ATLANTA — The narrative surrounding Pitt's trip to the Peach Bowl was all about the guy who wasn't playing. Kenny Pickett, a Heisman Trophy finalist and projected first-round draft pick, opted out. He sat in the Mercedes-Benz Stadium coaches' box with a hat on backwards and a headset on, out of sight and out of mind.

Frankly, it was odd for Pickett, someone so central to Pitt's sensational season, to not be on the field. But for all that Pickett did in 2021 — throwing 42 touchdowns, breaking Dan Marino's records and guiding the Panthers to an ACC championship — this year's Pitt team was always carried by more than No. 8.

Pitt proved that. Without Pickett (and for the majority of the night, Nick Patti) the Panthers nearly pulled off a New Year's Six win. But Pitt lost to Michigan State, 31-21, in the Peach Bowl on Thursday in Atlanta. The Panthers go home with an 11-3 record, one win shy of becoming the second 12-win team in program history.

"Obviously not the way we wanted to finish up the season," head coach Pat Narduzzi said. "It's never easy. Kids played their tails off. Didn't give up at all. ... But not the way you wanted your seniors to go out."

Advertise with us

"It's tough. We had a great season. We won the ACC championship, which was really our goal," super senior linebacker Phil Campbell added. "But we would have obviously liked to finish it much better."

The loss was a difficult reality for Campbell and his teammates to reckon with. It wasn't just that the loss happened, but how.

The Panthers surrendered an 11-point lead in the fourth quarter. Michigan State drove 70 yards on 13 plays and found the end zone to cut Pitt's advantage with eight minutes to go. The offense, called by interim offensive coordinator Tim Salem and operated by third-string quarterback Davis Beville after Patti sustained a broken collarbone, couldn't kill clock. The Spartans scored on their ensuing drive, capping an 11-play, 71-yard drive with a 22-yard reception by the bowl's offensive MVP, wide receiver Jayden Reed.

Pitt's advantage evaporated like that, and the Spartans led 24-21 with 2:51 remaining.

Beville tried to mount a comeback, but fell short. With the clock moving below a minute, Beville pushed Pitt down to Michigan State's 26-yard line. A Sam Scarton field goal would have tied it. But Beville's next pass was read perfectly and picked off. Linebacker (and defensive MVP) Cal Haladay returned it to the house, leaving Pitt's players at a loss.

Advertise with us

"This team means everything to me. Definitely disappointed to let those guys down," Beville said. "We missed some plays here and there. I'm obviously guilty of that. But my team's great. ... I've got their back, and they've got mine."

That was the mentality, Campbell said, when Patti — Pickett's backup making his second career start — went down in the first quarter. Patti's dive to the pylon on Pitt's second drive resulted in a 16-yard touchdown. But the fourth-year player who bided his time for a night like Thursday came up injured holding his left shoulder. Patti went to the medical tent, then the locker room and emerged with his arm in a left sling.

Beville played the remainder of the game. Overall, he wasn't asked to do much. He was sacked five times and completed 14 of 18 passes for 149 yards. More than a third of those yards came on an electric 52-yard catch-and-run by Biletnikoff Award winner Jordan Addison. The ESPN broadcast noted that Salem said the team's play sheet "shrinks dramatically" with Beville at quarterback, and it showed.

Pitt's defense had to step up. And given the circumstances, its effort was admirable.

The Panthers forced two turnovers, including a Cam Bright scoop-and-score to open the second half. The Panthers harassed Michigan State quarterback Payton Thorne all night. Without Doak Walker Award winner and opt-out Kenneth Walker III, Michigan State was limited to 56 rushing yards on 36 attempts. After surrendering 10 points on its opening two drives, Pitt held the Spartans scoreless on eight consecutive series.

Advertise with us

Ultimately, though, Michigan State's last two drives were the ones that mattered most. Those will be the lasting memories of Thursday's Peach Bowl.

But as Campbell and fellow senior Johnny Petrishen noted, they won't be the lasting images of Pitt's season. This 2021 team is only the fourth in Pitt history to record 11 wins. It captured the program's first conference championship. And even with Pickett and others moving on, it has pieces to build around in 2022.

"We got a lot coming back. We'll start the work tomorrow towards an ACC championship for next year. That's the goal. That's the standard that we have," Narduzzi said. "It's not easy. But that's the ballgame. We haven't lost for a while. Our kids have a lot of confidence. So it hurts. They're hurting. They're frustrated. A lot of tears in that locker room. They care and they fought.

"... I love every one of those guys in there. They fought their tails off. I'd go to war with them any day. There's never been any quit. It takes years to get what we got. We got a championship now. Now we have to try for a repeat."

Johnny McGonigal: jmcgonigal@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jmcgonigal9