Johnny Petrishen, after taking a moment to himself on Pitt’s podium, rejoined his teammates on the confetti-covered turf of Bank of America Stadium. Then, the seventh-year senior linebacker walked to the Panthers’ locker room where he held the ACC championship trophy and posed for photos.

Five years earlier, almost to the day, Petrishen did the exact same thing in Indianapolis. The Central Catholic graduate, a safety at Penn State at the time, was at Lucas Oil Stadium when the Nittany Lions captured a Big Ten title with a win over Wisconsin.

Petrishen was injured and didn’t play in that game in 2016. But he has photos and memories of that experience in Indianapolis. Now, he has the same from Charlotte.

“It’s surreal, man,” Petrishen, who transferred from Penn State to Pitt ahead of the 2019 season, told the Post-Gazette amid Saturday’s on-field celebrations. “I’m so happy for Pittsburgh, the city and the university. It’s been long overdue. And I think it’s going to be the start of something long-term. There’s really something special here.”

Advertise with us

By all accounts — from capturing an ACC title to winning 11 games to Kenny Pickett becoming a Heisman Trophy finalist — 2021 has been special for Pitt. And perhaps this conference title is something it can build on with the ever-changing landscape of the ACC and college football.

But it’s interesting (and fun) to look at Pitt’s ACC championship and Penn State’s 2016 Big Ten title through the lens of what could have been — and what could be in the future — with the College Football Playoff. No, we’re not here to play revisionist history and ask, “What if Pitt beat Western Michigan?” Without knowing how Pitt would play if that result went differently, that’s a cruel and fruitless exercise.

Instead, let’s consider the proposed 12-team playoff expansion and the reality that if it was in effect this year, Pitt would have a chance at a national championship.

Of course, the June proposal by a CFP working group — SEC commissioner Greg Sankey, the Big 12’s Bob Bowlsby, the Mountain West’s Craig Thompson and Notre Dame athletic director Jack Swarbrick — never would have been implemented in time for the 2021 season.

But if the “6 plus 6” proposal — six highest-ranked conference champions and six at-large bids get in with the top four guaranteed conference champs — was around this year, Pitt would be the No. 12 seed. The Panthers would face the No. 5 seed Georgia for a spot in the quarterfinals against No. 4 Baylor.

Advertise with us

In 2016, the Nittany Lions would have been the No. 4 seed with a bye. They would have faced the winner of P.J. Fleck’s Western Michigan or Ohio State, a team Penn State narrowly beat earlier in the season.

Neither of those are easy paths for Pitt or Penn State. But it would be enthralling to see Pickett play against Georgia’s heralded defense that was picked apart by fellow Heisman finalist Bryce Young. And it would have been exciting to see how far Penn State could ride the magic of Saquon Barkley, Trace McSorley and Joe Moorhead.

But alas. The playoff is still four teams as Alabama and Michigan prepare over the coming weeks to square off against Cincinnati and Georgia, respectively. And it doesn’t appear a 12-team format is coming any time soon.

ACC commissioner Jim Phillips, as well as the Big Ten’s Kevin Warren and Pac-12’s George Kliavkoff, raised concerns over the summer about the working group’s process to get to a 12-team proposal. Those concerns reportedly intensified after Oklahoma and Texas’ shock move to the SEC, which has put negotiations seemingly at a standstill.

As recently as Tuesday, Phillips told Sports Illustrated that the ACC is in no rush for expansion. Last week, Sports Illustrated also reported that the ACC, as well as the Big Ten and Pac-12, are against the “6 plus 6” proposal and support either an eight-team model or a different 12-team format.

Advertise with us

All season, the future of the playoff has been a raging debate from the CFP board room in Texas to sports bars across the country. When asked at ACC media days in July if he was for a 12-team format, Pitt head coach Pat Narduzzi said he was.

“I think it’s a great opportunity,” Narduzzi told the Post-Gazette. “It’s been the same four teams every year, and if Pitt can pop in once every three or four years, now you start to make some strides in recruiting and elsewhere. You start to move up the ladder. If it’s the same teams, the Alabamas, the Clemsons, the Ohio States, let’s just let those four teams play at the beginning of the year, you know?”

At the time, Narduzzi was ridiculed by some for that “if Pitt can pop in once every three or four years” comment. Turns out, this would have been the year. And if Narduzzi can propel the program forward after 2021’s success, perhaps this kind of season can happen again.

Since that sit-down interview in Charlotte, though, things have changed. Narduzzi made those remarks 24 hours before reports of Texas and Oklahoma jumping ship, which affected the mindset of the ACC and some of its coaches over the following weeks.

As recently as Nov. 22, when Pitt was 9-2 and preparing for Syracuse, Narduzzi reiterated that he’s in favor of an expanded playoff. But he’s not sure if it should go straight to 12 teams or start out as an eight-team field then grow from there.

Advertise with us

Last week, Narduzzi — when asked about the state of the coaching carousel — brought up Phillips and a 12-team format.

“He asked me, ‘Pat, what’s your feeling?’ Which I love about the guy,” Narduzzi said of Phillips last Thursday. “I just said, ‘Listen, there’s no rush to get to 12 teams. ... Don’t make quick decisions. Take your time.’”

How much more time will this expansion conversation drag on? That’s unclear.

But those who want to see new blood — who want to see what teams on a heater like Pickett’s Pitt or Barkley’s Penn State could have done if given the chance — hope change comes sooner rather than later.

Johnny McGonigal: jmcgonigal@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jmcgonigal9