Nearly 29 months after taking over as Pitt’s athletic director in 2017, there’s still one thing about what Heather Lyke inherited that doesn’t gnaw away at her as much as it befuddles her.
“We don’t have a track,” Lyke told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette last week, her voice tinged with a sense of bewilderment and frustration. “That is not OK.”
Indeed, what might be the most rudimentary of all athletic facilities — a proper 400-meter track — is one Pitt doesn’t have, other than the cramped loop that encircles the courts of the almost 68-year-old Fitzgerald Field House. It’s something Lyke is looking to rectify with her proposed Victory Heights facilities plan. More than that, though, the absence of such a track embodies a larger series of issues that predated her tenure.
Whether measured by the on-field and on-court success of its teams or the facilities in which it competes, Pitt has fallen behind its major conference peers, perhaps even significantly so.
While it’s a fact recognized by Lyke, it was codified in late June, when the Panthers finished 137th (of 295 Division I schools) in the standings for the Learfield IMG Directors’ Cup, an award given annually by the National Association of Collegiate Athletic Directors (NACDA) and USA Today using a point system based on a school’s finish in NCAA championships. Pitt’s finish put it behind, in order, Vermont, Middle Tennessee State, Montana State, Illinois State and New Hampshire. Additionally, it was 43 spots behind the next-closest Power 5 school (No. 94 Kansas State) and 50 spots behind the next-closest ACC counterpart (No. 87 Boston College).
With Pitt’s fall sports teams returning to competition this month, there’s a renewed sense of hope that comes with any blank slate, a chance to start over and move on from whatever shortcomings defined the school’s athletic programs over the past several years. From those overseeing the department, it’s an opportunity to showcase some much-needed improvement that leaders believe is on the way.
Read More
“”I don’t know if it’s negligence or priorities, but we’ve got to fix the absence of a true commitment to comprehensive excellence,” Lyke said.
Since 2013, the year Pitt began competing in the ACC, a major-conference school hadn’t finished lower than 121st in the Directors’ Cup standings, and there had never been a gap larger than 14 places between the last-place Power 5 institution and the second-to-last such school. Granted, Pitt has never fared well in those standings, having not placed higher than 85th since the 2006-07 academic year, and with only 19 sports, it isn’t well-equipped in such a statistical competition against schools with many more teams and resources.
Generally speaking, many of its teams are struggling. The men’s basketball program disintegrated in the latter half of the decade after being one of the country’s top programs for more than a 10-year stretch. The women’s basketball team hasn’t fared much better in the ACC, going 78-107 (and 24-72 in conference games) in that time. During that same span, men’s and women’s soccer have gone 28-62-15 and 29-72-7, respectively. Though it’s coming off an ACC Coastal Division title, the football program has been average for much of the past four decades, finishing a season with more than eight wins only three times in the past 36 years. The baseball program, faced with the challenge of competing in a league of mostly southern schools, has gone just 58-120 in ACC games.
“In real general terms, I think we were underperforming,” Lyke said. “I think there were opportunities to enhance the programs in a number of ways and I do believe it starts with the people. We went out and recruited what I think are some of the absolute best coaches in the country who lead our programs now. I think it starts there.”
Indeed, the biggest source of confidence comes not from blind optimism, but the fact that changes have been afoot in Lyke’s time.
Though one of the openings predated her arrival (wrestling), Lyke has hired eight head coaches for Pitt’s existing programs, representing nearly half those positions. It’s a mark that is unusually high, even for a new athletic director looking to make their mark, but given the Panthers’ competitive pitfalls, such swift, drastic changes make sense.
““It’s significant,” Lyke said. “I can’t undervalue it. It’s the most important thing we do, hiring good people. Coaches really directly impact the experience of our student-athletes. Having the right leadership who aspire to be the ACC champions, wanting that and not coasting and not being comfortable and taking on the challenge, but also bringing in coaches who have incredible confidence, conviction and courage in what they’re doing and why they’re doing it, it was really important. It starts there.”
Like it was for women’s tennis, if a program fundamentally isn’t positioned to excel, it could be eliminated entirely — the handling of which was criticized by both current and former players — and replaced with a sport where the metaphorical ceiling is higher.
Financially, Pitt still lags behind many of its conference peers. In 2017, the most recent year available, it spent $89.93 million on athletics, according to Department of Education data, ranking it ninth of the ACC’s 15 members. While its expenses increased nearly 36 percent over a five-year span dating to 2012 — the third-sharpest rise of any ACC school in that time — even that improvement showed just how far Pitt had to climb, something still evident to Lyke through things like 16 of the school’s 19 teams training out of the non-air-conditioned Field House.
“Football and basketball are definitely economic engines for this department and all Power 5 schools,” Lyke said. “That’s the reality. But I believe in comprehensive excellence. I’ve said it a lot. I really think that success is contagious. I do feel that those other 16 sports were not put in a position for success.”
Nonetheless, there are reasons for hope.
The volleyball program has been a beacon of what’s possible and begins the 2019 season ranked in the top 15 nationally. Pat Narduzzi’s football program is coming off an ACC championship appearance. In its second season under Keith Gavin, Lyke’s first coaching hire, wrestling finished No. 16 among Division I programs. Jeff Capel led men’s basketball to a six-win improvement in his first season. Even for some of the smaller programs, like men’s and women’s soccer, there’s potential for significant progress, as they’re each led by a coach with a national championship to his name (Jay Vidovich and Randy Waldrum, respectively).
But change, at least the kind Lyke envisions, only comes so quickly — even if they’re on track to achieve it.
““It’s not one person,” Lyke said. “There’s no magic dust. It takes time doing it the right way. I’ll tell you — they’re aggressively recruiting the caliber of athletes we need to win in the ACC. I’m confident we’re going to see continued improvement across the board in all of our sports. I think we’re starting to see that in bits and pieces.”
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.