Brian Batko: Howdy, folks. Some game last weekend, huh? A humbling experience all-around, including for the media types such as myself who predicted a close one. Anyway, I've got a couple soft pretzels from the South Side to munch on for lunch, so let's get into the chat.
SOMD Panther: To someone who was unable to watch the game live, and unwilling to watch a replay, what would be your answer to the following question: what in the wide, wide world of sports happened?!?!?!?!?
Brian Batko: Well, where should we begin? Pitt won, but actually lost the opening coin toss, and it was all downhill from there, my friend. Outplayed on offense, defense and in special teams. It wasn't pretty.
Jake Adonizio’s Baby Mama: After PSU begged us to take the game in the first half, does This team lack Killer instinct ?
Brian Batko: A killer instinct? After that performance, you could say it lacks a starting instinct, a battle-back instinct, and basically any other instinct needed to not lose a game by 45 points. To your rival. At your home field. On national TV.
tonto: I think Pitt's main problem is the 'important' people there think they have a lifetime membership in the blue blood club because they competed 40 yrs ago.
Read More
tonto: So my question, when are they going to realize they have to actually win something now? Like even a minor bowl? Wait make a minor bowl? That they can't just transfer credits, they have to retake and pass some courses first? All the other good stuff, nfl, hof, etc rings hollow until they do? Thanks
Brian Batko: Well, let's saddle up, Tonto. I didn't really know what you meant by that first comment, so I'm glad you followed up. The most "important" people in Pitt athletics and Pitt football haven't been here long at all, so I'm not sure that concern makes much sense. Pitt has made and won minor bowl games and guess what, that doesn't move the meter much. Obviously, things have changed in a major way since the halcyon days of Pitt winning the 1976 national title. Finishing on top in the ACC Coastal someday would be "something."
Bobby Bottleservice: How much longer do we have to put up with Shawn Watson?
Brian Batko: At least 10 more games, I reckon. Then again, he did get removed from play-calling duties after the season opener at Texas in 2014. I don't see Pat Narduzzi doing that, though.
SOMD Panther: What are your top three disappointing games in Pitt regular season history? Mine have to be Miami-2010, GA Tech-2014, and 51-6.
Brian Batko: Sorry, that was the 2015 season at Texas for Watson.
But gee whiz, I'd have to really sit down and think about it to make an all-time list. Losing to Penn State, 48-14, to ruin an unbeaten season in 1981 has to be up there. Probably even worse than Saturday night's pratfall. You could argue there have been even more disappointing ones under Narduzzi, such as Virginia Tech on a Thursday night at home in 2016, a game that if Pitt had won would've given them the Coastal title in retrospect. And then what about some of those losses to MAC and FCS teams over the years? And WVU was known to deal Pitt some pretty brutal defeats, as well. Too many to list, sir.
Brian Batko: And yet, the 2009 loss to Cincinnati, the Gilyard kick return and Andrew Janocko game, surely takes the cake. Thanks for playing.
RickTrocano: Will Pitt score in second half this season?
Brian Batko: Yeah
Optimist: Should Pitt drop football?
Brian Batko: Pitt dropped football too many times Saturday night, so my suggestion would be no.
SadPittFan4Life: After Kenny threw the pick against psu, would you say he lost his confidence or the coaching staff lost confidence in him, or was it just the weather ?
Brian Batko: I think a number of things, really. Pickett would never tell you he lost confidence, but to me, it's human nature to doubt yourself at least a little bit after any mistake, especially when you're a true sophomore starting your third career game and first in this kind of atmosphere. As for the coaching staff, yeah, they might've panicked a little bit and got away from whatever balance they intended to have offensively, be it because of Pickett's struggles, the O-line's protection issues or, as you said, the weather. But here's my thing with the weather: Trace McSorley and his passing game didn't have NEARLY as much trouble playing pitch and catch.
Brian Batko: Also worth noting on that pick is that it was a great play by Amani Oruwariye, Penn State's best corner and not a guy that I think any of Pitt's current wideouts are gonna beat for a jump ball/deep ball.
SOMD Panther: Any reason to be optimistic this weekend? The only thing I can think of is Q. Wirginis getting a lot of tackles.
Brian Batko: I do think Wirginis is in line for another big game. He wasn't Scott McKillop by any means Saturday night, but certainly stood out as both the best splash playmaker on Pitt's defense and probably its most consistent guy in getting to the ball. He should be a major help in slowing down the option.
Matt: Does this game change your opinion of Pitt's chances to compete for an ACC Championship
Brian Batko: Yeah, I'm not gonna lie, I'm much more dubious of their chances now than I was this time a week ago.
RickTrocano: Do you think Myrtle beach will still exist Monday?
Brian Batko: I'm more worried about my beloved Sandbridge
Optimist: How effective do you think Georgia Tech's passing game will be on Saturday?
Brian Batko: Depends on how effective it is in fooling Pitt on the occasional play-action deep ball. Can't say I really have the utmost confidence that this Pitt defense will stop that, given what we saw against Penn State and even Albany.
DSquared: Is Penn State a legitimate top 10 team or was Pitt that bad?
Brian Batko: Penn State was better than I thought, and I believe even their own fans and media would say that after the way they played vs. App State in the opener. I'm still not sure if they're Top 10 good, though, because Pitt really was that terrible Saturday. To me, it was their worst showing under Narduzzi, all things considered.
Fred Freeloader: Welp... will Pitt ever break this cycle?
Brian Batko: Forever is a long time, Freddy Free. But it's very fair to question the progress made, or not made, so far under Narduzzi. Especially now that players who were recruited by Paul Chryst are leaving the nest.
Matt: I feel like Kenny Pickett was the most disappointing part of that game for Pitt. I thought he could be a difference maker and he couldn't make any plays.
Brian Batko: Not sure I agree with you there, Matt. He made quite a few plays with his feet, though not with his arm. From my vantage point, he was on the run and uncomfortable in the pocket early and often. Sure, his pocket presence probably could've been better, but a lot of that was because of protection breakdowns in front of him. Was he overall disappointing? Yes. Most disappointing part of the game? Probably not. I'll take special teams, line play and coaching in that conversation.
Pat A. : What the heck happened to the special teams on Saturday ? Goodness gracious that was a poor display!
Brian Batko: Speaking of special teams, yeah, that was indeed special in its own way. Normally, I don't worry at all about Pitt's special teams units under Andre Powell. In fact, earlier this season in a chat someone asked me to rank Pitt's position groups from best to worst and I think I had ST fairly high. I would say their inexperience showed, but even fifth-year senior punt returner Rafael Araujo-Lopes wasn't fielding the ball cleanly.
Professor Plum: I understand the rain played a part and kirk doesn’t typically hold, but what happened to his leg? The punting was borderline horrific
Brian Batko: Yeah, Aussie punter Kirk Christodoulou had a night to forget all around. I actually thought his inexperience and even just cultural lack of awareness of this kind of game might show up in a bad way, but I figured it'd be more on his right foot than his hands. For one, I didn't expect him to be holding, and for two, I didn't expect him to just drop a punt (albeit on a less-than-ideal snap, as Narduzzi noted Monday).
As far as his punting goes, Pitt fans have to hope it was just nerves that made for some of those shanks and short ones. Or else Ryan Winslow may very well be Pitt's biggest loss from 2017.
Robert: Any chance the youner guys get more opportunities this week over the privileged upperclassmen that aren’t making plays? Their “knowledge” doesn’t seem to translate to competency
Brian Batko: There's certainly an interesting dynamic at work between trusting guys with the experience vs. trusting guys who might have more talent. At running back, I still think your two seniors are probably your best, most reliable guys. At wideout, youngsters like Shocky Jacques-Louis already are getting opportunities. I'm curious to see what happens on the O-line, where I thought Bryce Hargrove had some decent moments blocking as a tight end. Not sure the coaches would make a move just yet, but I do wonder if he might factor in at one of the guard spots, or at right tackle kicking inside. Alex Bookser.
The secondary is another place where you have to figure it's time for a new look at some relatively fresh faces. Damarri Mathis has been solid and obviously Dane Jackson is a go-to guy at cornerback, but I happen to agree with the legions of fans who want to see more of what Paris Ford can do.
RxPanther: Can we expect much shake up on the offensive line? I noticed Pickett didn’t have much time against a PSU D-line that wasn’t as experienced as in previous years.
Brian Batko: Yeah, as I said, I think Bryce Hargrove might be first in line for a real or extended audition of sorts, given his experience and versatility. Obviously Gabe Houy returned to backup duty with Alex Bookser healthy, but he got some good reviews after the opener (I know, vs. Albany). It's probably too early to see a huge shake-up, though.
Steve: Clear you are frustrated with Narduzzi as you are starting to take little shots at him. Can you try to be more professional?
Brian Batko: Not sure what you mean by that, but part of my professional job is to evaluate him and his team.
DougieFresh: Hi! I was at the game on Sat. night. I was very disappointed. But I watched the replay last night and was actually shocked to see Pitt match PSU for 3.5 quarters. It really came down to our punter laying a HUGE egg and theirs didn't. PSU had no converted 3rd downs until late 3rd qtr. Pitt at the very least should have been tied or leading into 3rd qtr. I am not as soured now. Am I wrong?
Brian Batko: Hello, Dougie. Well, I'm not sure I agree that Pitt necessarily matched Penn State, especially for that long. But they did hang tough, and, a lot like last year, I can see the game going much differently if not for some of those early blunders. I do think the more talented team won in the end though, proving that Pitt's margin for error against the Lions - for the second year in a row - was pretty slim.
Woof: Could you imagine if Pitt played in the Big 10 East?
Brian Batko: A lot of people probably wish Pitt was in the Big Ten East, actually. But that's a wormhole for another day. Maybe someday soon. At the very least, I'm confident that Pitt would be the least scandalous team in that division these days.
