Ben DiNucci faced a dilemma in 2017 about how to proceed with the rest of his college football career.

The former Pine-Richland star quarterback could have stayed at Pitt and continued battling Kenny Pickett for the starting job, which probably would’ve resulted in more frustration than on-field accomplishments and personal fulfillment.

Instead, DiNucci bet on himself by taking his talents to Harrisonburg, Va., and James Madison University. Two seasons later, he is one game away from leading the Dukes to a Football Championship Subdivision title.

“JMU giving me that second opportunity, second chance, I’m grateful for that,” DiNucci told the Post-Gazette. “Being a part of this team this year has been awesome.”

Advertise with us

DiNucci has shown improvement this year in just about every way a quarterback can from his days at Pitt, and even last season under former JMU coach Mike Houston. In the 2018 campaign, he completed 68.3% of his passes for 2,275 yards, 16 touchdowns and 12 interceptions while his Dukes finished with a 9-4 record.

Under the tutelage of current JMU coach Curt Cignetti — who served as a graduate assistant for Pitt’s football team for the 1983-84 season and was the Panthers’ quarterbacks/tight ends coach from 1993-99 — DiNucci posted career highs in completion percentage (71.3%), passing yards (3,237) and touchdowns (27) while only throwing five picks and propelling the Dukes to a 14-1 record and a date with reigning FCS champions North Dakota State on Saturday at Toyota Stadium in Frisco, Texas.

James Madison quarterback Ben DiNucci drops back to pass against Villanova Saturday, Oct. 12, 2019, at Bridgeforth Stadium in Harrisonburg, Va. (James Madison Athletics)

“I’ve been aware of Ben for a long time,” Cignetti said on a conference call last Friday with Bisons coach Matt Entz. “Ben’s got a lot of talent, a lot of savvy. He’s a competitor, he’s a good athlete. Last year, some of the issues were turnovers, ball security and such. ... It was important to us that we get those things cleaned up.

“His touchdown-to-interception ratio is really, really good. He’s played as well as any quarterback in the country this season.”

When Cignetti said he has “been aware” of DiNucci for quite a while, he’s not kidding. Cignetti’s sister happens to be close friends with DiNucci’s mother. The two lived about five minutes from each other and played tennis together on occasion, according to DiNucci.

Advertise with us

There was a small amount of pressure not to put a strain on that friendship for DiNucci when Cignetti took the James Madison job before the 2019 season. So, are the two of them still going strong?

“I would hope so,” DiNucci said, laughing. “The first meeting I had with him he pulled me in his office and started laughing and said, ‘Don’t make me ruin the relationship between your mom and my sister.’ So far, so good.”

Being a quarterback under Cignetti’s watchful eye was a very different experience for DiNucci than playing for Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi.

“Coach Narduzzi was really defense-minded, so he wasn’t really a part of the offense at all,” he said. “Coach Cignetti was the complete opposite. He’s really offensive-minded, so it was almost like having a second QB coach on the field with me. Coach Cignetti is pretty hands-off, but coach Narduzzi is up in your face if you weren’t doing something right.”

Of course, DiNucci also admitted there were a few times this past season when he did something wrong or poorly and “coach Cignetti let me hear about it.”

Advertise with us

There are certain things he misses about playing football in his hometown, but DiNucci has no regrets about leaving the city for the mountain ranges of Virginia.

“I miss the guys that I went there with,” he said. “I always tell people that I wouldn’t trade the experience for anything. If I had to do it over, I’d do it the exact the same way. ... A part of me is always going to miss it, but the decision I made to go to JMU is the best decision I made.”

Now, DiNucci has a chance to put an exclamation point on the success of his big life change as he — as well as brothers Riley and Dylan Stapleton, both receivers and Indiana High graduates — gets ready to take on a North Dakota State program that has won seven of the last eight FCS championships.

After that, things get murkier. This is DiNucci’s last year of college eligibility, so this game will be his swan song at James Madison regardless of the result. He said he’ll worry about that later, as his focus is currently on the biggest game of his life.

“We’re going to try to not make it any more than just another game,” he said. “Obviously the stakes are a little bit higher now. That’ll be exciting. It’s nice to know that the hard work’s been paying off. ...

Advertise with us

“There’s two [teams] left, and we’re fortunate to be one of them.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxel222