Jeff Capel Wake Forest postgame

The announcement was a brief one, taking up all of two sentences and maybe a third of the 8.5-x-11 sheet of white paper on which it was printed.

Au’Diese Toney was going to miss Pitt’s game Saturday against Wake Forest with an elbow injury.

By the end of the Panthers’ gut-punch of a 69-65 loss to Wake Forest at Petersen Events Center, Toney’s absence loomed large or at least much larger than his relatively modest numbers. In a game in which Pitt trailed by a single point in the final 10 seconds, it was, at the risk of oversimplifying matters, maybe the difference between a win and a loss.

“They missed Toney tonight,” Demon Deacons coach Danny Manning said. “He’s a nightmare matchup in terms of what he brings effort and energy wise. He’s always on the glass and creating some opportunities for his team with his effort.”

Advertise with us

It’s a statement that comes not from simple math, like adding his 6.4 points per game to the final tally, but from the seemingly small but incredibly consequential moments when his presence away from the court was most noticeable.

To start, Pitt’s rotation was trimmed with Toney not able to play. It finished the game having played just eight people, its second-smallest number of the season, with one of those players, freshman Abdoul Karim Coulibaly, playing just four minutes, and another, fellow freshman Gerald Drumgoole, playing just under seven minutes as he still gets back into proper physical shape after missing more than a month of games with an ankle injury.

That lack of depth was crucial from a tactical standpoint. Perhaps at no time was that more plain than with 7:41 remaining in the first half, when guard Trey McGowens picked up his second foul, meaning that, when Xavier Johnson was added to the equation, both members of the Panthers backcourt and their two leading scorers had two fouls.

Though at least one of them remained in the contest at all times, Pitt’s defensive strategy had to be drastically altered. An already thin team trying to keep its two best players out of even more foul trouble in a whistle-happy game went from its effective man-to-man defense to a zone, a more passive look that would, theoretically, reduce the likelihood of a damaging third foul for either of its sophomore guards.

In the game’s first 12:19, when the Panthers led by 10, their man defense held Wake Forest to 14 points on 19 possessions (0.74 points per possession). On the remaining 46 possessions Saturday, a majority of which came against the zone, the Demon Deacons scored 55 points (1.2 points per possession).

Advertise with us

“I knew coming in that it was going to be a big thing for us because of rotation, with how we like to play,” Pitt coach Jeff Capel said of Toney’s absence.

Without one of the team’s best rebounders, a versatile player who is a strong perimeter defender, Pitt also had to adapt by making what had been uncommon personnel decisions.

In the first half, to use one example, the Panthers played seven minutes with two big men — some combination of 6-foot-10 Terrell Brown, 6-9 Eric Hamilton and the 6-8 Coulibaly — on the court at the same time. In those minutes, Pitt was outscored by seven and had just six points on 13 possessions. It was an arrangement Capel had utilized before, including in a late November win against Kansas State, but against a Demon Deacons team with a power forward who stretched the floor, the Panthers were put at a mismatch defensively in that time.

With Toney confined to the sideline, the difference in what each team was able to bring off the bench was palpable. Wake Forest got 32 points from its bench while Pitt got just five, with the latter largely riding on the backs of a handful of starters such as Ryan Murphy (40 minutes played), Justin Champagnie (39:17) and Johnson (35:54). Fourteen of those bench points came from Ismael Massoud, a 6-8 forward who entered the game averaging just 3.4 points per game. Three of his four made shots were 3-pointers, making him the kind of stretch big Toney would have been well-equipped to defend and, potentially, neutralize.

Capel said after the game he isn’t sure when Toney will return. With a road game Wednesday against an unusually vulnerable North Carolina team, the sophomore forward can’t come back quickly enough for a team that desperately missed him Saturday.

Advertise with us

“We have to get adjusted to it,” Capel said.

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.