When he first arrived at Pitt as the school’s volleyball coach in 2013, Dan Fisher didn’t have scenes like the one surrounding him and his players Sunday in mind.

His goals, at that time, were more realistic. He was taking over a program that was mired in mediocrity, with a 48-47 record in the three years before his hiring. He wanted to dream, but in that moment, he didn’t have that luxury. More manageable benchmarks awaited. Chasing Penn State and its, at the time, five national titles? That wasn’t one of them.

“I probably would phrase it this way — we were, I think, 120th in the RPI when I took the job and they were No. 1,” Fisher said. “We weren’t looking at how we could be No. 1. We were looking at how we could get a little better of a recruit. We were looking at the next step.”

On Sunday, as he and the Panthers took to the court at Petersen Events Center, what greeted them was something out of one of his more grandiose visions. A program-record 5,195 fans were in the stands. A top-five opponent representing one of the sport’s most accomplished programs, a foe they swept on the road two nights earlier, stood on the other side of the net. Even for a program that itself sports a top-10 ranking, the setting for Pitt’s eventual five-set loss Sunday against Penn State bordered at times on surreal.

Advertise with us

For those programs, however, it’s an exalted status they’ve both reached, albeit in their own ways. Only one state has multiple volleyball programs ranked in the top 10 of the most recent AVCA coaches’ poll, and over the weekend, Friday night in University Park and Sunday afternoon in Pittsburgh, that designation received the proper settings complete with the proper fanfare.

As much as the end of the football series between Pitt and Penn State, whether temporary or not, was mourned over the past several weeks, much of what people romanticized about the rivalry at its apex in the 1970s and 1980s is still present now, just in a different, more-likely-to-be-overlooked sport.

Pitt's Sabrina Starks, left, and Chinaza Ndee, center, attempt to block a hit by Penn State's Jonni Parker at Petersen Events Center. (Christian Snyder / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The Panthers and Nittany Lions — ranked No. 6 and No. 4, respectively, in the most recent poll — are among the best in college volleyball. Their five-set thriller Sunday reaffirmed as much. Additionally, it has elements of a great rivalry beyond just geographic proximity, namely that the upstart program from the city school is now challenging and, as Friday showed, occasionally besting a towering counterpart that, even several years ago, may have appeared untouchable.

Penn State, led by 41st-year coach Russ Rose, is volleyball royalty, with seven championships to its name, six of which have been won in the past 12 years. Even as Pitt improved under Fisher, Penn State remained a barrier, much more of a white whale than a group of Nittany Lions. The Panthers’ seasons in 2016 and 2017 were ended by Penn State in the NCAA tournament, both in University Park and both in four sets. Pitt had come a far way, but its intrastate foe showed just how much further it had to go.

That imbalance has started to tilt. On Friday, Pitt (11-1) dominated the Nittany Lions (7-2), winning all three sets to snap a 16-match losing streak to them that dated back to 1987, about a decade before its oldest players were born. For Penn State, it was the first time it had been swept in a non-conference home match since 1986.

Advertise with us

“Somebody made a question on Friday saying ‘Hey, Pitt’s really good. Did they just get really good?’ I was like ‘They’ve been really good over the course of 40 years a number of times,’” Rose said. “Let’s not pass it off like they’re just good now. They’ve been good before, but they’re really good now.”

Eight days after the schools’ football teams played for what could conceivably be the last time, Rose was heartened by what he saw over the weekend — that is, a meeting of two regional rivals devoid of “the nonsense that exists in a lot of the other sports over the years.”

“You compete against somebody, but you’re not enemies,” Rose said. “You wish them well. They’re young people. They grow up and have families. It’s not a personal thing. I’m from Chicago. I don’t have a Pitt-Penn State thing. I married a girl from the Pittsburgh area. I have a son that lives in Pittsburgh. They live and die for the Steelers. I would say over the years, that has not always been the case, but certainly Friday and Sunday that was the case, which was great. It’s just two good teams playing.”

That tameness isn’t due to a lack of interest or passion. Before Pitt’s victory Friday, it had sold 3,200 tickets, which was already a program record. Not even 48 hours later, that number had ballooned by more than 60%.

What unfolded on the court didn’t disappoint, in part because the thing that brought those thousands of people together is a phenomenal spectator sport. As the teams go back and forth, tension and anticipation can be felt in crowd, as if everyone’s breath is held until the ball hits the court, a point has been decided and the crowd erupts, as it did so often Sunday.

Advertise with us

“It was pretty unreal,” junior Kayla Lund said. “This is what we’ve wanted. This is what we’ve worked for. We’ve wanted to make a big name for ourselves as a program that shouldn’t be underestimated and is finally having a lot more of the city of Pittsburgh behind our back and a lot more students behind us. It means a lot.”

The match wasn’t a distinctly regional affair, nor were the vast majority of players weaned on the rivalry. Only five players between the two rosters (39 players total) are from Pennsylvania, one fewer than were born outside the United States.

Nonetheless, there’s a hope days like this can continue. The weekend marked the first regular-season meetings between the two programs since 2011 and was only the fourth since 2003. Tournaments heavily populate volleyball teams’ non-conference schedules, but this year, both Pitt and Penn State had an open weekend. Fisher said he would love for regular-season matchups between the two to be more of a regular occurrence.

At a time when the programs have achieved the standing they have, it only makes sense.

“I think it’s great for the state,” Fisher said. “I’ve been trying to schedule them for a while. I’m glad it worked out this year.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG