Heading into the 2020-21 season, Pitt’s men’s basketball team was something of a mystery.
Picked to finish 13th in the 15-team ACC in the league’s preseason poll, the Panthers had some talent, but with five freshmen among their 13 scholarship players, questions remained. How good were these first-year players? How much could they contribute in their first years with the program? And how would that ultimately impact Pitt’s success or failures as a team?
With only about a month remaining in the regular season, answers are starting to not only emerge, but solidify.
The Panthers are seventh in the conference standings, 2.5 games ahead of the position in which they were picked to finish. They’ve gotten there largely on the backs of their more experienced players, as their top five scorers are all juniors or sophomores. The impact of their five-man freshman class, which was ranked 18th nationally by Rivals.com, has been more understated, with no player currently with the team averaging more than 4.8 points or 17 minutes per game.
“I think our freshmen have done a good job for us,” Pitt coach Jeff Capel said. “They’ve been good for us and I’m pleased with them and we’re going to continue to work with them. I think they have very bright futures here.”
It’s partially reflective of where Pitt is as a program.
In each of the previous three years, the Panthers had to rely on freshmen to fill a multitude of holes. After turning over virtually the entire roster from his first to his second year at the school, former coach Kevin Stallings had seven freshmen on his 2017-18 team, with four of them finishing among the squad’s six leaders in minutes per game. When Capel arrived the following year and faced roster fluctuations of his own, the kind that typically accompany coaching changes, he brought in three freshmen -- Xavier Johnson, Trey McGowens and Au’Diese Toney -- who ended up being three of the Panthers’ top four scorers that season. Last season, Justin Champagnie came in as a freshman and led the team in scoring and rebounding.
In Capel’s third season at the university, needs have changed and so, too, have the demands on freshmen. Johnson, Toney and Champagnie are all proven and productive commodities who can withstand the physical toll of playing 30 minutes or more a game. Ithiel Horton, a sophomore brought in from Delaware, provides Pitt with an outside shooter it largely lacks otherwise. There aren’t the same obvious voids for freshmen to fill.
It’s a reality reflected in numbers. Despite accounting for 38.5% of the scholarship players on the roster, freshmen are responsible for 18.6% of the Panthers’ points per game, 30% of their minutes per game, 28% of their rebounds per game, 21.7% of their assists per game, 13.7% of their made shots and 5.1% of their made 3-pointers. When John Hugley, who is indefinitely suspended from the team, is excluded from consideration, Pitt’s remaining four freshmen account for 12.4% of its points per game, 19.3% of its rebounds per game, 19.6% of its assists per game, 24.4% of its minutes per game, 10.2% of its made shots and 5.1% of its made 3s.
That stands in contrast to the percentage of production from freshmen the past several years.
2019-2020 (three freshmen)
Points: 25.4%
Minutes: 25.6%
Rebounds: 28.7%
Assists: 10.7%
Made shots: 25%
Made 3s: 20.6%
2018-19 (three)
Points: 49.5%
Minutes: 42.4%
Rebounds: 34.6%
Assists: 57.3%
Made shots: 45.8%
Made 3s: 38.2%
2017-18 (seven)
Points: 60.5%
Minutes: 64.7%
Rebounds: 59%
Assists: 61.3%
Made shots: 59.3%
Made 3s: 48.4%
It’s not a discouraging development. The Panthers’ 2017-18 season, with freshmen playing such prominent roles, was a disaster and each season since, as the contributions of freshmen have dwindled, Pitt’s record has improved, from 8-24 in 2017-18 to 14-19 to 16-17 to, currently, 9-6.
“Look at the best player in front of you and look why he’s playing a lot,” Johnson said. “He’s really producing a lot at his position and everybody else is, too. All the young guys look up to us and follow our lead. They’ll have to take the next step up next or whenever that time is.”
There are unusual circumstances that have impacted the Panthers’ freshmen this season, as well. Prior to his indefinite suspension on Jan. 15, Hugley was averaging 5.1 points and 4.3 rebounds in 14.3 minutes per game. His defensive rebounding percentage -- the percentage of available missed shots from opponents he grabbed while on the court -- was second on the team and his offensive rebounding percentage of 12.3% was the highest on the team. If he played enough minutes to qualify, that number would rank Hugley among the top 80 players nationally and top four players in the ACC. On a team without a reliably productive center, it’s quite possible that, at this point in the season, Hugley would have developed to where he occupied that valuable niche.
His indefinite suspension came after he was charged with three felonies related to a car theft last summer. His preliminary hearing, originally scheduled for Feb. 18, has since been pushed back to April 8, making it highly unlikely that Pitt’s highest-rated freshman will return to the court this season.
Without Hugley, Femi Odukale has emerged as the Panthers’ most dependable and decorated freshman. While averaging 4.8 points and 1.8 assists in 14.9 minutes per game, Odukale has been both a primary backup to Johnson and someone who can play alongside him, as well, with Odukale running the point and Johnson playing off the ball. In 10 conference games, those numbers have jumped to 6.3 points and two assists (to 1.5 turnovers) in 18.6 minutes per game. He has also shown himself to be perhaps Pitt’s second-best defensive player, behind only Toney.
There are areas of his game that need to improve -- namely his 43.6% mark from the free-throw line -- but for where he is as a freshman, he has shown promise.
“I’m just showing people I’m still tougher than everybody mentally,” Odukale said. “I might not be physically the strongest on the court, but I’m going to make them feel like I’m the strongest on the court. Just being tough. Showing the New York in me.”
In the past seven games, the Brooklyn native has 17 assists to just six turnovers.
“The game has really come to him, to be honest with you,” Johnson said. “He doesn’t really turn the ball over that much. He had two last game [ed. note: he had one], but that’s just him being in attack mode. I like that from him. He honestly wants it every game. He’s slowing the game down in his head and he’s making better plays with the ball in his hands.”
While Odukale’s profile on the team has increased during ACC play, those of some of his fellow freshmen have receded.
William Jeffress was one of Pitt’s two four-star recruits in the 2020 class, but over the past month, his place in the team’s rotation has waned to the point of disappearing. Since scoring seven points in a Dec. 9 win at Northwestern, which brought his scoring average to 4.3 points per game, the 6-foot-7 wing has scored just five points. He has appeared in just one of Pitt’s past six games. After playing 156 of a possible 360 minutes in the first nine games (43.3%), he has logged just 14 of a possible 240 minutes in the past six contests (5.8%).
Forward Noah Collier has been in a similar predicament, having only appeared in one of Pitt’s past six games after playing in eight of its first nine contests. The only one of those games he missed was due to COVID-19 protocols. When asked previously about that dip in minutes for both Jeffress and Collier, Capel has said they have to practice better to earn more playing time, adding that as a team “we need them.”
In a season inextricably impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic, there’s some question of how the development of young, inexperienced players has been affected, given that freshmen this season don’t have some of the same luxuries and benefits first-year players have in a normal year. It’s a particularly relevant inquiry for someone like Jeffress, who is only 17 years old.
For now, though, those same freshmen are trying to earn the hard-earned minutes they desire.
“I’ve learned I can compete with anybody,” Odukale said. “Everybody doubted me, but I’m meant to be here. I’m just looking to keep proving people wrong.”
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.