(This is Part III of our three-part series. Part I can be found here. Part II can be found here.)

The request was simple, or at least that’s what Dave Wannstedt thought.

In 2010, heading into what would be his final year as Pitt’s head football coach, Wannstedt noticed some marks on the carpet of the Panthers’ football facility, blotches that looked like stains or cigarette burns. He went to university leadership with a plea — $260,000 for new carpeting to make the building housing the program look a little more presentable.

It turned out to be a more complicated question than anticipated.

Advertise with us

“I was being told by administration there was no money,” Wannstedt said. “So that’s how I was looking at it — if there’s not enough money to put new carpet down, and other places are building new facilities, if we’re that broke as an athletic department, we better get into a new conference.”

It didn’t take long for Pitt to find that fat-pocketed savior, one that provided it with enough money to buy much more than just carpeting. (Mark Nordenberg, Pitt’s chancellor at the time, said that while he had no knowledge of the request, such a refusal wouldn’t have been because of a lack of funds.)

For any on-field and on-court struggles that have beset Pitt after its move from the Big East to the ACC in 2013, the university and its athletic department have thrived away from those venues of play, hauling in record amounts of revenue as a member of a much more lucrative league.

In the scramble for survival that was conference realignment, Pitt secured a coveted space on a lifeboat as some others were left to sink.

Pitt to the ACC: financial implications Pitt has been in the ACC for five years, a time that has seen it make a good deal more money but also spend more of that new cash to keep up with its conference mates. Recruiting expenses nearly doubled from 2012, Pitt’s final year in the Big East, compared to 2016 figures, the most recent data available. Pitt also saw a more than 47 percent increase in revenue during this time, and conference payouts and coach’s salaries have all seen an upward trend. Average ACC athletic dept. revenues, 2012-16

Advertise with us

Created with Highstock 6.1.2$74.6$74.6$77.9$77.9$85$85$90.2$90.2$95.5$95.5$57.6$57.6$66.1$66.1$70.5$70.5$75.3$75.3$84.8$84.8ACC averagePitt20122013201420152016$0$25$50$75$100$125

Average ACC athletic dept. spending, 2012-16

Created with Highstock 6.1.2$71.1$71.1$74.8$74.8$79.5$79.5$87.4$87.4$92$92$57.6$57.6$66.1$66.1$70.5$70.5$75.3$75.3$84.8$84.8ACC averagePitt20122013201420152016$0$25$50$75$100

Average ACC recruiting expenses, 2013-16

Created with Highstock 6.1.2ACC averagePitt201220132016$0$500000$1000000$1500000$2000000

Advertise with us

Pitt conference payouts, 2010-17

Created with Highstock 6.1.2Acedemic year/conference9.369.369.599.5910.1910.1918.8618.8625.0425.0423.623.626.3426.34Pitt conference payout2010-11Big East2011-12Big East2012-13Big East2013-14ACC2014-15ACC2015-16ACC2016-17ACC$10$20$30$0

Pitt men’s basketball head coach salaries, 2008-17

Created with Highstock 6.1.2Acedemic year0.940.941.241.241.541.541.671.672.282.281.971.973.063.062.322.322.322.321.831.83Salary (in millions)2007-082008-092009-102010-112011-122012-132013-142014-152015-162016-17$0$1$2$3$4

Pitt football head coach salaries, 2008-17

Advertise with us

Created with Highstock 6.1.2Acedemic year0.920.920.950.951.381.381.81.81.941.941.531.531.631.631.651.651.771.772.892.89Salary (in millions)2007-082008-092009-102010-112011-122012-132013-142014-152015-162016-17$0$1$2$3

Sources: U.S. Department of Education, individual universities' federal tax returns | Post-Gazette

A brave, and profitable, new world

The benefits of such a seismic shift are complex and far-reaching. The payouts a school receives from its conference, however, often paint a reliable picture of where an athletic department stands financially.

For the Panthers, that change has been drastic. In its final year (2012-13) in the Big East, the university received $10.19 million from the league, according to federal tax returns. The following year, its first in the ACC, it got $18.86 million, and the year after that, it brought in $25.04 million.

Advertise with us

During the 2017 fiscal year, the most recent year of tax returns available, Pitt received a $26.34 million payout from the ACC. By contrast, former Big East mates South Florida, Connecticut and Cincinnati received $8.88 million, $8.09 million and $7.66 million, respectively, from the American Athletic Conference, a geographically sprawling conference consisting largely of former Conference USA members and Big East expats unable to land in a Power Five league.

“It was dire straits to make sure you got to be a part of the key players,” said Rodney Paul, a sports economist and professor of sports management at Syracuse’s David B. Falk College of Sport and Human Dynamics. “You wanted to go on ahead and be a part of the big conferences. That’s where you had to be.”

With that sudden influx of tens of millions of dollars, the beneficiaries of realignment have taken different approaches to reinvestment. Most commonly, according to Paul and other economists, that newfound money is channeled into inflated salaries for coaches and administrators, as well as recruiting-related expenses — new or renovated facilities, chartered flights to visit prospects from across the country and the like.

In that sense, Pitt isn’t drastically different.

Then-athletic director Steve Pederson’s salary increased by 44.8 percent from the 2013 fiscal year to the 2014 fiscal year, from $577,083 to $835,417. Beyond that, money was poured into athletics, turning what was a cash-strapped department into a more robust one. In 2016, according to the most recent data from the U.S. Department of Education, Pitt spent $84.83 million on athletics (ninth among the ACC’s 15 schools), a 32.1 percent increase from the $57.61 million it spent in 2012, which would rank 14th among the ACC’s 15 current schools. That percentage increase was the third-highest in the ACC. In that same stretch, the Panthers’ football budget increased by 44.9 percent, rising all the way to $27.42 million in 2016 — the fourth-highest in the ACC behind only Clemson, Florida State and Miami — and recruiting expenses increased by 46.7 percent, the second-largest climb in the ACC.

Advertise with us

Coaching salaries didn’t experience the same sharp spike in that four-year period, but under athletic director Heather Lyke, that has changed abruptly, as well.

Since coming aboard in March 2017, Lyke has hired eight new head coaches and given football coach Pat Narduzzi a seven-year extension. While financial terms of those contracts are not subject to open records requests, the understanding among industry sources is that Pitt is paying much more for its coaches than it was previously.

That money dedicated to coaches and their staffs is a way of luring talented newcomers and rewarding successful coaches already in place, something sorely needed for an athletic department that was 111th out of 291 schools in the 2017-18 Learfield Cup standings, an annual ranking of athletic departments by the National Association of Collegiate Directors of Athletics.

“I firmly believe unless you’re continually investing in those programs, you’re falling behind,” Lyke said in mid-August. “We have a five-year facility master plan. There are football elements to that we absolutely have to invest in every year. You have to keep things fresh, keep things current and continue to improve.”

Pitt AD Heather Lyke speaks to the football team shortly after her hire in March 2017. (Nate Guidry / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Keeping up with the Joneses

Advertise with us

The topic of facilities adds another variable to multi-million-dollar equation.

The landscape of the school’s Oakland campus has been almost entirely unchanged over the past five years, with no new athletic buildings sprouting up. There have been internal improvements, though. The Panthers’ football facility on the South Side has been gutted over the past several years, with costly renovations to the locker room, team meeting room, staff meeting room and players’ lounge, along with a new turf practice field. As of this season, that building comes complete with a barbershop. Petersen Events Center and Trees Pool have also received multi-million-dollar facelifts in the past four years.

The most ambitious of those projects is still in the planning stage. In April, Lyke announced what she named Victory Heights, a proposed development on the university’s upper campus that includes a 3,000-seat arena for volleyball, wrestling and gymnastics, as well as an indoor track and a human-performance center, all of which would effectively replace 67-year-old Fitzgerald Field House.

Though Pitt brings in more money as an athletic department in the ACC, other schools receive similar payouts. Those universities, therefore, need to do something to differentiate themselves from their peers.

“It doesn’t seem like any of the athletic departments are like ‘Oh, we have too much money. Let’s go ahead and give some away,’ ” Paul said. “They find ways. It really depends on where you start from and where you’re trying to get to from that point.”

Advertise with us

As some facets of the athletic department have moved forward, others have fallen behind.

Maybe the most notable is attendance for the school’s two major sports, football and men’s basketball. By leaving the Big East, the Panthers were abandoning longtime schedule fixtures such as West Virginia, Connecticut, Villanova and Georgetown, but with it, they would be gaining regular visits from the storied likes of Duke, North Carolina and Florida State. Part of the allure of the ACC was the draw of bigger-name opponents that could generate more interest in home games in a crowded, pro-oriented sports market.

That hope hasn’t come to fruition. In its first five seasons in the league, Pitt’s home football games against ACC opponents drew an average of 41,671 fans, with seven crowds smaller than 40,000. In its final five seasons in the Big East, intra-conference games had an average audience of 48,017, with only one smaller than 40,000. On the men’s basketball side, it saw average home conference attendance dip from 11,957 in the final three years in the Big East to 11,640 in its first three years in the ACC.

That decline has an adverse effect on the money the athletic department is able to bring in from ticket sales and concessions, among other things. In realignment and expansion, all the talk of television markets and brand enhancements perhaps obscured other factors that can’t be so easily measured.

“Look at the Big Ten — how much interest is there in Rutgers-Minnesota or Maryland-Iowa? If Pitt doesn’t play Penn State or West Virginia anymore, those rivalries are gone,” said Brad Humphreys, a sports economist at West Virginia University’s College of Business & Economics. “I think that’s an important part of college sports. Ten years from now, it wouldn’t surprise me if many athletic programs look back on this realignment period and think they made mistakes.”

Advertise with us
In its first five seasons in the league, Pitt's home football games against ACC opponents drew an average of 41,671 fans. (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

A brighter future?

Any conversation of where the ACC and its members stand financially comes with an all-important asterisk.

Fall 2019 will mark the launch of the ACC Network, a linear television network in partnership with ESPN upon which some of the conference’s financial aspirations rest.

For the league and its leadership, there are reasons for optimism, some of the same reasons that pushed them to pursue a network in the first place. The Big Ten Network — which debuted in August 2007, making it the pioneer of conference-centric channels — is an undeniable success story, having turned the league into more of a money-making behemoth than it already was. The SEC Network spurred a similar transformation since its launch in August 2014. According to federal tax returns, in the ensuing three years, the SEC’s television and radio revenue nearly doubled, from $210.4 million to $409.1 million, helping increase its advantage over the ACC in that category from $13.2 million to $173.1 million.

Sports economist John Vrooman projects that each ACC school should see a bump of $5 million to $8 million after 2019. Lyke, while declining to discuss specifics, said the revenue generated by the network is going to be “an incremental climb” before 2025, when she said “it really starts to pick up.”

Advertise with us

Those potential rewards come with costs and questions.

In November 2017, a Pitt trustees panel approved a $13.8 million plan to fund infrastructural improvements to university facilities to support network broadcasts, as is required by contract with the ACC. Those renovations include the construction of a broadcast studio and control rooms at Petersen Events Center, as well as fiber connectivity and light and power upgrades at various facilities. An August report from Sports Business Daily noted that the 15 ACC schools will collectively spent $110 million to $120 million of their own money to prepare for the network’s launch, four times what SEC members spent four years ago.

The ACC doesn’t have the same reach as the Big Ten or SEC, both of which have larger schools with larger fan bases, but it will be able to collect subscriber fees from major media markets that stretch along the east coast from Boston to Miami, to say nothing of Notre Dame and its nationwide following.

At the same time, though, the conference is hoping to cash in on linear television in 2018, a time when networks such as ESPN are feeling the brunt of cord-cutting and losing subscribers who are seeking out other options in a changing marketplace.

“We don’t care whether you’re buying it and watching it on your phone and tablet or whether you’re doing it on your more traditional television set,” ACC commissioner John Swofford said. “The exposure is the same. The dollars, to us, are the same. What it will do for the league is that it should generate significantly more dollars for our institutions, as well as provide a tremendous service for all of our sports and our fans throughout the country.”

Advertise with us

The potential success of the ACC Network could play a pronounced role in buoying the financial standing of a conference that lags behind its peers. In 2016-17, the ACC made $418.1 million, ranking fourth among the Power Five conferences (ahead of only the 10-team Big 12), and its $26.6 million average payout was last among those leagues.

For now, the ACC has something potentially more valuable than wealth — stability. In 2016, as part of the extension of the conference’s media deal with ESPN through 2036, league members unanimously agreed to extend a grant-of-rights provision. With that, the ACC controls a school’s media rights — and, far more notably, the money that comes with them — until the expiration of the contract. There’s likely nothing that can blind the wandering eye of college administrators in search of greener, more lucrative pastures, but the threat of losing out on tens of millions of dollars annually may be the closest thing.

For what seems like the first time in a long time, there is a sense of calm at a school like Pitt. For now, the fear that whatever prosperity it is enjoying will be swiped from under it at any moment has vanished. The athletic department, after years of peering over its shoulder, has a firm place at the gilded table of major college athletics, with carpeting and all under its feet.

“I think there’s a sense of stability moving forward,” Lyke said. “We’re in a really good position within the ACC. I think we match that conference very well academically and athletically. I think five years from now, if we invest wisely as a campus and as a university, we’ll be in a much better competitive position, as well, across the board.”

Brian Batko and Stephen J. Nesbitt contributed reporting. Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG

Advertise with us

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.