Inside a musty gym near the banks of Alaska’s Cook Inlet in November 1995, the four men tasked with resurrecting Pitt’s men’s basketball program were interspersed among the thousands gathered there for Duke’s game against Old Dominion.
On the court of Sullivan Arena was Jeff Capel III, the Blue Devils’ standout junior guard, who that day had the unusual chore of squaring off against his father, Old Dominion head coach Jeff Capel Jr. Sitting a few feet from the elder Capel was Milan Brown, a 24-year-old assistant coach in his first season on the Monarchs’ staff. On the opposite bench was Tim O’Toole, a thirty-something in his first season working under legendary Duke coach Mike Krzyzewski. Sitting in the stands and absorbing all the action was Capel’s younger brother, Jason, a prodigious 15-year-old prospect Duke was already recruiting.
Nearly a quarter-century later, they’re back together, not only under one roof, but, unlike that late fall day all those years ago, on the same staff. With O’Toole, Brown and Jason Capel now serving as assistant coaches under Jeff Capel, Pitt is the only program in college basketball with three former Division I head coaches on staff.
In his quest to bring together a group of individuals whom he could trust and whose coaching acumen he could lean on, Capel created something of an oddity, one that has the kind of experience that may make it perfectly suited to help lift a program from the laughingstock of the conference to a championship contender.
“It’s hard, but it’s a true statement — it’s a totally different life moving over eight to 10 inches to the next chair,” Brown said. “It’s a totally different mindset, a totally different responsibility. I think we have a good understanding of the weight that’s on his back.”
■ ■ ■
Read More
The story of the staff’s construction is one of happenstance. It wasn’t, as Jeff Capel put it, about having three former head coaches; it was about having three really good coaches.
Each man was selected, in part, because of a deep bond established over decades. O’Toole was an assistant coach at Duke during Capel’s junior and senior seasons. Brown worked for two seasons under Capel’s father at Old Dominion in the mid-1990s, not even three years after he had graduated from Howard. In the case of Jason Capel, well, the connection is obvious.

O’Toole, the oldest of the group at 54, has the lengthiest and most eclectic resume of the trio, with stints at 10 different schools over a coaching career of more than 30 years. From 1998-2006, he was the head coach at Fairfield, his alma mater, where he went 112-121.
“This was something special,” said O’Toole, who came to Pitt from Cal. “If you’re going to move 3,000 miles away, it better be really special. Jeff is that type of guy.”
Brown had the longest run as a head coach, spending seven seasons at Mount St. Mary’s before moving on to Holy Cross, where he coached from 2010-15. Over those 12 years, he went 164-203, highlighted by an NCAA tournament appearance with Mount St. Mary’s in 2008. He arrived at Pitt after three seasons as an assistant at College of Charleston.
After an accomplished playing career at North Carolina, Jason Capel spent one season as an assistant at Appalachian State before being promoted to head coach in April 2010, making the then-30 year old the youngest head coach in Division I at the time (Robert Morris’ Andy Toole nabbed that title about three weeks later). He coached there for four seasons and later worked three seasons as a broadcaster before jumping at the only thing he said could have lured him back into coaching — a chance to work alongside his brother.
Though the work they do is collaborative by nature — three men working toward a common goal — their roles are specified to an extent. A native of White Plains, N.Y., O’Toole has strong recruiting connections in the Northeast and works primarily with the Panthers’ big men. There’s slightly more overlap between Brown and Jason Capel, both of whom recruit heavily in the Mid-Atlantic and South, though the former works with the team’s guards while the latter, a 6-foot-8 wing as a player, vacillates between the two positional groups.
Between the three men, there aren’t just different skills, but different personalities. O’Toole is a reservoir of perpetual energy. Brown is admittedly mellower, with a calm and soothing voice to boot, while Jason Capel is something of a mix.
Together, though, they have the same goal — help elevate the Pitt program and, in the process, make their boss’ life as easy and his time as maximized as possible.
■ ■ ■
Head coaches are the face of the program, but the assistantsare often what make it go. There’s the two or three hours of on-court instruction daily, with Jeff Capel overseeing it all. Recruiting is the life-blood of the sport and a daily activity for assistants who make calls, send texts, write letters and shoot off emails to establish and fortify relationships with top players. There’s the process of scouting those players and determining which ones to pursue. If a current player wants to work out away from practice, one of them is often brought in to help, even during odd hours.
The minutiae of operating a program and the bulk of that work falling on those three has a purpose.
“We know how we felt as head coaches,” Jason Capel said. “You’re the final answer for everything, but there are some things you shouldn’t have to answer. They can be taken care of for you so you can focus on something greater.”
The sense of prestige and the sliver of fame that comes with being a head coach gets mostly abandoned when that person becomes an assistant. What’s a jarring adjustment for some has been embraced by Pitt’s assistants. For Brown, it was a chance to return to the intensive individual workouts with players for which a head coach doesn’t always have the time. Even in his work as a broadcaster, Capel never strayed far from coaching, sitting in on film sessions and staff meetings while doing scouting of his own for games he was calling.
Those traits and that collective selflessness have made what could have been a tenuous situation work.
“It’s kind of like what Shakespeare said — in some way, every man is my superior,” O’Toole said. “I’m not better than anybody. I’m not worse than anybody. There’s not a job that we won’t do. If we need to do laundry, we’ll do laundry. If we have to clean up the gym, we’re cleaning up the gym. It is what it is. When you’re trying to build the proper culture, it’s not about ‘I’ and it’s not about my ego — it’s about how are we going to get this thing done?”
Part of that harmony has come from the man under whom the other three work. Jeff Capel actively seeks the opinion of his assistants, whether it’s an adjustment in a game, something an opponent is doing that can be countered or whether a certain recruit would fit what they’re trying to build. Even if Capel disagrees or opts not to use whatever piece of information he is given in the moment, he’ll usually pocket it for later.
That arrangement comes from a familial vibe established over the nearly 25 years they’ve all known each other. O’Toole, who most recently spent two seasons at Stanford and two at Cal, compared it to a Silicon Valley think tank in which all parties involved are continually learning from one another. Even with that, though, there are boundaries that are recognized.
“At least from my standpoint, we feel like we work with Jeff,” Brown said. “It doesn’t feel like we work for him. All three of us understand, though, we work for him. We understand that.”
In a profession as transient as coaching, a given situation, as good as it may be, only lasts so long. Each of the three acknowledged there’s a desire to one day get another opportunity to a head coach, provided it’s the right move for themselves and their families.
Such thoughts, however, mean little right now. All three are enjoying a job working for a boss they respect and who respects them. Besides, like any good coach, they’re far too immersed in the work at hand to be thinking of anything else, especially when the fate of the fragile program they inherited rests in their hands.
“We’re all different in our own way, but the biggest thing is we all understood when we came here that we were trying to build something special and we had to be in the foxhole and be ready to really grind to do it,” Jason Capel said. “I think he hired three guys that are grinders, guys that are going to work hard and are passionate about what they do. I think we’re off to a good start of doing something we know is going to be pretty cool.”
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG
Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.