Each week during the 2021-22 season, Craig Meyer, the Post-Gazette’s Pitt basketball writer, will answer fan and reader questions about the Panthers. And some other stuff, too.
If you want to submit a question, you can email Craig at cmeyer@post-gazette.com or hit him up on Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.
Ethan: Who would be your starting five of the Jeff Capel era?
Craig: I guess we are at the point in Capel’s tenure where we can start to do these kinds of exercises. In some ways, his introductory press conference doesn’t seem all that long ago, but in others ... whew, it really does.
Xavier Johnson, guard: Probably one of the more polarizing Pitt players in recent memory, but he’s an easy call at point guard. He finished among the top 50 Division I players in assist rate in each of his three years at the school. It really seemed for a minute after his freshman year that he could be a Brandin Knight-like figure for a reborn program.
Au’Diese Toney, guard: A versatile and tough-minded defender who got better offensively in each of his three years at the school. Probably Capel’s biggest loss as far as players who transferred out.
Read More
Jared Wilson-Frame, guard: The only player on here Capel didn’t recruit and still, by a solid margin, the best shooter Capel has had in his time here. A good argument could be made for him being one of the more underrated Pitt players of the past eight or 10 years.
Justin Champagnie, forward: The best player of Capel’s tenure, no question.
John Hugley, forward: It’s early in his time at Pitt, but the bar for this spot in the lineup also isn’t especially high. Still, Hugley could very well finish his career as the Panthers’ best big man in more than a decade.
John: It appears Johnson, McGowens and Toney were all selfish players. Did Capel make any pleas or guarantees to at least keep one in the program and build around them while making the assumption Champagne was leaving?
Craig: I wouldn’t necessarily say those three were all selfish players. Was there some jealousy and internal friction within the team? Absolutely. The inherent problem was that those three players were brought in to rejuvenate a roster short on talent and, from virtually their first game, were three of the team’s four best players. They emerged from that first season with the belief that they would be the faces of the program and when other — and, in Champagnie’s case, better — players came in, it created some of those feelings I mentioned earlier. I don’t think it was much jealousy with each other as Johnson, Toney and McGowens have remained good friends, though for McGowens, part of his decision to transfer had to do with wanting to play point guard more, which wasn’t going to happen at Pitt with Johnson.
It would have been hard to make a guarantee of any kind to one of those players. Altercations between players had been breaking out or threatening to break out late last season, and once it came to a head, Johnson and Toney transferred out. It had become untenable. Could Capel have basically begged with them, ‘Hey guys, for my own sake, get through these next two weeks and then that’s it?’ As a way to make sure he didn’t lose Toney and Johnson, knowing that Champagnie was likely going pro? I guess, but that’s something that’s much easier said than done.
Tristan: Has Pitt Basketball somehow become a “second half team” this season?
Craig: It certainly seems that way of late, right? And the stats definitely back it up. In Pitt’s past seven games, a stretch in which it has gone 3-4, it has been outscored by a 240-156 margin in the first half and has outscored opponents 284-243 in the second half. In the first half of those games, it has scored 156 points on 221 possessions (0.706 points per possession) while scoring 284 points on 222 possessions in the second half (1.279 points per possession). For a Panthers team that averages 64 possessions per game, that’s the difference between 45 and 82 points in a game. It’s pretty drastic.
Part of that disparity is tied to Pitt falling behind by so much in the first half that it becomes much easier to score in a second half where the final result is never really in doubt. But over the past month, the Panthers have been undeniably better in the second half. While it’s unrealistic to expect them to keep up those ridiculous second-half numbers over the course of an entire game, they also shouldn’t be nearly as bad as they have been to start these matchups.
DC Pitt Fan: Why can’t Capel recruit? I know he’s had some bad breaks with guys, but when they hired him he was supposed to be a fantastic recruiter. He was apparently great at Duke and even signed McDonald’s all Americans at Oklahoma. Why has he struggled at Pitt?
