Pitt has six players from its 2019-20 team returning next season. The Post-Gazette is speaking with each of them to discuss last season and what awaits for the program and themselves.

For 31 minutes, Au’Diese Toney trudged up and down the court at the Greensboro Coliseum on March 11, the pain evident with each and every step he took.

Not even 24 hours earlier, the Pitt sophomore had injured his ankle in an ACC tournament win against Wake Forest, but a matchup the next day with N.C. State stood as perhaps his team’s last game of the season. So, even though he was very clearly not himself — scoring four points on five shots with four rebounds — he found it within himself to play, doing whatever he could for a team with dwindling hopes.

That day, Toney carried more than just a throbbing joint. In the days and weeks following that final loss of the 2019-20 season, there was something that, as he said, he felt like he needed to get off his chest, sentiments that, once expressed, would determine whether or not he stayed at the place where his college career began.

Advertise with us

“I don’t want to keep having a losing season,” Toney said in a phone interview with the Post-Gazette. “We’re always saying we want to have this one goal to get to the tournament. It’s just so frustrating because last season, we had a chance to do that, but it’s the simple fact we got too comfortable and the main things we used to do, they ceased. They went away at a point when we started losing. That was frustrating, but you couldn’t really talk to the coaches about it because it’s during the season. You really don’t know what we were thinking about or whatever, so I just had to talk to him about it after the season.”

As the end of March approached, so did a conversation Toney was set to have with Panthers coach Jeff Capel. He, Toney said, also had some things to get off his chest. What ensued, though, was a productive, re-energizing dialogue. If there was doubt before, there wasn’t after it — Toney was coming back to Pitt for his junior season.

For both parties, it’s a boon of an arrangement. Toney gets to return to a team on which he’ll continue to play big minutes and have a pronounced role, while Pitt retains a tough, versatile wing who, in the final two months of last season, was arguably its best player.

As he weighed his options after the season ended, Toney thought back often to that season and how it transpired — a slow start followed by a burst from which he never truly slowed (at least until his injury). While doing so, he thought of the coach who guided him through that.

“They could have given up on me, but they didn’t,” Toney said. “He still gave me opportunities to play through the mist I was in and the fog I was in. He was just trying to help me get out of it. Once I got out of it, it was a relief from everything. It was really a great opportunity.”

Advertise with us

The final product of that 31-game run for Toney was impressive. He was fourth on the team in scoring at 9.5 points per game, a two-point increase from his freshman season. His shooting was much better than it was the year before, with his field goal percentage jumping 10 percentage points, to 46.1%, and his 3-point percentage going from 24.6% to 32.8%. He remained, by a fairly wide margin, the team’s best defender, someone who was regularly assigned to the opponent’s biggest offensive threat and who, at 6-foot-6, was able to effectively shadow a foe as small as a point guard and as large as a power forward.

As a freshman, he was alluring but erratic, a tenacious menace on defense who disappeared or actively hurt his team offensively at times. As a sophomore, that defensive aggressiveness remained and was paired with an improved touch and awareness on offense, turning him into a legitimate and needed two-way threat. He, in some ways, fit the profile of a player that could have been a valued contributor on some of Pitt’s best teams from earlier this century.

Coming off the season he had, Toney projected to be one of the Panthers’ most prominent players in the two years to come. So why the hesitation about returning?

To start, Toney said he didn’t know if he was going to be playing the same minutes he had been (last season, he averaged 30.2 minutes per game and started in 24 of the 31 games in which he played). Beyond that, the weight of losing — Pitt went 30-36 in his first two seasons — wore on him. Last season in particular took a toll. The Panthers started off 15-9 only to lose eight of their final nine games to erase any kind of postseason hopes before COVID-19 could. That abrupt change came after a Feb. 8 victory against Georgia Tech, a day when Pitt surpassed its win total from the previous season.

“We got so relaxed when we won more games than we did last year,” Toney said. “It was just like, ‘Oh, wow. We made it.’ But we didn’t really accomplish anything at all. Every practice, it was different. It was making people go harder. There was anger. We didn’t want to be the last seed and knowing we were heading that way, it made it even worse. Everybody was just in their own world.”

Advertise with us

Capel often cited his team’s relative youth, with three sophomores and a freshman accounting for its top four scorers, as one reason for the collapse. While that may not be totally true from a pure basketball perspective, it showed in other ways.

“We were too — and this is a key word Coach preaches a lot — relaxed,” Toney said. “That’s part of being young. We get too relaxed and thinking everything will be given to us. We really had a lot just going through our minds. At the time, we were thinking we can’t be beat, so when we did get beaten, it was like, ‘Oh, we weren’t expecting this.’ We were just getting frustrated. Everything was so frustrating. We were separating.”

Earlier in the season, Toney had experienced a fraught psychological state of his own following the death of grandmother in August. It impacted his game even more than his nagging ankle against N.C. State ever could have. In Pitt’s first eight games, he averaged 4.9 points per game while shooting an abysmal 32.4% from the field.

“It was very rough in the beginning,” Toney said. “I just couldn’t let that get the best of me. I had to put my mind in a different world when I stepped inside the lines. But off the court, I can handle those situations better.”

Those numbers later improved — and did so drastically. Beginning with a 16-point effort on Jan. 22 against Boston College, Toney averaged 12.3 points in Pitt’s final 15 games while shooting 46.7%.

Advertise with us

That finish provides a justifiable sense of hope for Toney and how he may progress the rest of his career with the Panthers. The rising junior believes the team will be better next season — “We’ve got guys that are coming in that are hungry,” he said. — and if he makes the changes he aims to with his game, he should be, as well. Over the offseason, he said, he’ll focus primarily on his ball-handling and being more consistent with his jump shot. He, like millions of others across the country, has been watching ESPN’s documentary “The Last Dance” and sees a player in Scottie Pippen that he can emulate.

There’s something harder to measure that he will look to improve over the next several months — his leadership. He went into last season expecting to be, even as a sophomore, a leader his team could count on. But by his own admission, he fell short in that task, something he said Capel discussed with him in their March conversation. If that piece falls into place, both he and Capel have an idea of what he can evolve into on the court.

“Just to become the player that Pitt brought me in to be and accomplish our one goal — the tournament,” Toney said.

It’s one of the many things that are bringing him back to the place he has called home the past two years.

“I just accepted the fact that I’m riding this out until the wheels fall off,” Toney said.

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG