What exists as a larger problem for college basketball — an ongoing FBI investigation into corruption in the game — localized for Pitt athletic director Heather Lyke as she tried selecting a new men’s basketball coach in March.
How, in an uncertain climate, would she find someone who came free of tarnish? The answer involved a series of difficult decisions and, from those, cuts.
In a meeting with reporters Wednesday at Petersen Events Center, Lyke said the search for a new coach, which ended with the March 28 hire of Jeff Capel, came with names that were crossed off her list after she and her staff had sufficient information and evidence on their involvement in outlawed activities.
“There were some situations where you just had too much concrete information,” Lyke said. “You didn’t do it on a whim or someone saying something. But if you had concrete information then there’s too much at risk for the reputation of our university and athletic program.”
Heather Lyke details upcoming changes to Petersen Events Center
Lyke’s pragmatic approach isn’t unusual for someone who began her career as an enforcement intern for the NCAA and worked in compliance for six years, first at Cincinnati and later Ohio State.
During the process, however, she did discuss the school’s coaching vacancy with Arizona coach Sean Miller, a Pitt graduate and Beaver County native whose program has been ensnared in the FBI investigation. One of Miller’s longtime assistant coaches, Emanuel Richardson, was arrested last September on federal charges of bribery and fraud uncovered by the probe, and in late February, ESPN reported that FBI wiretaps intercepted telephone conversations between Miller and a runner for an agency in which they discussed a $100,000 payment for star center DeAndre Ayton, who would later sign with the school. Miller vehemently denied the report and received support from the university president that he would remain as the school’s coach.
Read More
Though there was no reported contact with other such candidates, the annual coaching carousel was littered with coaches who came with some level of risk. Rick Pitino, the Hall of Fame coach who was fired by Louisville last October in wake of the FBI’s findings, has hired an agent and expressed interest in returning to coaching. Mark Gottfried was hired in March by Cal State Northridge, even after former N.C. State star Dennis Smith Jr. allegedly received a $73,500 loan from an agency while Gottfried was the team’s coach.
Even Capel, albeit indirectly, hasn’t been free from trouble at programs he has overseen. In 2011, the NCAA handed Oklahoma a number of sanctions — three years’ probation, scholarship and recruiting reductions, the vacation of 13 wins — connected to what it found to be major violations that occurred while Capel was the Sooners’ head coach. The infractions were centered primarily around assistant coach Oronde Taliaferro, and Capel was not implicated in the violations.
“We really had to vet a lot of candidates as much as possible because no one really understands how widespread it is,” Lyke said. “One of the things I read that Condoleezza [Rice] wrote that makes you pause is everybody seemed to know it was happening in the business. Everybody knows this goes on, yet it still goes on. That’s really concerning.”
Lyke’s comments came on a day in which the Commission on College Basketball, chaired by Rice, a former United States Secretary of State, and formed by the NCAA board of governors in Oct. 2017 to examine the sport and what plagued it, released a 60-page report in which it provided an array of recommendations including, but not limited to, ending the NBA’s so-called “one and done” rule, lifetime bans for rule-breakers, making agents more accessible to players and the NCAA running its own recruiting events (rather than shoe companies doing it, as is presently the case).
Lyke agreed with many of the commission’s findings. She doesn’t care for the NBA’s current age limit, which effectively requires prospects to spend at least one year in college, and expressed concern over whether top prospects understand the value of a college degree, the same players who she believes are connected to many of the problems currently being investigated. Her feelings, while genuine, appear odd when contrasted with the hiring of Capel, who helped transform the Duke program for much of his seven years as an assistant there by stockpiling the Blue Devils’ roster with highly ranked players, a number of whom spent only one year in college.
Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.
Get the PG Sports Feed newsletter each weekday here.
“Giving kids the opportunity who have that exceptional talent to go to the NBA, let them go,” Lyke said. “But the one-and-done, I think, is a real problem. There’s a number of those kids who taint the rest of it. I don’t think every kid is getting paid to go to college — they just really aren’t — but there are a number of them where there is too much money involved to think that they’re not.”
Additionally, she said involving outsiders in the NCAA’s governance structure and investigative processes is a positive development, and that the NCAA should take a more active role in certifying summer leagues and AAU programs as a way to try to clean up the sport.
For her, it would bring transparency to a sport clearly in need of it.
“You can’t legislate integrity at the end of the day, so it’s got to be innate for people in their own value systems,” Lyke said. “There are coaches out there you know that have said to you all along, ‘I’m not going to cross that line,’ and they know people who are.”
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.