Behind the Fitzgerald Field House bleachers, Cole Matthews sat on a training table, adjusting the brace that supports his recovered right knee. Moments after securing a major decision against Virginia, the 141-pound wrestler was asked for autographs. He told his young fans not to go anywhere, that he’d sign whatever they had in a minute.

Matthews, the 15th-ranked wrestler nationally in his weight class and, in a lot of ways, the calming presence of Pitt’s program, refocused.

“If I could describe myself as a song, I think it would be ‘Fast Car’ by Tracy Chapman,” Matthews said last week, cracking a smile. Matthews acknowledged that his walk-out song before hitting the mat — the raw, melodic hit from 1988 — is different from what you might hear ahead of other bouts. “It’s more my speed.”

In reality, it’s exactly Matthews’ speed. Sure, he gets into some wild scrambles. Teammate and friend Jake Wentzel called him “one of the most exciting wrestlers to watch in the NCAA.” But it’s Matthews’ relaxed belief and natural feeling that he can, in Chapman’s words, “be someone” that makes him one of the best in the sport.

Advertise with us

“I never want him to change that song. That is Cole Matthews,” Wentzel said. “He goes out there with a straight face, and he kills you. He shows no emotion.”

“Some people need to be ramped up,” Pitt head coach Keith Gavin added. “Cole just needs to be locked in.”

Matthews has been locked in since he arrived from Reynolds High School in 2018. But this season especially, after suffering and competing through a torn ACL last year, the Greenville native has showcased both the self-assurance and skill that has him poised for a run at an ACC title, All-American status and maybe even more.

Competition is stiff at 141 pounds. Penn State’s Nick Lee, the reigning national champion and top-ranked wrestler in Matthews’ weight class, is a fifth-year senior. Iowa’s Jaydin Eierman and Rutgers’ Sebastian Rivera, the second- and third-ranked wrestlers at 141, are sixth-year seniors. In the ACC, North Carolina’s Kizhan Clarke and N.C. State’s Ryan Jack are ranked fifth and 14th, respectively.

But Matthews is 11-2. He beat Michigan’s Stevan Micic earlier this month, putting the Serbian Olympian, ranked fourth in the country by InterMat, on his back. A week later, Matthews sparked his team’s upset of sixth-ranked Arizona State. His only losses are to Penn’s CJ Composto (16th nationally) and Ohio State’s Dylan D’Emilio (17th) — and those were within a month of Matthews’ return from rehabbing his right knee.

Advertise with us

Matthews unknowingly tore his ACL and meniscus against Virginia on Jan. 29, 2021. He was hobbled for a few days, limping around Fitzgerald Field House. But Matthews felt fine enough to wrestle against North Carolina the following weekend. It wasn’t until Feb. 9, his birthday, that Matthews found out the severity of his injury from Pitt’s team physician, Dr. Jeanne Doperak.

“She had this sad face. She tells me it’s a torn ACL, and I’m like, ‘You’re gonna make me cry,’” Matthews recalled. “I was like, ‘Why are you looking at me like that? It’s not like we’re not gonna wrestle with it.’”

“Our trainer brought me and Cole out from practice. He had already talked to Cole, but he wanted to tell me,” Gavin said. “Before I said anything, Cole said, ‘I want to keep wrestling throughout the season. I feel like I can do it.’ ... That was that.”

Pitt had one meet, at fourth-ranked Virginia Tech, before the ACC tournament. Matthews claims he was unbothered by the torn knee, winning in Blacksburg and later finishing third at ACCs — securing a spot at the NCAA championships. In St. Louis, he beat Rider’s McKenzie Bell before losing to Iowa’s Eierman in a thrilling 5-3 decision.

That experience, pushing the eventual national runner-up to the brink, was a confidence boost for both Matthews and Pitt’s coaching staff. Gavin always knew that Matthews, the first wrestler he recruited upon arrival, was talented.

Advertise with us

“But, man,” Gavin said, shaking his head. “It was like, ‘If I can do this with an unhealthy knee, then what can I do with two healthy ones?’”

Admittedly, Matthews’ 2021-22 expectations were lower in the preseason than they are currently. He didn’t know how his knee would react after undergoing surgery and, essentially, taking seven months off from the sport. Wrestling, as Gavin pointed out, isn’t like other sports where you can only run so fast or jump so high. “You’re always adding to your skill set,” the coach said, and Matthews wasn’t able to this offseason.

Even still, Matthews believed entering this season that he could finish in the top eight at the NCAA championships and become an All-American. Now? After putting in the work, seeing it bear fruit and quietly growing in confidence, Matthews has new goals.

It’s not like him to shout them from the rooftops. He’s still calm and collected, comfortable enough in his own process that he doesn’t need to show off or celebrate wins. But Matthews does consider himself one of the best wrestlers in the country and a contender at NCAAs in March. And he’s not the only one, either.

“It’s not far-fetched to say I can win the tournament,” Matthews said. “I’m competing at a high level right now. If I put together a good tournament, I could win it. I’m sure everyone has their opinions on that. But they don’t know what my progression is, what I do throughout the week and how I’m competing. I don’t push myself to be overly confident. I don’t want to be someone I’m not. But it’s just who I am.”

Advertise with us

“We know how good he is. He knows what he can do,” Gavin said. “He’s in a very good weight class that’s very deep. He’s going to be in a lot of battles. But there’s no reason for him to not believe that he can beat anybody. And that’s how we feel, as well.”

Johnny McGonigal: jmcgonigal@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jmcgonigal9