Four months ago, Pitt announced the creation of an athletics hall of fame, one of several measures Heather Lyke has implemented in her 13 months as athletic director.

At an unspecified date over the next few months, the school will unveil its inaugural class. That group will be the product of a lengthy process, one in which the university accepted online submissions from the general public and used a 19-member selection committee to determine who makes the cut.

Rather than wait out a meticulous undertaking, let’s take a stab at who might make it.

Though opinions on the matter have no bearing on who will ultimately be inducted, the Post-Gazette’s Craig Meyer and Brian Batko have drafted their own 10-member class (Meyer won a coin flip, so he gets the first pick). There wasn’t a strict methodology to it, though there were some general guiding principles, including an attempt to draft athletes from a handful of sports, though a 10-member inaugural class at a school like Pitt would likely be heavy on football. People whose careers are still ongoing were largely eliminated. And the order of the picks itself, while a fun exercise, isn’t too much to get worked up over, especially given some of the stature of some of those who didn’t make the cut.

Advertise with us

Let’s get to it:

1st selection (Craig): Tony Dorsett

The lone Heisman Trophy winner from the school’s most prominent team seems like a natural place to start. A pro football and college football Hall of Famer, Dorsett holds basically every major rushing record in program history, from yards in a game (303) to yards in a season (2,150). His career rushing total (6,526) is nearly 3,000 yards more than the next-closest player (James Conner). The Hopewell graduate capped off an already legendary career by leading the Panthers to their most recent national title, in 1976, rushing for 202 yards and a touchdown in a win against Georgia in the Sugar Bowl. Even among a group of legends, Dorsett stands taller than the rest.

2nd selection (Brian): Jock Sutherland

Craig leads off with the face of Pitt’s most recent football glory years, but he left me with the most significant person in the history of the program. Sutherland was head coach for more than half (five) of the nine national championships Pitt claims, and even a player on two more, in 1915 and 1916. He was coach from 1924-38, going 111-20-1, and now the freshman dormitory where all first-year athletes live across from Petersen Events Center is named Sutherland Hall.

Advertise with us

3rd selection (Craig): Dan Marino

Like Dorsett, Marino is a Pittsburgh-area native who stands as the most accomplished player at his position in Pitt history and enjoyed a Hall of Fame career at the next level. Marino isn’t the program’s career passing leader — that would be Alex Van Pelt — but he put up eye-popping numbers at a time when quarterbacks passed much less. By the end of his career with the Miami Dolphins, he cemented his status, at that time, as arguably the best player to ever go under center. On an unrelated but very much relevant note, he also had excellent cameos in “Ace Ventura: Pet Detective” and “Bad Boys II,” feats which are hall-of-fame-worthy in their own respect.

4th selection (Brian): Bob Peck

Again, Craig went with a more recent Panthers star, while I again go very, very old school. In fact, Robert “Bob” Peck was Pitt’s first ever football All-American, earning first-team honors three consecutive years from 1914-16 as coach Pop Warner’s center. It’s still unclear to me what a center did back then, but obviously Peck was very good at it. He was posthumously inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame in 1954, thanks to helping Pitt win national titles in 1915 and 1916.

5th selection (Craig): Roger Kingdom

Advertise with us

The first non-football selection, Kingdom has made as big of an impact as any Pitt athlete ever on the world stage. The Georgia native won the gold medal in the 110-meter hurdles in both the 1984 and 1988 Olympics, becoming only the second person to do so in Olympic history. After originally attending the university on a football scholarship, he excelled on the track and still holds program records in the 50-yard hurdles, 55-meter hurdles and high jump. He remains just one of two men in program history to capture an NCAA championship in an event and just one of two people to win an Olympic gold medal.

6th selection (Brian): Billy Knight

Opening up the basketball portion of the draft, some might think it’s curious to start with Billy Knight. But Pitt only has four retired jerseys in this sport, so that narrowed down the field of basketball greats right there. But of those other three (Don Hennon, Brandin Knight, Charles Smith), none managed to lead their teams to the national quarterfinals of the NCAA tournament. Knight did just that in 1974, when Pitt reached the Eastern Region final, which we now call the Elite Eight.

7th selection (Craig): Doc Carlson

Only one of two Pitt players or coaches in the basketball Hall of Fame, Carlson possessed a rare blend of excellence and longevity. In his 31 seasons as the program’s coach, he led the Panthers the kind of heights they haven’t experienced since. Under Carlson, they won two Helms Foundation national championships, in 1928 and 1930, and made the only Final Four in school history, in 1941. Not only was he successful — winning 367 games at Pitt, the most of any coach in program history — but he was an innovator with his Figure 8 offense, a scheme predicated on various weaves and movements that would go on to be copied across the sport.

Advertise with us

8th selection (Brian): Charles Smith

I thought for sure Craig would counter the Knight pick by selecting the leading scorer in program history, but turns out Smith is mine, too. So I don’t have to worry about passing on probably the best all-around hoops player Pitt has seen. Smith didn’t “send it in” like teammate Jerome Lane, but he did send in 2,045 career points, 987 rebounds and 346 blocks in four seasons. He’s also Pitt’s highest NBA draft pick, going third overall in 1988. Smith was even an Olympian in 1988 and helped the U.S. team win gold at the FIBA world championships in 1986.

9th selection (Craig): The Peery Family

Admittedly, it’s a bit of a cop-out to include three people in one selection, but there’s an exception when they’re blood-related. Besides, while reserving three of a coveted 10 spots for members of a single family would have seemed excessive, including only one simply wouldn’t have been enough. In one of the country’s most wrestling-crazed regions, the Peerys are royalty. Rex, the family patriarch, was Pitt’s coach for 16 seasons, leading the Panthers to their best-ever NCAA tournament finishes (second place, in 1954, 1955, 1957). That success was due in large part to his two sons, Hugh and Ed, each of whom won three NCAA championships (the former from 1952-54 and the latter from 1955-57).

10th selection (Brian): John Woodruff

Advertise with us

Roger Kingdom has two Olympic gold medals, but John Woodruff’s one is an amazing story that is certainly Hall of Fame-worthy. Woodruff won the 800-meter race at the 1936 Summer Games in Berlin, scoring an historic triumph not just for his country but his race, at a time when the United States was still considered “Jim Crow” America and Adolf Hitler had risen to power in Germany. Putting Woodruff in the inaugural class would also be wise given what happened in 1937, when Pitt’s track team didn’t pull out of a meet at Navy that banned black athletes. In 2006, then-Pitt chancellor Mark Nordenberg offered Woodruff a formal apology during a ceremony that honored him at Heinz Field, but this would be another way to make things right with the university’s first Olympic gold medalist.

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG; Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko