Unlike those who opt to stay home and watch the Steelers-Browns game, Bill Stull will be at Heinz Field on Thursday night. The former Pitt quarterback — the last one to lead the Panthers to a win over North Carolina — hopes to see Kenny Pickett follow in his footsteps.
The fact that Pitt has struggled with the Tar Heels since joining the ACC in 2013 isn’t news. The Panthers’ 0-6 record against North Carolina by a combined 26 points in conference play is a maddening reality. But Thursday night provides Pitt with an opportunity to not only beat North Carolina, but continue down a path of exorcising demons.
Pitt hasn’t had a 10-win season or finished a campaign ranked in the top 25 polls since 2009, when the Panthers last beat North Carolina: In the Meineke Car Care Bowl, 19-17, at Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte.
When Stull steps into Heinz Field, he’ll pull for the Panthers to end their winless run against North Carolina. He also knows the memories of that day — Dec. 26, 2009 — will flood back. As Pitt pushes to take down the Tar Heels, Stull will recall his own triumph over the team from Chapel Hill.
“It’s crazy to think that was 10 years ago,” Stull said. “We all remember that game like it was yesterday. That muscle memory doesn’t go away.”
Read More
■■■
It would be incomplete to recount the Meineke Car Care Bowl without addressing how the Panthers landed there in the first place. Shield your eyes if you may, Pitt fans. We’re delving into that regular-season finale against Cincinnati — as Dickerson referred to it, “One of the most disappointing losses in Pitt history.”
“I’d be lying if I said I don’t think about it constantly,” Stull said. “I can’t help it.”
Even after falling in Morgantown the week before, 19-16, to an unranked West Virginia team, Pitt’s 2009 preseason goal was still intact: win the Big East and get to the Sugar Bowl. The No. 14-ranked Panthers hosted undefeated, No. 5 Cincinnati with both on the line. But a 45-44 loss — highlighted by Andrew Janocko’s mishandled extra-point hold late in the fourth quarter — was the death knell for Pitt’s BCS hopes.
With 194 rushing yards and three touchdowns, Pitt running back Dion Lewis went off. So did Cincinnati playmaker Mardy Gilyard. The All-American wide receiver had five catches for 118 yards and a score, while adding a 99-yard kick-return touchdown. Armon Binns caught the game-deciding score with 35 seconds to go. But it was Gilyard’s 381 all-purpose yards on 13 touches that dominated the defacto Big East championship game.
Two months later — after Pitt players sat in the Heinz Field tunnel, heads in their hands as Brian Kelly and the Bearcats celebrated on the North Shore — Pitt’s Dorin Dickerson ran into Gilyard. The two played in the Senior Bowl together down in Mobile, Ala.
“Every single day there I was thinking about it. This guy single-handedly beat us,” the tight end said. “[Gilyard] didn’t even bring it up that much. He was just like, ‘Ah yeah, that was a crazy game.’ And I’m looking at him like, ‘Man, you don’t even understand. You crushed our dreams. You crushed our hearts. You crushed everything.’”
■■■
The Panthers’ BCS dreams were dead. But their season wasn’t.
Coach Dave Wannstedt knew he and his staff had to shift the team’s goal. Normally, the players came in on Sundays for film review, but Wannstedt gave them the day off after falling to Cincinnati. When the Panthers returned to the facility Monday, the staff had a new objective: become the first Pitt team since Dan Marino’s 1981 Panthers to reach 10 wins.
“That’s when a head coach earns his money, you know? You don’t have to get ’em ready much for a Cincinnati game. A playoff-type game, the guy selling popcorn is ready to play in the stands. Let’s be real,” Wannstedt said. “This one, the coaching staff and the leaders of that team, I mean, everybody had to step up. And you find out what type of team you really have. Do you have any character? Don’t you have character? Is it just talent? You find out a lot about yourselves and your team and your program.”
Former Pitt captain and offensive lineman John Malecki gave Wannstedt credit for “steering the ship in the right direction” and “bringing enthusiasm and positive vibes” when the Panthers need them most. But in truth, the coaching staff’s new goal didn’t resonate with everyone.
Going into bowl prep, players still thought about the missed opportunity in the regular season finale. Stull said there was an “unsatisfied” feeling around the team. His roommate, Dickerson, believed the same.
“We were sitting there, wishing we had another year, wishing we had that game back against Cincinnati,” Dickerson said. “It was disheartening. I’m sure there were guys who didn’t even want to play in the bowl game. Like, what for? We’re down here during Christmas time, and some would rather be with their families. Instead we’re playing in the Meineke Car Care Bowl.”
Pitt tried to make the most of the bowl experience.
The game was played on Dec. 26, so the families of players and coaches came down for the holidays. The team also spent a day at Charlotte Motor Speedway, where each player rode shotgun with a professional driver, going 200 miles per hour around the NASCAR track.
“That was pretty friggin’ sweet,” Stull said. “And it was pretty hilarious watching coach Wannstedt put on a helmet and one of those race car suits that did not fit him, too.”
While his players enjoyed themselves at the bowl events, Wannstedt caught up with an old friend, North Carolina coach Butch Davis. Both coaches came from the Jimmy Johnson tree, spending time together on Johnson’s staff at Oklahoma State and Miami in the 1980s and the Dallas Cowboys in the early 90s. The teams turned out to be as similar as the coaches’ resumes.
“We were I-formation, play-pass. They were I-formation, play-pass. We were 4-3, very little blitzin’ with outstanding defensive linemen. They were 4-down. I mean, it was spittin’ images of each other,” Wannstedt said. “I remember talking to Butch about it, and we were laughing. This was an easy one to prepare for because we kind of knew each other pretty well. We knew tendencies. We knew what we each believed in, philosophy-wise.
“So it was an interesting game from that standpoint. And it played out that way. It came down to the last minute or two of the game, you know?”
■■■
Pitt running backs coach David Walker, on the headset with offensive coordinator Frank Cignetti Jr. in the Bank of America Stadium booth, stared down at Stull and said: “All right, make sure you don’t force this [stuff].” The senior heeded Walker’s warning.
The Panthers faced a third-and-7 near midfield with 3:55 to go in regulation. Lewis wasn’t an option. Pitt had to throw to extend its drive, down 17-16 to North Carolina late in the fourth quarter.
Cignetti called a simple high-low concept. Stull’s primary job was to read the single-high safety. If the Tar Heels’ safety went with star wideout Jon Baldwin deep, tight end Mike Shanahan would be open on a deep dig route. If he picked Shanahan, Baldwin would be gone for a touchdown. North Carolina’s safety chose the former, and Stull hit Shanahan for the fifth time of the day.
“I had to make sure I wasn’t greedy,” Stull said. “I had to make sure we got the first down so we could kick the field goal.”
Following Shanahan’s catch, Lewis ran it on first, second and third down, taking the game clock down to 1:55. On fourth-and-2, Hutchins, whose career long was a 45-yard field goal, lined up for a 47-yard attempt. But North Carolina jumped offsides. “We went out there and hard-counted them,” Wannstedt said. It worked.
The first down gave Lewis three more cracks at it, making the go-ahead field goal 14 yards shorter than before. With less than a minute to go, Janocko secured the snap and set the hold — and Hutchins, described by Malecki as a “hyper-focused individual,” drilled the 33-yard attempt that turned out to be the game-winner.
Stull said Pitt left 21 points on the field, but it didn’t matter.
North Carolina quarterback T.J. Yates was limited to 187 passing yards. Tar Heels receiver Greg Little caught two touchdown passes, but didn’t burn the Panthers like Gilyard did. Defensive ends Robert Quinn and Quinton Coples — a pair of eventual first-round draft picks — combined for one sack. And former five-star defensive tackle Marvin Austin, later a second-round selection, was held in check by Malecki and the line. Lewis’ 159 rushing yards carried the Panthers until Stull, Hutchins and Janocko stepped up, sending the seniors to the postgame stage to accept their prize.
“We’re holding the trophy up. We’re all looking around, and we’re like, ‘Man, this is the last time we’re all going to be together. And we could be doing this in the Sugar Bowl,’” Dickerson said. “This wasn’t how we wanted it to play out.”
■■■
The season, in Dickerson’s mind, was a failure. Pitt had its goals, and the Panthers fell short of meeting them.
But at the time, there was still reason for optimism after reaching double-digit wins for the first time since Ronald Reagan’s first term. Bill Hillgrove, Pitt football’s longtime radio play-by-play announcer, thought “the arrow was pointing upward” under Wannstedt. “The fact that he had already made the commitment that this would be his last coaching stop, it all seemed very good,” Hillgrove said. “But it unraveled.”
Wannstedt was forced to resign less than a year later after a 7-5 campaign in 2010, and the Panthers have been searching for stability ever since. Todd Graham left after one season in 2011, Paul Chryst hung around for three years, and now Pat Narduzzi is in the midst of Year 5 at the helm.
From 2011-18, Pitt went 53-51 without so much as a nine-win season. But technically, at 6-3 with three regular-season games and at least a bowl game left, Narduzzi’s current Panthers have a chance at 10 wins. Is it likely? No. According to ESPN’s Football Power Index, the Panthers have 12% odds to win their final three ACC tilts, never mind a bowl.
But there’s still hope Pitt will end the 10-year, 10-win drought. There’s hope the Panthers will finish the 2019 season ranked. And there’s still hope they’ll make it back to Bank of America Stadium for the conference title game.
To achieve all three, Pitt has to do something it hasn’t since Dec. 26, 2009: beat North Carolina.
“I truly believe Pitt will win the game,” Wannstedt said. “I don’t think they’re as good as Pitt. Pitt’s playing defense and making plays like they haven’t in a long, long time. It’s going to be cold. I don’t know if those guys from North Carolina will get off the bus.”
“It’s a must-win for Pitt,” Dickerson added. “But I do think they take care of it.”
John McGonigal: jmcgonigal@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jmcgonigal9
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.