Ithiel Horton walked out of the double doors of Courtroom Two inside the Pittsburgh Municipal Court building Wednesday, leaving his legal woes behind him.

There wasn’t much the Pitt men’s basketball junior guard wanted to say after a felony aggravated assault charge was dropped as part of a negotiated plea during his preliminary hearing, clearing the path for him to return to the team he had been away from for the better part of the past three months. With the few words he did say, there was a palpable sense of relief and optimism.

“I’m just happy to get back to playing, get back with the team and hopefully help us win more games,” Horton said.

He speaks for more than just himself. Though not a superstar that fundamentally changes the complexion and outlook of his team, Horton’s return to the Pitt roster gives it a much-needed boost as it heads into the final 11 games of the regular season, beginning with a matchup Saturday against Boston College.

Advertise with us

At least offensively, Horton gives the Panthers skills and traits they’ve been so obviously missing for much of the season.

For one, Pitt will get another scorer. As a sophomore last season, Horton averaged 8.9 points per game, making him the team’s leading returning scorer heading into this season. He finished in double figures in 10 of the 22 games in which he appeared in 2020-21, including nine times in 17 ACC contests.

A player consistently putting the ball in the basket is so seemingly simple — it is the point of the sport, after all — but given where the Panthers stood without Horton, it can’t be overlooked. Without Horton, Pitt was dangerously thin on scorers, with only four eligible players averaging more than 4.2 points per game this season. If one of that quartet of John Hugley, Jamarius Burton, Femi Odukale and Mouhamadou Gueye had an off night, the results were disastrous, like when Gueye was held to three points in a 75-48 loss at Clemson last Saturday. It took a career-high 11 points from guard Onyebuchi Ezeakudo, nine points above his season average, to overcome a season-low two points from Odukale and beat a listless Syracuse team, 64-53, earlier this week. While still far from an offensive juggernaut, Pitt no longer always has to roll out lineups in which one of the players isn’t a threat to score.

Then there’s what Horton does best, which happened to be Pitt’s most glaring offensive weakness without him — 3-point shooting. The 6-foot-5 guard made 37.1% of his 3s last season and is a 39.8% shooter from beyond the arc in his college career. In his lone appearance this season, he scored 13 points and connected on three of his five 3s in a 75-72 loss at Louisville on Jan. 5. Without Horton, the Panthers had just one player with more than one attempt this season shooting better than 34.5% — and that player, Ezeakudo, attempts just 1.6 3s per game.

Horton was a streaky shooter last season — shooting lights out for several games in a row only to go ice cold or be invisible over the next several contests — but unlike so many of his teammates, he at least poses a threat to score from beyond the arc. The effect that can have on how teams defend Pitt could be significant.

Advertise with us

With no viable outside shooters, opposing defenses were able to key in on Hugley, double- and sometimes even triple-teaming the Pitt big man, who’s averaging a team-high 15.6 points and 8.6 rebounds per game this season. Not every team employs a zone like Syracuse’s, but just look at what the Orange did to him at times on Tuesday night.

With Hugley in the middle of a four-out offense the Panthers often utilize, and with his abilities as a passer out of the low post, they had the makings of a solid offensive strategy if players could knock down shots from long distance with some frequency. If a defense collapsed on Hugley, he could kick it out to an open teammate. The problem was, without such shooters, opposing teams could reliably and routinely overwhelm Hugley without having to fear the consequences of doing so.

Horton gives the team at least one option to find in those scenarios, something that can keep defenses honest on Hugley, stretch the defense out a bit or give the 6-foot-9, 270-pound big man the kind of one-on-one matchups he desires. Though they only played about 13 minutes together due to early foul trouble for Hugley, the Louisville loss provided some idea of what the Panthers offense could ideally look like with Horton back in the fold.

In those minutes they played together, the Panthers scored 26 points on 21 possessions, an average of 1.238 points per possession that’s well above their season average of 0.998. That night, Pitt scored a season-high 1.143 points per possession. Even when Hugley wasn’t on the court, elements of its offense that don’t work as seamlessly without Horton worked well with him, like skip passes from Burton that led to points.

It takes a burden off Hugley, as well, whom Capel has helped to understand that he can impact a game without scoring. He praised the sophomore forward after the Syracuse win for turning in one of his best games of the season despite scoring about five points below his season average.

Advertise with us

“It’s difficult for anyone that’s used to scoring,” Capel said Tuesday. “It’s an adjustment. So many of these young people — and I was probably like them when I was their age — you base everything on scoring. Normally when you talk to people, your family and friends or whatever, it’s, ‘Hey, how’d you play? How many points did you score?’ It’s normally the first question. So many people place value on that. The people that know basketball and understand it understand that there are so many different ways you can affect the game. For him, it’s an opportunity to learn and to grow. He impacted the game at such a significant level and he has the opportunity to do that.”

If the Louisville game from early January is any indication, Horton will only be eased into competition so gradually. In that contest, he came off the bench to play 28 minutes. He understandably wore down as the game went on, going scoreless in the second half and looking fatigued after about seven minutes on the court in the first half.

“I expect him to be in pretty decent shape because he’s a worker,” Capel said Thursday in his weekly appearance on The Fan Morning Show. “I know he’s been working. I know he’s been in the gym. We’ll throw him right back out there. There’s no minute restriction, but it’s something we’ll gauge as practice goes on and games go on. Hopefully now, he’ll be able to get into a better rhythm than he was just the one game he played last time. Hopefully this is behind him and we’ll have him throughout the rest of the year and he can get into a better rhythm offensively and defensively. But it’s tough.”

Horton’s reinstatement wasn’t the only positive development for Pitt in a week in which senior guard Nike Sibande, who is out for the season with a torn ACL he suffered on Nov. 1, said on Capel’s weekly radio show on 93.7 The Fan that he will be returning to the program next season. With him, an offensively limited team will have yet another scoring it has plainly missed in its first 20 games.

For what remains of this season, though, the Panthers will be plenty thankful to have even just one previously absent scorer back.

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG