The epitome of brutality.
It’s a four-word phrase popularized on Twitter in recent years by college basketball analyst Jon Rothstein, who uses it any time a top program loses a home game to a much weaker opponent.
The sentiment applies just as well to Pitt’s encounters with North Carolina on the football field, the next of which is set for Saturday in Chapel Hill, N.C.
Since joining the ACC in 2013, the Panthers have had a hard time defeating the Tar Heels. They remain the lone ACC Coastal Division team Pitt hasn’t defeated since the conference change. And those losses have been a parade of narrow misses and what-ifs.
Let’s rank them from least to most disappointing:
5. 2013 (North Carolina 34, Pitt 27)
Read More
How it went: The day Pitt and its fans were introduced to the menace of Ryan Switzer (he’ll make a few more appearances on this list). The 5-foot-8 wide receiver, a West Virginia native, returned a second-quarter punt 65 yards for a touchdown, helping extend North Carolina’s lead to 24-3. The Tar Heels would push that lead to 27-3 early in the third quarter, but the Panthers mounted a spirited comeback, tying the game with 8:52 remaining on a touchdown run from some freshman named James Conner. It was then, though, that Switzer delivered his most damaging blow of that day, returning another punt for a touchdown, this one going 61 yards, with 4:46 left to provide the game’s decisive score.
What it meant: Ultimately, not a whole lot. Pitt finished the regular season 6-6 and 3-5 in the ACC, placing it next-to-last in the Coastal Division. The Tar Heels finished one game ahead in the standings, meaning the Nov. 16 loss was merely the difference between fifth and sixth place.
4. 2014 (North Carolina 40, Pitt 35)
How it went: Powered by 220 rushing yards from Conner in a season in which he would win ACC Player of the Year, Pitt jumped out to a 14-0 lead in the first quarter and went into halftime up, 21-13. A 45-yard touchdown run from Marquise Williams gave North Carolina its first lead of the day, 34-28, with 14 minutes left, but a 22-yard touchdown run from Conner, his fourth of the day, put the Panthers back in front by one with 3:33 remaining. That lead would only hold for so long. The Tar Heels mounted a 13-play, 75-yard drive capped off by a T.J. Logan touchdown run from one yard out to capture a victory from Pitt in a game in which it was up or tied for about 48 minutes.
What it meant: A little more than the season before, but it didn’t cost the Panthers dramatically in any way. They ended the regular season 6-6 and 4-4 in the league, and had they beaten North Carolina, with whom they were tied in the coastal standings, they would have finished in a tie for second with Duke (who beat them in double overtime).
3. 2017 (North Carolina 34, Pitt 31)
How it went: In a strangely entertaining, largely mistake-free game between two teams that finished a combined 8-16, a Switzer-less Tar Heels offense got perhaps its best performance of the season from quarterback Nathan Elliott, who went 20 of 31 for 235 yards and two touchdowns. He was countered by Darrin Hall, who continued a midseason tear with 121 rushing yards and four touchdowns. The final one of those scores gave Pitt a 31-27 lead with 13:16 remaining, but North Carolina responded with a touchdown of its own seven minutes later to go up for good.
What it meant: This is where they start to cut a little deeper. The Panthers finished the season 5-7, marking the first time since 2007 they missed out on a bowl game. Had it taken care of business at home on that Thursday night in November against an opponent that finished 3-9, Pitt would still be nursing a longer consecutive bowl streak than Michigan, Notre Dame, Ohio State and USC.
2. 2015 (North Carolina 26, Pitt 19)
How it went: In a nationally televised Thursday night matchup between two ranked teams, the Tar Heels burst out of the gates, building a 20-3 lead by halftime, a stretch highlighted by a 71-yard touchdown reception from Switzer, who finished the night with five catches for 126 yards. Despite what the final score indicated, the game was never particularly close, as Pitt trailed by double digits for 34 of the game’s 60 minutes. A Scott Orndoff touchdown catch with 46 seconds left made the loss slightly more presentable.
What it meant: Quite a lot. With a 6-2 record in conference games, Pitt finished second in the coastal in its first season under coach Pat Narduzzi, behind only North Carolina at 8-0. If the Panthers had won that night, both teams would have been 7-1, with Pitt earning a trip to the ACC championship against eventual national runner-up Clemson by virtue of the head-to-head tiebreaker.
1. 2016 (North Carolina 37, Pitt 36)
How it went: Beginning with an Ejuan Price safety that opened scoring 4:30 into the game, Pitt led the Tar Heels for almost the entirety of the afternoon. Buoyed by 130 total yards from Conner and 107 rushing yards on just nine carries from future all-American Quadree Henderson, the Panthers scored the game’s first 12 points and led, 36-23, with six minutes left. A 2-yard touchdown pass from Mitch Trubisky to Bug Howard with 5:24 left got North Carolina within six, and after a Panthers three-and-out, it embarked on a rather improbable and, for its opponent, nightmarish drive. The Tar Heels’ 17-play, 63-yard drive included three fourth-down conversions, all of which required at least 6 yards to move the sticks, the final of which was a fourth-and-9. Switzer, in his final act of emotionally tormenting Pitt and its fans, was on the receiving end of two of those conversions on a day in which he had 16 catches for 208 yards and a touchdown. The possession ended in predictably painful fashion. Having to hurry from the 0-yard-line, with no timeouts, Trubisky took the snap and tossed the ball up near the corner of the end zone, where the 6-foot-5 Howard grabbed it with two seconds remaining. It was North Carolina’s first lead of the day.
What it meant: While the 2016 loss didn’t have the same obvious and crippling effect as the one the previous season, it had a significant and perhaps even unknown impact. Pitt finished one game out of first place in the Coastal Division that season, tied with Miami and, you guessed it, North Carolina. Holding on to beat the Tar Heels would have put it in a first-place tie with Virginia Tech, a team it lost to by three on a Thursday night home game in October. How might have that game gone had the Panthers entered that contest with a 3-0 ACC record and a chance to put a stranglehold on the coastal division, rather than just an opportunity to keep pace it in? Well, that shall remain lost to history.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.