At first thought, the idea of luck existing in and determining the outcome of a game of skill seems ludicrous. How is it exactly that abilities honed through careful and diligent work over many years can be occasionally trumped by seemingly inexplicable, even supernatural forces?

In a sport like college basketball -- with its hundreds of moving parts, all executed by imperfect, still-developing players – there can sometimes be little that separates a win from a loss. As those minuscule moments add up, they can be the difference between a triumphant season and a disappointing one and, yes, perhaps even a lucky team and an unlucky one.

This season’s Pitt men’s basketball team may well be living proof.

At 12-15 and losers of 10 consecutive games, the Panthers have seen some of their hopes gradually dashed over the past several weeks, as setback after setback has accumulated. Painful as some of those defeats may have been, they’re not necessarily indicative of a bad team. Pitt, for all of its shortcomings and limitations, may just be snake-bitten.

Advertise with us

With only four games remaining in the regular season, a stretch that begins Wednesday at home against Clemson, the Panthers are rated as the fifth-unluckiest team of 353 Division I squads (and first among major-conference programs) by KenPom.com, a popular and widely used college basketball statistical website. Luck, as founder Ken Pomeroy explains it, is “the deviation in winning percentage between a team’s actual record and their expected record.” Phrased differently, Pitt is better than its current mark.

It’s reassuring in a way to a team in search of silver linings and encouragement, but it’s not an idea embraced by its coach.

“I don’t believe in ‘unlucky,’” Pitt coach Jeff Capel said Monday. “I just think we haven't done the things necessary to be able to finish. Whether it’s making free throws, whether it’s getting one rebound, whether it’s stepping up and making a shot. Just whatever it is, I think the last six games, right at about the final media timeout, it’s been at the most a two-possession game. Whether we’re winning or we’re down, it’s been that. In each game, we haven’t been able to make the necessary plays in order to win the game. And we have to change that. It has nothing to do with luck.”

By his own admission, Capel isn’t as analytically driven as some of his coaching peers. In that sense, he’s much more traditional, even espousing the oft-used Bill Parcells line that a team is what its record says. Right now for the Panthers, that record is a below-average one.

The way they have arrived at those wins and losses, though, is more nuanced.

Advertise with us

Three of their past five losses have come by six points or fewer, with those games having been decided by a combined 11 points. In seven of its 14 ACC games, Pitt has either trailed or led by four points or fewer in the final four minutes of a game. It is 1-6 in those games, with the lone victory coming in overtime against Louisville. Even before conference play began, two of its three non-ACC losses came by just two points, as it lost to Iowa and Niagara after missing contested layups in the final five seconds that would have given Pitt the lead.

It’s the type of broader misfortune that can be boiled down to specific moments. With a chance to put his team up by as many as four with 20 seconds remaining in what ended as a two-point loss at Wake Forest, Xavier Johnson, an 81.4 percent free-throw shooter at the time, missed the front end of a one-and-one, with the Demon Deacons sending it to overtime on the other end. In an 82-69 loss at Clemson last month, Pitt saw an opponent that had been shooting 30.6 percent from 3-point range that season make 51.9 percent of its 27 attempts. An eight-point loss at Georgia Tech last week was defined in some part by the Panthers, who had been making 71 percent of their free throws, going just 20-of-38 (52.6 percent) from the line.

Each anecdote was a statistical deviation from the mean at a most inopportune time, but those instances could just as easily be described as a failure to execute.

“If we make a free throw at Wake Forest, maybe we win that game,” Capel said. “That’s not luck. We missed a free throw. Or if we get one rebound — that’s not luck. We have to be better in those situations. If we make free throws against Georgia Tech, maybe that’s different. We played great defense against Markell Johnson, he hit a hell of a shot against us for N.C. State that gave them the lead for good. So you can look at each game and look at some situations where we have to adjust some things. Maybe a call didn’t go our way, but whatever it is, we have to be able to make the necessary plays in order to win, and we haven't done that.”

If there’s some solace to be found for Pitt, it’s this – of the four ACC teams directly ahead of the Panthers on KenPom’s luck measurement, they face three in their final four regular-season games. A matchup of even the most ill-fated of squads will produce a winner.

Advertise with us

As they prepare for those games, Pitt’s players and coaches can’t concern themselves with whatever has slipped beyond their grasp over the past three months. Ultimately, their fate is in their own hands.

Well, mostly.

“We’ve been saying it all season and I know it’s repetitive, but it’s true -- when we watch film, it’s us,” senior Jared Wilson-Frame said Monday. “It’s little things that we’re doing that are giving people this relaxation on the court, letting them get into a zone. You let any player get into a zone, any team get into a zone, they’re going to be better off, so we’ve got to do better of making sure we’re in our zone instead of letting other people get in theirs.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG