As Pat Narduzzi said over the weekend, the Panthers are “halfway home.”
Enjoying its first off-week, Pitt is 4-2 with six more regular-season ACC games to go. With the off-week comes time to reflect on what’s happened so far this season. The Panthers are always looking forward, focused on the next opponent. But that doesn’t mean we can’t take a peek in the rear-view mirror.
Here are midseason grades for Pitt’s offense, defense and special teams — and breakdowns on what the Panthers have done right and wrong so far this year:
Offense
Reason for optimism: The Panthers have the potential to score 30 to 35 points every week. The flashes of a potent offense are there.
Taysir Mack, who is on pace for a 1,000-yard season, has exposed cornerbacks in man-to-man coverage for the last month. Maurice Ffrench, despite being slightly limited to a role around the line of scrimmage, is on pace for 908 scrimmage yards in a 13-game season. V’Lique Carter creates mismatches on linebackers as a receiver out of the backfield. And Kenny Pickett has evolved.
Read More
Pickett struggled in Week 1. But he’s noticeably more comfortable after five weeks playing under Mark Whipple. He’s completed 62.8% of his passes for 1,185 yards in his last four starts and guided Pitt on a pair of fourth-quarter touchdown drives. Those with preseason doubts about Pickett ought to be pleasantly surprised.
A good sign for Whipple and Pickett: Pitt, which ranks No. 1 in the country in passing attempts, has favorable matchups through the air the rest of the way, bookended by Syracuse (113th pass defense) and Boston College (115th).
Cause for concern: The Panthers are throwing it so much partly because it’s Whipple’s way of operating. In five years at Massachusetts, the Minutemen’s average national ranking in attempts per game was 22nd. But Whipple is also dialing up pass plays because the run game isn’t working.
“We’d like to run the ball,” running backs coach Andre Powell said last week. “But we like winning.” And Pitt’s run game, which ranks 109th nationally, is doing nothing for the Panthers.
Pitt held a 21-0 lead against UCF in Week 4 and a 26-3 advantage over Duke on Saturday. On 17 combined drives after taking those commanding leads, Pitt ran with its running backs 24 times for 84 yards (3.5 ypc). And against Delaware, Pitt failed to run the ball down an FCS opponent’s throat when its backup quarterback could’ve used the help. That’s discouraging to say the least.
The offensive line, a question mark with four new starters entering the season, is still shaky aside from center Jimmy Morrissey and left guard Bryce Hargrove. Pickett ran for his life against Virginia, and while pass protection has slightly improved, No. 8 has been forced to scramble 39 times in five games.
Pitt’s offense is sporadic. It’s the 18th-least efficient offense in college football, per ESPN’s Bill Connelly. It scored only 37 total points against Ohio and Delaware. And it managed 10 points on six possessions that ended in Penn State territory in Week 3.
“We need to put up more points,” Morrissey said last week. And he’s right.
Grade: C
Defense
Reason for optimism: Narduzzi hasn’t been gung-ho about Pitt’s defense so far this year. “We can play a lot better,” he said after Duke. “I can guarantee you that.” But he’s nitpicking at this point.
This is a defense that, from front to back, is excelling.
Outside Pitt’s facility on the South Side, there was an “oh crap” mentality after losing both Rashad Weaver and Keyshon Camp to season-ending injuries in August. But the Panthers are second nationally in sacks, behind only Ohio State. Emerging star Jaylen Twyman (six sacks) was the Outland Trophy defensive player of the month. Haba Baldonado’s 3.5 sacks is third nationally among freshman linemen. And Patrick Jones recorded a pair of game-changing strip-sacks at Duke this past weekend. The front four alone deserves an A+ for its efforts.
The linebackers have done well, too. Florida transfer Kylan Johnson has four sacks. Cam Bright and Phil Campbell III have each forced a turnover. Saleem Brightwell had 12 tackles against the Blue Devils with Chase Pine and Elias Reynolds still out.
And the secondary is worthy of praise, as well. Teams should avoid throwing at Dane Jackson. Damarri Mathis has held his own. Jason Pinnock, when on the field, has caused havoc blitzing and picked off UCF’s Dillon Gabriel. Damar Hamlin has been steady at safety. And Paris Ford is leading the team in tackles and snagged two interceptions over the weekend.
Defensive coordinator Randy Bates deserves a lot of credit, too, for how he’s schemed this unit for every offense, from an up-tempo UCF to the multifaceted Blue Devils.
Pitt’s defense has allowed 15 touchdowns. Nine of them have come from drives started in Panthers territory, including five of the last six surrendered.
Connelly’s efficiency ratings have Pitt pegged as the 15th-best defense in the country, and the Panthers are playing like it.
Cause for concern: You can argue the defense should hold opponents to field goals on those short-field scenarios. But that’s a tough ask.
You could argue the Panthers need to create more turnovers after recording only two through their first five games. But they just had six on Saturday.
The area Pitt has to focus on defensively is discipline — cutting out the unnecessary personal foul penalties. And this isn’t stemming from Ford’s targeting penalty in Durham, which was a suspect call at best. That officiating decision not included, Pitt’s defense has been penalized 18 times for 208 yards in its last three games.
“We have to cut that out of our game,” Narduzzi said postgame in Durham, after his defense was flagged eight times.
Aside from that, though, Pitt’s defense is in good shape.
Grade: A
Special teams
Reason for optimism: Give punter Kirk Christodoulou props. The Aussie is fifth in the ACC with a 45.6-yard punt average. Fifteen of his 34 punts have been pinned inside opponents’ 20-yard line and 10 have been boomed 50-plus yards.
On the other side, Pitt’s punt block unit scored a touchdown against UCF and lived near Delaware’s punter a couple weeks ago. Credit to Aaron Mathews, Wendell Davis and that unit.
Cause for concern: This is pretty straight forward.
Alex Kessman is 6 for 12 on field-goal tries. He nailed attempts from 38 and 43 yards over the weekend but missed an extra point. The redshirt junior’s accuracy needs to improve, and Narduzzi is confident it will.
As far as the return game, Ffrench hasn’t looked like himself. He had a 50-yard punt return at Duke, but after posting a top-10 kick-return average in 2018, those duties have seemingly been handed over to freshman A.J. Woods. He didn’t do much in his starting debut at Wallace Wade Stadium, gaining 45 yards on three returns.
On punts, Ffrench is averaging 3.1 yards per return on 15 attempts excluding the 50-yarder. He has the potential to pop off, but it isn’t materializing consistently.
Grade: C-
John McGonigal: jmcgonigal@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jmcgonigal9






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.