Graduate transfers have become a fixture of college basketball recruiting the past several years. Such players, who have graduated from their previous school and are immediately eligible to compete at their new destination, are as highly sought after as any group of players on the proverbial market.

It’s a route to building a team to which Pitt has turned frequently over the past several years. With the commitment Monday of New Mexico State guard Sidy N’Dir, Pitt has had five graduate transfers on its roster over the past four seasons, going back to the 2015-16 campaign.

N’Dir will blaze his own path upon arriving on campus and his ultimate success with the Panthers won’t be dictated by those in a similar position who preceded him. Still, it’s worth examining how Pitt’s experimentation with graduate transfers has fared and how, for the most part, the results from it have been negligible:

Sterling Smith, 2015-16

Advertise with us

Stats in final year at previous stop (Coppin State): 30.1 minutes per game, 13.9 points per game, 4.9 rebounds per game, 1.6 assists per game, 10.1 field goal attempts per game, 46.8 field goal percentage, 41.8 3-point percentage

Stats in lone season at Pitt: 17.3 minutes per game, 4.5 points per game, three rebounds per game, 1.1 assists per game, 3.6 field goal attempts per game, 36.7 field goal percentage, 40 3-point percentage

Rafael Maia, 2015-16

Stats in final year at previous stop (Brown): 30.1 minutes per game, 9.9 points per game, 8.7 rebounds per game, 6.2 field goal attempts per game, 53.8 field goal percentage

Stats in lone season at Pitt: 12 minutes per game, two points per game, 3.6 rebounds per game, 1.6 field goal attempts per game, 46.2 field goal percentage

Advertise with us

Alonzo Nelson-Ododa, 2015-16

Stats in final year at previous stop (Richmond): 23.1 minutes per game, 6.6 points per game, 5.1 rebounds per game, 4.7 field goal attempts per game, 45.2 field goal percentage

Stats in lone season at Pitt: 8.4 minutes per game, 1.3 points per game, 1.6 rebounds per game, 1.2 field goal attempts per game, 45.9 field goal percentage

Smith, Maia and Nelson-Ododa were brought in by former coach Jamie Dixon in a single class as a way to supplement leading scorers Jamel Artis, Mike Young and James Robinson after the departures of Cameron Wright, Durand Johnson and Josh Newkirk, the latter two of whom transferred. Smith was the headliner of the group, a player pursued by a number of major-conference suitors, and made the biggest impact, starting 23 of a possible 33 games, but even still, his contributions were relatively modest.

Monty Boykins, 2017-18

Advertise with us

Stats in final year at previous stop (Lafayette): 23.4 minutes per game, 10.7 points per game, 2.5 rebounds per game, 1.9 assists per game, 9.4 field goal attempts per game, 38.4 field goal percentage, 35.8 3-point percentage

Stats in long season at Pitt: 5.7 minutes per game, 1.4 points per game, 0.5 rebounds per game, 0.1 assists per game, 1.6 field goal attempts per game, 19.4 field goal percentage, 19 3-point percentage

On paper, Boykins was a veteran who would provide a measure of experience and stability for an extraordinarily young roster, even if it was just his first year at the school, as well. As was the case with most anything related to Pitt’s 2017-18 team, it didn’t quite work out as planned. Boykins was never able to beat out freshmen such as Parker Stewart or Khameron Davis (or junior-college transfer Jared Wilson-Frame) for playing time, and even when on the court, the contributions coaches expected him to make in games — namely, making 3s — seldom came to be.

N’Dir should present another interesting test case next season. In his second-to-last season at New Mexico State, he was one of the Aggies’ top scorers at 13.7 points per game before a foot injury sidelined him after nine games. Last season, he slid into a less-involved role on offense following the arrival of Texas Southern transfer Zach Lofton, who ended up averaging 20.1 points per game (N’Dir, as a result, averaged 7.8, with his field goal percentage also declining about eight points).

Nonetheless, he is regarded as an excellent defender who should figure prominently in a suddenly crowded rotation of guards that also features Wilson-Frame, Davis, Malik Ellison, Trey McGowens and Xavier Johnson.

Advertise with us

Of Sports Illustrated’s top 100 transfers heading into the 2017-18 season, 26 were graduate transfers who were entering one of the sport’s six major conferences after having not played in such a league at their most recent stop. Of those 26 players, only three improved their scoring average from their final year at their previous school, with an average dip of 5.5 points per game (from 13.2 points to 7.7 points per game). Among those graduate transfers who averaged single-digit points per game at their most recent school, like N’Dir, their scoring average went down by 1.4 points per game (from 6.9 to 5.5).

N’Dir could very well be an exception to what has become a general rule, finding a productive and high-volume niche on a young and in many ways still rebuilding team. At this relatively late stage of his career, however, he largely is what he is, which is to say what many grad transfers ultimately are, as Pitt has learned the past several years — potentially helpful pieces, but far from program- or even season-altering forces.

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG