With an empty arena — save for a handful of employees sweeping the aisles and picking up trash — serving as the backdrop, Xavier Johnson got back to work Monday night.

Not even 45 minutes after his Pitt team was stunned by Niagara, 71-70, Johnson was back on the Petersen Events Center court, hoisting up free throw after free throw long after the people who came to the building to see him do such things had left.

A prodigious freshman who leads the team in scoring, Johnson willed the Panthers back in a game they very easily could have lost by more, scoring 10 of their final 18 points on his way to a game-high 19. But in the moments after the loss, it wasn’t those numbers and those plays that stuck with him. It was the four turnovers. It was the would-have-been winning layup that rattled in and out in the final seconds after he created an open look for himself with a well-executed pump-fake.

What perhaps stung the most, though, were the three free throws (on five attempts) he missed, valuable missed opportunities that, along with a smattering of other factors, made the loss hurt the way it did. As he harbored that disappointment, Johnson did the only thing he believed he could — try to make sure it doesn’t happen again.

Advertise with us

If there’s a silver lining to be had in a loss to the Purple Eagles it’s that it could be a searing reminder of an all-important lesson in college basketball, especially for a relatively young team such as Pitt. If a team doesn’t come ready to play and bring with it the requisite concentration and intensity, it can lose to any opponent, regardless of what school or conference from which it comes.

Whether something good comes from it is, starting in the late hours of Monday night, up to them.

“We’ve got to get back to being us,” senior Jared Wilson-Frame said. “Our identity is not what we showed on the court tonight. It’s what we showed in those games we did win, when we played good defense, when we played hard and played together. We have to get back to that. If not, stuff like this will happen a lot.”

The crux of that lesson — that any game is a losable one — was embodied by Niagara. Ranked 270th of 353 Division I teams by the website KenPom.com entering the matchup, the Purple Eagles are the lowest-rated team that Pitt has lost to dating to when the website began ranking teams (the 2001-02 season).

Capel reacts to loss to Niagara

The loss was the product of a sound defensive strategy from Niagara, which held the Panthers to a season-worst 0.91 points per possession, but more than anything else, it came because an undermanned and less-talented team outworked a major-conference foe playing at home. It was a reality summed up in numbers, such as a 38-31 rebounding advantage, and in moments, like in the final two minutes, when a Niagara player missed a jumper only for one of his teammates, as Pitt’s players waited for it to go out of bounds, to sprint after the ball and throw it off an opponent out of bounds to allow his team to maintain possession.

Advertise with us

Is there something to be learned from that?

“Never take nothing for granted,” said freshman Au’Diese Toney, who had a team-high nine rebounds and was the only Pitt player to have more than three. “They played their [butts] off.”

While there is potential long-term value in a loss — falling to Niagara could help prevent Pitt from looking past a future opponent in the same way — Panthers coach Jeff Capel doesn’t see why it’s necessary to experience in the first place.

“Just like I don’t believe in moral victories, I don’t believe you need to lose or go through something to learn a lesson,” Capel said. “I don’t believe in that. We just got outplayed [Monday night] in every facet of the game.”

Though Wilson-Frame and Capel shouldered blame for the loss, either by not having the team prepared to play or by not providing the kind of leadership they felt was necessary, the Panthers inexperience could be seen as a culprit for an off and inexplicable night. Their three freshman — Johnson, Toney and Trey McGowens — carried them offensively, finishing with 14 of their 24 made field goals and seven of their 10 made 3-pointers, but they also exemplified the sloppiness that plagued Pitt for much of the game, accounting for 13 of its season-high 18 turnovers.

Advertise with us

Whether the pain of the loss translates into something positive and productive for Pitt remains to be seen. Only nine games into the season, the Panthers now have shown the extent of their unevenness, proving they’re just as capable of being a missed layup away from beating a ranked opponent on the road as they are falling at home to a 2-4 Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference team without its best player. As this team’s identity and effectiveness becomes clearer in the coming months, the loss will either stand as an uncharacteristic stumble in an otherwise successful season or a harbinger or caution, that this team wasn’t quite as good as it looked on its way to a 7-1 record.

A matchup Saturday at West Virginia, a preseason top-15 team, will provide the first signal of what direction this Pitt team might head. Rest assured, though, the challenge it is about to face is one it will be ready for, unlike it was Monday.

“As much as I can say, I don’t think there’s anything I’m going to say,” Wilson-Frame said. “I’m pretty sure we’ll be ready for that game, let alone what happened today. Everybody who watches college basketball or is a part of college basketball knows the importance of that rivalry and how big it is, not only to the cities, but the programs and schools behind them. I don’t think there’s going to be much talking. We’re just going to be focused and ready to fight. It’s called a brawl for a reason.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.