Craig: I wouldn’t say that he can’t recruit. He brought in two top-35 classes, as ranked by 247 Sports, in his first three seasons, the second of which was a top-25 class with two top-100 recruits. At least one of those top-100 recruits, William Jeffress, hasn’t looked the part thus far, but it was still an impressive commitment at the time.
The reality is that he was never going to bring the kind of recruiting classes to Pitt that he helped land at Duke, which I think all but a few delusional fans understood when the hire was made. I get the frustration, though. He had only one high-school recruit in the last class — Nate Santos, a three-star prospect — and doesn’t have anyone lined up for the 2022 class, which I would expect to be transfer-heavy. In his four years here, he has come up short on a slew of top-100 or top–50 targets, some of whom went on to stardom (or at least productive careers) elsewhere. He has another top-100 recruit on the way in Marlon Barnes for 2023, but when you’re going through the kind of spell Pitt has in 2021 and 2022, it’s understandable to be vexed.
Jayselia: Hey Craig, how good do you think Kedon Slovis will be this season ? He’s playing with a new team, new OC, what are realistic expectations for him ?
Craig: There are a lot of variables, as you mentioned, that make it difficult to predict exactly how he’ll do, but I see it going well. Before what was kind of a lost season with a lame-duck coach last year, Slovis threw for 47 touchdowns and 16 interceptions in his first two seasons while completing 70% of his passes. He’s a much more productive and proven player than Max Browne, the last USC transfer quarterback Pitt brought in.
It would be unfair to hold him up to the standard of the quarterback he’s succeeding, but I think high expectations are justifiable for Slovis, especially with the skill-position talent he’ll have around him.
Kevin: What are ur anticipations for Pitt’s ground game next year under Coach Cignetti given his track record do you think it’ll be Izzy as the feature or more of a “division of labor”?
Craig: I think it depends in part on the progression of someone like Rodney Hammond, who looked great most of last year. Cignetti has a reputation of getting the ball in the hands of his best, most effective offensive weapons, so I doubt we’ll see carries apportioned in the same way they were the previous few years, which could seem gratuitous at times. But I think Abanikanda will be going into next season as the favorite to be the No. 1 back.
It’s also worth it to look at the percentage of carries the top back got at some of Cignetti’s past stops as offensive coordinator.
Boston College, 2021: 43.2%
Boston College, 2020: 35.2%
St. Louis Rams, 2015: 53.4%
Rutgers, 2011: 50.1%
Pitt, 2010: 46.6%
Pitt, 2009: 67.8%
Last season, Pitt’s leader in carries, Vincent Davis (oddly enough), got 27% of the team’s carries.
Chick: What’s your thoughts on a TBT or NBA Summer League type tourney for current ncaa mens/womens rosters? Since recruiting and transferring is completely different from years past, I don’t see how teams can build chemistry and develop if they can’t play beyond the reg season.
Craig: I like the idea. I’m always down for more basketball and I think it has the potential to be fun. In the age of NIL, it could be an opportunity for some of these players to get paid, too, which would be great.
Another idea I like, which was proposed by Pittsburgh native Tom Droney, a former player at Davidson: a transfer portal showcase to be held after the season, which he argued would give coaches a chance to properly evaluate potential new additions and give players a chance to show themselves off to suitors.
Corey: What are your top 5 SB halftime shows in the last decade?
Craig: This isn’t just recency bias — this year was my favorite, especially with it happening in LA, where most of the artists are from.
Here’s the order I’ll go with:
1. Dr. Dre, Snoop, Kendrick Lamar, Mary J. Blige, Eminem (2022)
2. J Lo and Shakira (2020)
3. Katy Perry (2015)
4. The Weeknd (2021)
5. Justin Timberlake (2018)
I missed most of the 2016 Panthers-Broncos Super Bowl, so I didn’t see the Coldplay-Beyonce performance, which I heard was great. The Bruno Mars one was decent, but for as undeniably talented as he is, I find his music remarkably boring. Lady Gaga’s was good. Maroon 5 can kick rocks.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.