Toney, a starter on a top-15 Arkansas team, Johnson, the No. 2 scorer and assist leader on an Indiana team on the NCAA tournament bubble, and Trey McGowens, a starter on Nebraska, on his current roster, a trio of players that would have perhaps had Pitt in the postseason. Instead, he had a group that was at a talent and depth disadvantage in the vast majority of ACC games it played.

Holding on to the best players he does have will be imperative for Capel this year. Hugley in particular is a piece he can’t afford to lose, a stocky and skilled forward who led the team in scoring and rebounding this season while earning all-ACC honorable mention recognition. With the proper development, he could be one of the best big men in the ACC, if not the country, next season.

“Having a guy like John to build off of is something that’s really, really important,” Capel said. “I think we have an elite big guy I think will be exciting for people to want to play with. I think we’ve helped some guys get better. Certainly Justin Champagnie is an example of that. Mo Gueye is an example of that. You look at Jamarius Burton. He had his best year in college basketball here. I think we’ve shown some development with that. But you have to continue to add the right pieces and we have to develop the guys we have.”

It’s not just Hugley, either. In Burton, Odukale and Ithiel Horton, the Panthers have three players who averaged at least 9.8 points per game last season. Along with guard Nike Sibande, who missed the entirety of the season with an ACL tear, they have a five-player starting point from which they can add the depth and talent it lacked in 2021-22.

Advertise with us

It will require a level of consistency from Pitt that hasn’t been seen for much of Capel’s tenure — and not from the players, but their coach.

“I don’t know,” Capel said when asked how much confidence he has that all of his key pieces will be back next season. “I don’t think anyone ever knows. There are so many factors now that go into these things. It’s not just about playing time anymore. …We’ll see. Honestly, I haven’t really thought about it that much. But we’ll see going forward. I think that’s going to be the case at most places.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG