EL PASO, Texas — Darrin Hall spoke as the lone voice for Pitt’s 19 seniors, and in some ways, the perfect mouthpiece for the Pat Narduzzi tenure of Pitt football to date.

Hall came in with Narduzzi and has been with the Panthers for all four years of his coach’s regime, so who better to ask what this stretch of program history has amounted to thus far?

“This is a step in the right direction,” Hall said shortly after Pitt’s 14-13 loss Monday to Stanford in the Sun Bowl. “We got back to a bowl game, which we didn’t do last year. We made it to the ACC championship, which was never done before. Really, I think we set the platform for these young guys to come up and have a big year next year. We’re upset, we wanted this one bad, but as far as next year and the years after, I think we set it in the right direction.”

It’s up for debate which way Pitt’s compass is pointing. If a team goes 0-12, it’s obvious changes must be made. If a team goes 12-0, the goal is to keep as many facets the same as possible.

Advertise with us

But what about 7-7, with a division title that put you one win from a New Year’s Six bowl, combined with three losses by more than 30 points, a slip-up to the last-place team in the ACC and a three-game slide to end the season — is that a disappointing run?

“I don’t think so. I really don’t,” Narduzzi said. “Our goal is to get to a championship and win an ACC championship. We got there, we had a chance, we didn’t play great. That was our first time there. I think we rebounded and played a lot better in a bowl game against a quality opponent. Then you see what happened to Notre Dame against that Clemson football team. … We got there. There was a lot of people that would love to be there. We won the Coastal Division. You can walk away from that season saying we were Coastal Division champions. That ‘C’ word is still on this football team and this 2018 senior class.”

Of course, it’s a more nuanced discussion than that, and likely doesn’t boil down that simply for much of Pitt’s fan base. Fresh off his sophomore year, his first full season as a starter, quarterback Kenny Pickett didn’t always find the right spot in El Paso, but he might have been on the money in his assessment of Pitt’s 2018 campaign.

“I’d say there’s a lot of missed opportunities,” Pickett admitted. “It’s a success — like coach said, we’re champions, we’re Coastal champs, no one can take that away from us. But there’s also a lot of opportunities that we should’ve taken advantage of and we didn’t.”

There was the 38-35 blunder at conference doormat North Carolina in Week 4, but the final four defeats of the season shared similar faults in how they came to be. Pitt averaged 10 points per game against Notre Dame, Miami, Clemson and Stanford, with three of those putrid offensive performances coming in the final three.

Advertise with us

Pickett rarely flashed the form of his freshman finale against Miami, and an offensive line with three new starters was often a mixed bag, but offensive coordinator Shawn Watson likely deserves a good bit of the blame. From a big-picture view, Pitt is 12-14 since Narduzzi hitched that unit to him, after going 16-10 with his first two play-callers.

“We’re just going to continue to look at what we’re doing, how we’re doing it and evaluate every part of the program,” Narduzzi said, which could be interpreted as routine coachspeak or an ominous statement.

“We’ll just kind of continue to go back to the drawing board and evaluate what we’re doing.”

Nevertheless, when asked to publicly assess his confidence level in Watson, he deflected.

“High,” Narduzzi said, then repeated himself before pointing a finger at the Stanford offense. “High. What’s their confidence in their coordinator? They had 208 yards, we had 344. I don’t know.”

Advertise with us

That should say more about Narduzzi’s defense, which ended its first year with coordinator Randy Bates on a brilliant note. And yet, redshirt sophomore defensive end Rashad Weaver — arguably that side’s top player already — would take no solace in it Monday while answering a question about whether the defense can carry momentum into 2019.

“No,” Weaver said, flatly. “They scored more points than us, and it was all against the defense. They didn’t score on special teams or against the offense. They scored 14 points. I guess you could say that’s low in college football nowadays, but they score one touchdown or none, and we win. So no, we did not play good enough.”

Regardless of if you believe Pitt made strides in Narduzzi’s fourth year, or argue the progress is stagnant at best, it couldn’t hurt the Panthers to mimic Weaver’s mentality. The appetite for good enough might be waning.

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.