The City Game between Pitt and Duquesne, once a fixture of the basketball calendar in Western Pa., will not take place for the second time in as many seasons.
Both schools confirmed Thursday that the Panthers’ and Dukes’ men’s basketball teams are not scheduled to play during the 2020-21 season, marking only the second time in the past 50 years that has been the case. The rivals, with campuses separated by only a two-mile stretch of Forbes Avenue, did not play last season, either. It was the first time since the 1969-70 season the two had not met.
The programs’ women’s teams have met every year since 1984, including last season when Duquesne beat Pitt, 81-62, and are scheduled to continue to play. The absence in the men’s basketball series came with the hope of resumption, as it was announced in March 2019 that the two schools had agreed in principle to play in 2020 and 2021.
Panthers coach Jeff Capel, through a program spokesman, offered no further comment Thursday. In a statement released Thursday, Duquesne athletic director Dave Harper said he was informed that Pitt did not wish to play the game at PPG Paints Arena either year, as was planned. The Dukes had offered to play at Petersen Events Center, the Panthers’ home arena, this year for no guarantee fee — which can often run close to $100,000 — ticket allotment or special considerations, but Harper noted that proposal was declined.
Duquesne, according to Harper, has an offer to play at Pitt during the 2021-22 season that “we are considering.”
“This is an event that is annually anticipated by the City of Pittsburgh and was well on its way to growing back to being a great college basketball rivalry,” Harper said in the statement. “We have worked hard to build our program into a postseason contender. We finished 94th in the 2020 NET rankings and anticipate having an even better ranking in 2020-21, which makes us a quality non-conference opponent for any program with postseason aspirations. The NCAA selection committee values Quad 1 and Quad 2 games, and we are actively seeking games against Power [Five] opponents and have secured them. This situation is unfortunate for many entities involved, in particular the college basketball fans of Western Pennsylvania, but ultimately Pitt declined to play us.”
Read More
With 87 all-time meetings, Duquesne is Pitt’s fourth-most-played opponent in men’s basketball program history. The Panthers hold a 55-32 advantage in the series, which includes victories in 17 of the past 18 matchups.
The Dukes, however, have improved in recent seasons under coach Keith Dambrot, finishing 21-9 last season, giving them their most wins in a season in 11 years and their best single-season win percentage in nearly five decades. For years, the lopsided nature of the rivalry and Duquesne’s struggles as a program would have stood as a reasonable justification for ending the series. What, aside from logistical ease and some sense of civic pride, would Pitt have to gain from such an arrangement?
Last season, though, Duquesne finished 15 spots ahead of Pitt in the NCAA’s NET rankings, and in front of three other ACC programs. Playing the Dukes at a neutral site like PPG Paints Arena would have given the Panthers a game against a Quad 2 opponent, which would enhance their NCAA tournament resume with a win and wouldn’t damage it with a loss.
“If they feel like it’s in their best interest for their program not to play, I get that,” Dambrot said. “I’ve coached a long time. Any alternative excuses other than that would be difficult for me to understand.”
During the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic — which has stripped athletic departments of bountiful sources of revenue and forced many schools to trim costs, sometimes significantly so — a local matchup like the City Game would have made even more sense. Other schools have sought similar deals with nearby counterparts over the past several weeks. To use one example, Georgia Tech and Georgia State, both based in Atlanta, announced a three-game men’s basketball series Wednesday, pitting them against one another for the first time since 2008.
One-sided as the City Game has been over the past two decades, it has still generated interest locally. In the past 10 meetings, all of which were held at neutral sites (PPG Paints Arena and, before that, Mellon Arena), there was an average crowd of 12,749 fans, a much higher figure than a non-conference game for either program would typically produce.
For Pitt, there are reasons why such a deal may be more difficult.
Beginning last season, the Panthers play a 20-game conference schedule as a member of the ACC, up from 18 games in previous seasons, which limits the number of non-conference opportunities they have. Next season, should it occur, they’re set to face West Virginia in the final matchup of a four-game deal, will almost certainly take part in the ACC-Big Ten Challenge and will have three additional games as part of the Myrtle Beach Invitational, leaving only six open dates.
“Coach Capel and I regularly discuss non-conference scheduling and how to balance it against 20 ACC games, the ACC-Big Ten Challenge as well as special opportunities like this year’s Myrtle Beach Invitational,” Pitt athletic director Heather Lyke said in a statement. “A game with Duquesne this season did not fit with our non-ACC scheduling model. However, we have provided Duquesne with a game contract to play at the Petersen Events Center during the 2021-22 season and we are awaiting their response to our offer to play.”
The way the deal collapsed between Pitt and Duquesne was difficult for some to rationalize.
“I give Coach [Capel] credit; he never agreed to it,” Dambrot said. “He said all along ‘Well, I’m going to make the decision.’ But once you agree as an institution, you should play the game. They didn’t have to agree to play in ’20 and ’21, which they came out and they said it. You can’t say something and not do it because that makes you not credible.”
Last year, Capel said the once-annual game’s absence was the result of Pitt agreeing to play at Robert Morris in the first basketball game ever held at UPMC Events Center. Capel, as he said at the time, made the decision not to play both teams in a single year.
“I’m not afraid to play anyone. Nobody,” Capel said in December 2019 in an interview with 93.7 The Fan. “Let’s get that out there right away. I’m not afraid to play anyone, but as the leader of our program, as the caretaker of this program, my job is to do what’s best for my program.”
There is some promise that the series may resume at some point, with the offer to play during the 2021-22 season still being mulled by Duquesne.
Dambrot, for his part, would like to see it continue in some form, believing it to be good for the players, the city and the fans. He respects Pitt, viewing it as a place that helped shape his son, Robby, a graduate of the university, into the professional soccer player he currently is. But the future of the City Game, even for one of the coaches involved in it, remains uncertain, especially after recent developments.
“I’m hopeful,” Dambrot said when asked if the series will resume. “But I wouldn’t count on it.”
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.