NEW YORK — Kenny Pickett’s right hand rested on the Heisman Trophy. He kept smiling, walked away from the photo-op with the other finalists and made his way down the Marriott Marquis ballroom steps.
Shortly after, he was whisked away from the Times Square hotel down Broadway to the Lincoln Center for Saturday’s Heisman ceremony. But before he left, Pickett sat by himself in front of reporters, a Pitt flag at his back, and offered perspective on the evening he was about to experience.
“Whatever happens happens. It’s been an unbelievable journey, an unbelievable ride,” Pickett said. “With all the adversities, if I told you guys I’d be up sitting here after my sophomore season, I don’t think you’d believe me. So it’s really special to be here.”
Ultimately, the 2021 Heisman Trophy was not Pickett’s to hoist. Alabama quarterback Bryce Young — the overwhelming betting favorite — won, as expected.
Heisman Trophy finalist Kenny Pickett: Pitt in the spotlight
Pickett finished third in voting with 631 points and 28 first-place votes (three points for a first-place vote, two for second, one for third). Michigan pass-rusher Aidan Hutchinson finished second with 954 points. Ohio State quarterback C.J. Stroud finished fourth. The award was decided by 928 electors (870 college football media members, 57 living Heisman winners and one overall fan vote).
Despite not hearing his name called when he desired it most, Saturday night wasn’t lost on Pickett. Seven days after winning an ACC championship, he was recognized as the first Pitt player to reach the Heisman ceremony since Larry Fitzgerald in 2003.
Read More
“I’ve been saying this from the beginning, but all the individual accolades are team-oriented. We committed to being great this offseason,” Pickett said. “... We bought in, and we went out and did it. It’s an incredible feeling to bring Pitt back to where it was. With all the big-name schools, Pitt’s back up there where it should be.”
And it’s thanks in large part to Pickett, a fifth-year senior who could have left for the NFL after the 2020 season. Instead, the New Jersey native consulted with his parents, Ken and Kasey; now former offensive coordinator Mark Whipple; Super Bowl champion Peyton Manning and others en route to a decision.
Pitt’s Kenny Pickett and Heisman Trophy memories
Pickett chose to utilize the NCAA’s COVID-19 eligibility waiver, and a record-setting season followed.
Statistically, the differences between Pickett and Young are razor thin. Young boasts Pro Football Focus’ top quarterback grade (92.9) while ranking second and fourth nationally in passing touchdowns (43) and passing yards (4,322). Pickett’s credentials (92.8 PFF grade, 42 touchdown passes, 4,319 yards) are narrowly behind.
Pickett does have five rushing touchdowns to Young’s three, giving Pitt’s fourth-year starter a slim lead on total scores. Pickett also ranks third nationally with 72 completions of 20-plus yards. Young’s 68 completions sit fourth in the country.
“The thing about Kenny Pickett is, he’s a true NFL quarterback. He’s throwing the ball down the field in a pro-style offense,” Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi told the Post-Gazette on Friday. “If you ever did a chart, whether it’s Bryce Young or anybody else, and you put where the balls are completed, I don’t think there’s a quarterback in the country that’s throwing the ball down the field in the spots he has. To me, that’s what it’s all about.”
But the Heisman doesn’t just come down to numbers. Everyone knows it comes down to moments. And while Pickett didn’t embarrass Georgia’s defense on national television days before votes were due, he did show up when Pitt needed him most.
On Sept. 11 at Tennessee, he whipped a third-down touchdown to Melquise Stovall to quiet the Neyland Stadium crowd and mount Pitt’s comeback. On Oct. 23 against Clemson, he closed the first half with a 39-yard, fourth-and-short score to Taysir Mack, igniting both the North Shore and Pitt’s ACC title hopes. On Nov. 11, he drove an overtime bullet into the chest of Lucas Krull to beat North Carolina. A week later, he threw four touchdowns to overcome Virginia and clinch an ACC Coastal division title.
And in Charlotte, Pickett did what he came to Pitt to do. He won a conference title.
In Pitt’s 45-21 win over Wake Forest, Pickett threw two touchdowns, surpassing Deshaun Watson’s single-season ACC record and breaking a tie with Dan Marino atop Pitt’s all-time chart. Pickett left Bank of America Stadium with every major passing record in program history. He also quite literally changed college football.
Last Saturday, Pickett’s fake slide against the Demon Deacons turned into a 58-yard touchdown run. And on Thursday, after days of debate and discussion, the NCAA banned fake slides moving forward.
In every sense, it’s been a crazy week and an eventful year for Pickett. And though he wasn’t selected as college football’s most outstanding player, Pitt’s captain and folk hero will always hold himself in that regard.
“Every time I step on the field, I just feel like the best player,” Pickett said. “I think it’s the only mindset you need to have to be successful. It’s just the way I play the game. I’ve always believed in myself. I publicly bet on myself last year coming back. And I proved it to everybody. It’s a great feeling.”
Johnny McGonigal: jmcgonigal@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jmcgonigal9






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.