IOWA CITY, Iowa — As Xavier Johnson and Trey McGowens thumbed through their phones late Tuesday after Pitt’s one-point loss to Iowa, the Panthers’ freshmen saw they, to a certain extent, had arrived. The phones to which Johnson and McGowens returned, after a game in which they combined for 28 of their team’s 68 points, were filled with words of praise from voices such as Steelers linebacker Ryan Shazier and his more than 300,000 Twitter followers, turning young men who were high-schoolers mere months ago into something more.

Their biggest win of the season had come six days earlier, but that victory — a 75-73 triumph against Saint Louis in Brooklyn — came in front of only a few hundred fans in a cavernous NBA arena, the kind of setting that allowed something as faint as a shoe squeak on the court to echo from the floor to the rafters. On Tuesday, they played against a top-15 opponent from a major conference and did so in front of their first national television audience of the season, providing them with the kind of stage they had yet to have.

On that platform, Johnson and McGowens showcased the full freshman experience — brilliant play that was sometimes counteracted by easily avoidable mistakes. They were perhaps the biggest reason Pitt led a ranked foe on the road by six with 12 minutes remaining, but they also played a role in Pitt’s second-half offensive woes that ultimately deprived it of a monumental win.

Johnson, who finished with a team-high 18 points, showed poise and comfort, regularly blowing past defenders and making artful finishes at the rim. On a court featuring older, more experienced opponents, he was the best player.

Advertise with us

“I don’t even care about the crowd or anything,” Johnson said. “I just play basketball.”

In a first half in which he scored 10 points and pulled down four rebounds, McGowens dazzled the most in a single moment. With about four minutes remaining before halftime, he bypassed what would have been an open 3-pointer, streaked by a charging defender with a crafty behind-the-back move and jump-stepped for a layup to push Pitt’s lead to four, showing in a four-second burst exactly why he was Pitt’s highest-rated recruit in six years.

As the game wore on, though, their play waned, along with their team’s fortunes.

After scoring a combined 22 points on 8 of 13 shooting in the first half, they went 1 of 7 for six points in the second. Though he was an active part of the game early, McGowens seemed slightly removed from it later on, ineffectiveness that limited him to 11 second-half minutes. Johnson’s assertiveness in the first half sometimes turned into carelessness in the second. The two accounted for six of Pitt’s 12 second-half turnovers.

“I thought they really tried to take Xavier out of the game, to try to deny him,” Pitt coach Jeff Capel said. “I thought we just got a little sloppy. When you come on the road and you’re playing against a really good team on the road, in their place, you have to minimize mistakes. We did that in the first half. In the second half, that’s something we failed to do.”

Advertise with us

As Iowa stormed back in front of a re-energized home crowd to take the lead, the Panthers turned increasingly to their two oldest players, senior Jared Wilson-Frame and graduate transfer Sidy N’Dir. The pair combined for 10 of Pitt’s first 12 points in the second half, allowing the Panthers to regain a six-point lead after they squandered it in the opening minutes of the half.

Wilson-Frame and N’Dir, who both started the game on the bench, played 15:39 and 16:31, respectively, in the second half. Of the four Panthers’ players with the most second-half minutes Tuesday, three of them were at least juniors, with Johnson, who played all but the game’s final 10 seconds, the exception.

“We’re old guys,” N’Dir said. “I’ve been in NCAA tournaments. It’s a game of runs. They got those seven points and we knew after that timeout, we were going to come back anyway.”

Those 10 seconds Johnson missed after fouling out proved to be conclusive. Pitt had two opportunities at winning shots but failed to connect on both. The first and best of those came from McGowens, who showed with a single drive the Jekyll-and-Hyde nature of college freshmen, no matter how talented they are. The 6-foot-3 guard had the speed and skill to get through the Iowa defense and to the rim, but once there, he looked to have rushed a decent look with taller Hawkeyes defenders standing around him.

For players, whether it was McGowens on the court or Johnson watching from the bench, it was a learning experience.

Advertise with us

“For coaches, it’s a good thing,” Johnson said. “They can see who can actually bring the ball up and play point with me out of the game. It was hard for me because I knew I could have helped the team out. We could have gotten a better shot. Not saying Trey’s shot was a bad shot. He tried his best to get to the rim.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG