Not even 24 hours re­moved from Pitt’s sea­son-open­ing win Wed­nes­day night against Flor­ida State, Jeff Capel had a mes­sage for his team once it re­con­vened at Peter­sen Events Center, where the con­fetti had long been cleared, but where a sense of eu­pho­ria and ac­com­plish­ment still lin­gered.

As Capel saw it, all of his play­ers — from his three fresh­men to his two star soph­o­mores to grad­u­ate trans­fer Eric Ham­il­ton, now at his third col­lege in five years — had to un­der­stand the se­ri­ous­ness of col­lege bas­ket­ball. Noth­ing, es­pe­cially for a re­build­ing pro­gram such as Pitt, could ever be as­sumed in a sport where the un­ex­pected can of­ten be­come the or­di­nary.

Jeff Capel Nicholls State postgame

“It’s ev­ery day,” Capel said. “It’s not one game. It’s not some­times. It’s ev­ery day. It’s the in­vest­ment men­tally and phys­i­cally you have to put into it. We have to un­der­stand that. We have to learn that.”

A loss Satur­day to Nic­holls State showed just how hard that les­son can be de­liv­ered. Against a team picked to fin­ish 11th in the 13-team South­land Con­fer­ence, the Pan­thers were out­played, ou­t­hus­tled and out­classed. They fell be­hind early, blitzed by an en­er­gized op­po­nent that led by eight within the first five min­utes and 10 at half­time, and were never able to re­cover, lead­ing for only 35 sec­onds of a pos­si­ble 40 min­utes in what ended as a 75-70 loss.

Advertise with us

On Wed­nes­day, Pitt was able to start its 2019-20 sea­son on an em­phatic and hope­ful note. Fewer than three days later — as an 18.5-point fa­vor­ite against an op­po­nent over whom it had ev­ery kind of ad­van­tage, be it on the court or in re­sources — it suc­cumbed to di­sas­ter.

It was, if noth­ing else, an il­lus­tra­tion of the in­her­ent wacki­ness that comes with a sport in which games rest upon a group of peo­ple as fickle and in­con­sis­tent as col­lege-age stu­dents. There are few other ex­pla­na­tions for how the same team could beat the ACC’s pre­sea­son No. 5 team only to fall three days later to a small-con­fer­ence foe that was 14-17 a sea­son ago.

To Capel, it was an in­dict­ment of where his team is now, of the ma­tu­rity, fo­cus and per­spec­tive that it lacks.

“We have to grow up,” he said. “We’re not as good as our guys maybe think we are or we think we are. I guess peo­ple have pat­ted them on the back for a night and two days. They won’t be get­ting pats to­day.”

Unen­vi­able as Satur­day’s loss was, it wasn’t un­imag­in­able, at least to Pitt’s play­ers and coaches. Ear­lier in the week (Tues­day), Nic­holls went on the road and took Il­li­nois to over­time be­fore los­ing by eight. In the days af­ter the Flor­ida State win, Capel stressed that fact to his play­ers, so much so that guard Ryan Mur­phy said they were re­minded of it ev­ery five min­utes.

Advertise with us

For the six schol­ar­ship play­ers who have been with the pro­gram the past two sea­sons, they knew such a loss was pos­si­ble. They had ex­pe­ri­enced it last sea­son, when they fell at home to a Niag­ara team that went 13-19 and fired its coach. Now, a new col­lec­tion of play­ers en­dured the same fate and now are left to learn what­ever they can from the pain it caused.

“We aren’t one of these pro­grams yet where you can just show up and you’re go­ing to out-tal­ent ev­ery­one,” Capel said. “That is not us. We aren’t go­ing to just out-tal­ent any­one. I don’t care who it is we play. That’s not who we are. I un­der­stand that. We have to un­der­stand that.”

It was ev­i­dent early that the Pan­thers wouldn’t be able to coast on the tal­ent and pres­tige gap alone. For vir­tu­ally the en­tire af­ter­noon, the dif­fer­ence be­tween the two pro­grams and teams was im­per­cep­ti­ble, if not non-ex­is­tent.

Pitt had five turn­overs in the open­ing 4:17 and didn’t make a field goal un­til nearly six min­utes had elapsed. Xavier John­son, the team’s lead­ing scorer and best player, didn’t score a point in the first 18 min­utes. The Col­o­nels took ad­van­tage of those mis­cues and more, build­ing a lead as large as 12 with 16 min­utes re­main­ing.

They did it with shoot­ing, go­ing 11 of 24 from 3-point range as a team, with D’An­gelo Hunter, a West Vir­ginia trans­fer, and Kevin John­son com­bin­ing to go 7 of 14. When they weren’t mak­ing 3s they were col­lect­ing their own misses and get­ting good looks close to the bas­ket, fin­ish­ing with 19 of­fen­sive re­bounds and 26 sec­ond-chance points.

Advertise with us

“They’re a re­ally streaky team,” said Mur­phy, who scored 28 points, the sec­ond-most in Pitt his­tory for a player off the bench. “If they’re hot, they’re hot. If they’re off, they’re off. To­night, they were hot.”

The Pan­thers mounted a late push, re­main­ing within a pos­ses­sion for much of the game’s fi­nal five min­utes, but they were un­able to fully erase the dam­age that had been done and when they had the chance to, they only con­tin­ued with self-in­flicted wounds. Twice in the fi­nal 30 sec­onds, they had a chance to tie the score, but were un­done by turn­overs, first when Au’Diese Toney was called for a travel with 25 sec­onds re­main­ing and then when Mur­phy had the ball poked away from him with 10 sec­onds re­main­ing. In both in­stances, Pitt trailed by three.

As the final horn sounded, a Nicholls player flung the ball high into the air as he and his teammates, some of whom sprinted from their bench on the opposite side of the court, embraced one another in front of a stunned and rapidly thinning crowd.

“It would have been easy for our guys to be satisfied,” Colonels coach Austin Claunch said of the aftermath of the Illinois loss. “But what I have been preaching the last few days is to raise the bar. We did that today.”

Joy for Nicholls means sorrow for the Panthers, as well as questions about how this team will respond and how it can fix its glaring problems, from its turnovers (21 as a team, nine of which came from Johnson and Trey McGowens, each of whom scored 10 points) to its questionable defense.

Advertise with us

If the past week has proven anything to Pitt’s players and its coaches, it’s a saying that Capel and Murphy, strangely enough, repeated verbatim after the game, something each had learned from their respective fathers – you can’t get too high off your highs and too low off your lows.

They’re words that will have to reverberate and resonate for the Panthers, not only following up Saturday’s loss and in the lead-up to Tuesday’s game at Robert Morris, but for the rest of the season for squad that counted six freshmen or sophomores among the nine players who saw the court Saturday.

Capel has made easily measurable progress in his first 19 months with the program, but it and, especially, the team representing it still have a long, long way to go before setbacks like Saturday’s become inconceivable.

“We have to understand the things we have to do that have to become a habit and that’s when you have a very strong culture,” Capel said. “We’re working to try to build that. It doesn’t just happen because we put up a video about some bricks or we won a game. It’s not words; it’s living it every day. That’s where we have to continue to grow.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.