Each week through the end of the 2019-20 season, Craig Meyer, the Post-Gazette’s Pitt basketball writer, will answer reader questions about the Panthers. And some other stuff, too.
If you want to submit a question, you can email Craig at cmeyer@post-gazette.com or hit him up on Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.
Nick: What does Pitt need to do to get to the NIT, and will they do enough to get there?
Craig: I’ve been on the NIT train for Pitt for weeks now, if not months, and I’ve gotten to the point where I’m thinking of getting off a few stops earlier than I had originally planned. To qualify for the NIT, a team needs to be .500 or better. With one more win, the Panthers would guarantee themselves a non-losing season (at least before any postseason opportunities they may pursue).
There are a couple of problems, though. One is that while the NIT is widely and accurately considered a second-tier tournament, there are a finite number of spots available (32). The number of invitations available to major conference teams is dependent upon how things unfold in mid- and low-major conference tournaments, as the regular-season champion of those leagues is guaranteed a spot in the NIT should it not win the league’s tournament. If there are a lot of upsets in those conferences, the opportunities for a program like Pitt dwindle significantly. It’s not especially well-positioned among schools that would get at-large NIT bids. This is an imprecise measurement, but 28 teams not included in ESPN’s most recent mock bracket are ranked at least 20 spots higher than the Panthers in the NET rankings (in which they’re No. 98), with five of those programs coming from the ACC. Since the ACC added Syracuse, Pitt and Notre Dame in 2013, it hasn’t had more than three teams in the NIT in a given year.
The other troubling development for the Panthers is that I honestly don’t know how many wins are left on their schedule given their recent play. Four of their final five opponents are ranked in the top 60 on KenPom and the one that isn’t, Georgia Tech, comes on the road against a team ranked 16 spots higher than Pitt. This all comes after it went 1-2 in a three-game stretch against teams ranked 81st, 97th and 97th at the time of their matchups, two of which came at home. I think it will grab one win in those final five, but it’s getting increasingly hard, to the point of being unlikely, to see more than two wins and it doesn’t seem all that implausible that it goes winless.
Read More
Rich: I look around at the local HS basketball teams and I see one player this year going to a Power Five team. Would you say the No. 1 problem for Capel, or any future basketball coach at Pitt, is the lack of any local talent?
Craig: Western Pennsylvania is definitely a football region — albeit not as much of a talent-rich one as it was decades ago — but it does produce some basketball talent, even if some of those players weren’t blue-chip prospects coming out of high school. Cam Johnson and T.J. McConnell are both in the NBA, the former of whom was a lottery pick. He’s not originally from the area and didn’t play in the WPIAL, but Oscar Tshiebwe was a McDonald’s all-American. Ethan Morton and William Jeffress are top-100 recruits in the 2020 class and Pitt seems to have a very good chance at landing the latter.
Having said that, Pittsburgh lags behind other cities in terms of the number of high-end recruits it produces, many of which are either larger than Pittsburgh or have more ingrained basketball cultures (or AAU programs with deals with major shoe companies). Pitt doesn’t have that kind of a local talent pool and it’s not one of the sport’s bluebloods, but it’s an ACC program close to a number of fertile recruiting cities, with a proven recruiter as its head coach. It could be a lot worse.
Pitt Hoops: What do you think the main rotation will look like at the start of next season?
Craig: It can be tough to project just how well a freshman will adjust to the college game, even with the ratings attached to these guys coming out of high school. Pitt’s best freshman each of the past two seasons was ranked outside the top 200 in their class. So while John Hugley and Noah Collier are both top-150 recruits (the former a top-100 recruit), it’s not some guarantee they’ll make an immediate impact.
Having said that, I think that given the state of the frontcourt, both of them (and Max Amadasun, the lowest-rated of Pitt’s three signees) will have the chance to earn minutes alongside Terrell Brown and Abdoul Karim Coulibaly, both of whom are slated to return. Ithiel Horton will give the backcourt some much-needed depth and another ball-handler (along with Xavier Johnson and Trey McGowens). Au’Diese Toney, Justin Champagnie, Gerald Drumgoole and Ryan Murphy are all wings who could make an impact, with the first two definitely able to play the three or four in traditional lineups.
Drew: Do you expect Pitt to be active in the grad transfer market this offseason?
Craig: You can never rule anything out in recruiting, but I would be surprised. Pitt’s roster situation already is a little cramped. It has three signees and, technically speaking, only two roster spots available with Eric Hamilton’s graduation and the open scholarship it currently holds. Beyond those three players, Capel is still actively recruiting a couple of players in the 2020 class.
I also think the impact of grad transfers can be a bit overstated. Most of the top ones who can really make a difference end up at bigger, more successful programs, where very few of them even have that profound of an effect. With Hamilton and Sidy N’Dir in recent seasons, the Panthers have gotten what many programs get with grad transfers — guys that can provide some depth and modest production in an area of immediate need.
Brandon: How do you explain lack of recruiting for the backcourt for next year with only one addition (Horton)? Still lacking major depth at guard position.
Craig: I’ll say that it’s still relatively early. The frontcourt is an area of much greater need and they’ve addressed that with their three 2020 signees thus far. Could they use some more depth in the backcourt? Sure. But I also don’t think it’s especially dire if they don’t add anyone else. Johnson, McGowens and Horton are all capable ball-handlers, though Johnson would obviously stand out as the primary point guard since the other two are more combo guards. Murphy gives them a shooter. That’s four players for the two traditional guard spots and Johnson and McGowens, for some of their struggles this season, will benefit, I think, with what should be an improved roster talent-wise.
Capel and his staff extended an offer to Femi Odukale, a three-star guard in the 2020 class, earlier this month, so it’s possible that the players on the current roster won’t make up the entirety of the backcourt.
Tim: Let’s do a pointless yet fun one ... how many more wins would they have with Marcus Carr (or other grad transfer “true” PG) on the roster. Not a knock on X but I think someone to steer the ship would help with the scoring droughts and wild decision making
Craig: Not pointless at all, Tim. I dig questions like this, though I will say that Johnson would qualify as a true point guard given his distribution abilities and assist numbers (though his miscues and decision-making remain an issue). I think Carr would be faring well, especially given what he is doing at Minnesota, where he is averaging 15.7 points, 6.7 assists (to 2.7 turnovers) and 5.8 rebounds per game while ranking among the top 20 Division I players in assist rate. His 3-point shooting, like Johnson’s, isn’t great, at 33.3%, but even with his lack of high-end speed, Pitt’s among the slowest 25 teams in Division I in tempo, and I think that low-possession style would suit him well.
He was a player who fared pretty well as a freshman at Pitt despite being stuck in an untenable situation. It makes it all the more ridiculous that some folks tried to claim back then that he wasn’t an “ACC caliber player.”
Aileen: How does Jeff Capel get his team through the next three weeks when it looks like his team has hit the proverbial wall mentally and physically?
Craig: He has talked about not trying to over-exert his players in practice, which I think is a good step. It is concerning, though, that this is the second year in a row this is occurring, though this year, the losing has started about a month later than it did last year and it was caused in some part because of injuries. If Murphy gets back to playing how he was before his concussion and Hamilton isn’t out too long with his ankle injury (he wasn’t in a walking boot or on crutches Saturday, which is a good sign), they’ve got nine players averaging at least eight minutes per game, which should be enough to carry them.
Matt: What past Pitt basketball player would help this team the most?
Craig: I guess it depends on what you prioritize the most. This team’s two greatest needs are a strong interior presence and outside shooting. If you want shooting, Jason Matthews and Ashton Gibbs would be great options. Gibbs works a couple of miles away at Duquesne, so maybe it’s worth seeing if he has eligibility left (there’s also Ronald Ramon on Pitt’s staff). If I had my pick, though, I’d opt for a big man. Charles Smith would be an appealing option (and he’d get to be teammates with his son, though I’m not sure how that would work if it’s the pre-fatherhood version of Smith that played at Pitt), but I’ll go DeJuan Blair, who would be roundly considered the best player in program history if he stayed all four years and maintained his statistical production from his first two seasons.
Corey: In honor of Duke-UNC, what are the best rivalries in sports? That’s gotta be way up there with Army-Navy, no?
Craig: I maintain that college rivalries are superior to basically any pro rivalry, so this list will be limited to those. Here’s my top five, in no particular order:
Auburn-Alabama football: Oak trees died in the name of this rivalry. It embodies a lot of the general nuttiness around SEC football.
Michigan-Ohio State football: Been a bit lopsided of late, but it’s a classic.
Duke-North Carolina basketball: The gold standard in college basketball. Always seems to produce close, compelling games.
Louisville-Kentucky basketball: It, too, has been a bit lopsided the past decade, and the games often aren’t that enthralling, but it might be the pettiest, most intense rivalry in sports. People got in a fight at a dialysis clinic over it!
Army-Navy football: I wanted to not include this because I think rivalries lose something when there’s a lot of mutual respect — they’re different branches of the military, but they’re ultimately on the same team, right? — but this list would feel incomplete without it.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.