Steve: Evaluate yes but taking personal shots is not called for. But you cowardly take little shots in tweets
Brian Batko: Again, gonna need you to back up your theory with some evidence here.
SVPanther: Pitt’s recruiting over the past years has been anemic. Is this fixable? Or is it structural? Ie, quantity of 5, 4, 3 stars from WPIAL has greatly diminished since the early 80’s. If fixable, how?
Brian Batko: You can still recruit those types of players and develop them. It's not THAT bad. It's more mediocre than anemic, if you're going by the star rankings. Of course, it's also the classic chicken-egg deal. If Pitt is better, they'll recruit better. But you have to recruit better to get better. Such is the challenge of coaching. "That's why they call us coach," as Pat Narduzzi might say. Hope that wasn't a "shot"
H2P: Taysir Mack wasn’t even targeted much and why throw a deep ball to Tipton?
Brian Batko: Great question. Probably wasn't a very good decision by Kenny Pickett on that pick, but I'm not sure that going up to get that ball is Tre Tipton's game, either. Especially when he hasn't played in so long.
Optimist: Why are people making a big deal about Tim Salem drinking flat Mountain Dew? It tastes just as bad as regular Mountain Dew.
Brian Batko: Well that's just nuts. Regular Mountain Dew is fine. Flat pop/soda/whatever is awful.
Gus from Moon: How bad will PSU beat Pitt next year? The talent disparity will be even worse.
Brian Batko: Yeah, that's a scary thought Gus, and one that I think is one of the biggest takeaways/reasons that game was so concerning. Then again, Trace McSorley will be gone, so that's more than likely a downgrade at the most important position. We'll see how Pitt develops as this year goes on, but then again, lots of seniors will be gone on their side, too.
DougieFresh: Just looking at halftime stats and game stats alone, you would not expect a 51-6 score. The OKST game last year, they got boat raced and didn't belong on the same field. The PSU was so much different in my opinion.Too many penalties and unforced errors. After watching the replay, Pitt LOST that game. PSU didn't WIN it. I do not say this lightly as I bust on Pittt when they deserve it. They have a lot to do to get better, but I think these are correctable problems.
Brian Batko: Your point is well taken. This was a demolition in a different way than the OK State game was. That was over before it ever really began.
H2P: What did the media think of James Franklin running it up?
Brian Batko: I haven't seen anyone rip him for it. It's not like the time he iced the kicker from Georgia State with Penn State up by a million. That was lame. This was against an ACC team, an in-state rival, a team that hates you. And thus, that team has to stop you, lest they take their medicine.
H2P: Where is this vaunted defensive line Narduzzi and Partridge were bragging about?
Brian Batko: It's absolutely been a letdown against power-five opponents, both last year and so far through one opportunity this year. Rashad Weaver is still pretty disruptive. Shane Roy, Keyshon Camp and Amir Watts strike me as decent tackles. But I still think another end needs to emerge, whether it's Dewayne Hendrix or someone else. I feel like all those guys have had their moments, but obviously the defense needs more than that.
Gopitt: I thought this tight end that transferred in was a good receiver, we don’t even throw to the tight end!
Brian Batko: Not really sure what's up with that, yeah. Saw more of Will Gragg vs. Penn State than Albany, but perhaps they're still figuring out how to work him into the offense and how they want to use him, if at all.
Matt: 4th and 3 going in for a score, and Pitt calls a jumbo formation base lead play. Did anyone ask about the thought behind that call?
H2P: What did you think of the 4th and 3 call. You burn a timeout for that?
Brian Batko: No one asked about the formation specifically, but it was a topic after the game and again on Monday that Narduzzi addressed. The jumbo set had been having some success, but yeah, some think it should've been a more imaginative playcall. I don't necessarily blame Narduzzi for it, given the way Pitt had been pounding the rock. Maybe the timeout was even a setup to make Penn State think it'd be a more creative effort? Problem was, Pitt just didn't hit them in the mouth and get the push they needed for that to work. Hindsight n'at.
Tim: How bad will attendance be on Sat? Under 30k?
Brian Batko: No, I don't think it will be that low. But you never know. We'll see how the weather turns out.
Panther: Did Pitt show any interest in Matt Canada after LSU sent him packing?
Brian Batko: Don't think so, no.
Pitt is lit: Maybe Pitt needs to schedule like PSU play winnable non conference games at home and occasionally go on the road! 6 road games is crazy and the non conference is to tough.
Brian Batko: Eh, there's certainly an argument for that. Personally, I think games against good teams are good for everyone. Notre Dame on the road this year is out of Pitt's hands.
Panther: Pitt 34- ga tech 31, ironically on a field goal to win it!
Brian Batko: Would not surprise me. I actually do think Pitt might win this one, given how Georgia Tech played last week. Will it be high-scoring? You'd think so, but who knows what to expect with these teams anymore. I'll say Pitt wins 34-27.
Brian Batko: Thanks as always for stopping through. That's all the time we've got to chat today. See you next week, same place same time.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.