Jeff Capel’s overarching challenge as Pitt’s new coach is rebuilding a tattered program, but in the short term, his primary hurdle is holding together a roster that saw nine of its 11 players ask for a release to transfer.

There’s an argument to be made about whether it’s worthwhile to scramble for players from a team that went 0-19 in ACC play. While it’s undeniable the 2017-18 Panthers struggled mightily, the alternative isn’t all that more appealing. Last season, we witnessed the bold undertaking of adding 11 new players. The product wasn’t pretty. Part of that had to do with lackadaisical recruiting under former coach Kevin Stallings, but few programs outside of Kentucky and Duke can excel after overhauling a roster. Regardless of how touted a recruiter Capel is — and he is quite good — having to piece together a team in mid-April is less than ideal.

Since requesting their releases last month following Stallings’ firing, several players have announced they will return following Capel’s hire. One has said he will leave. Others remain in limbo, especially as the Panthers’ coaching staff is finalized. Let’s get a better sense of where Pitt’s 2018-19 roster sits right now.

Returning

Advertise with us

Jared Wilson-Frame: The Panthers’ leading scorer last season was also the first released player to say he would be back, doing so within hours of Capel’s hire. Had he transferred, he would have almost certainly had to sit out a year to play one more season, making such a move appear unlikely. Still, as the team looks to improve under Capel, having a proven scorer and well-liked veteran leader helps immensely.

Shamiel Stevenson: Right around the time Wilson-Frame announced his return, so too did Stevenson, who was coming off a promising freshman season (8.5 points per game, 4.4 rebounds per game). Stevenson showed flashes of brilliance and an impressive skill set that meshed well with his muscular 6-foot-6, 230-pound frame. Not surprisingly for a freshman, he was inconsistent, but his potential is clear.

Khameron Davis: Late last week, Davis announced he would be back, complete with a Nike and Pitt-script branded statement on his decision. Davis showed himself to be capable enough offensively as a freshman, but his greatest contribution came on defense, where he was the team’s best player.

Terrell Brown: Brown’s decision to stay — revealed Monday night with another branded statement — is a big one for Capel beyond puns about the freshman’s 6-foot-10 stature and 7-foot-3 wingspan. Brown improved perhaps as much as any of the Panthers’ seven freshmen last season, averaging 7.3 points in the team’s final 10 games (after averaging 2.9 in their first 22). He’ll need to build strength and improve defensively, but few players on this roster are as intriguing.

Peace Ilegomah: As one of two players not to request a release, Ilegomah appears set to return to Pitt after a freshman season in which he was used sparingly, averaging 0.7 points in 5.8 minutes per game. The only question with him would appear to be whether Capel brings in enough talented players to necessitate a transfer.

Advertise with us

Samson George: The other Pitt player not to request a release, George’s situation largely mirrors Ilegomah’s, though being two inches shorter, at 6-foot-7, makes him a slightly less tantalizing prospect.

Leaving

Parker Stewart: Given his late commitment to Pitt and his connection to Stallings, Stewart long seemed like the least likely of the released players to return. It’s undoubtedly a loss for the Panthers, as Stewart averaged nearly 11 points per game in ACC play. He has since heard from a number of schools, a group that includes Maryland, Nebraska, USC, Missouri, Georgetown and St. John’s, among others. Playing for his father at Tennessee-Martin also remains an option, as does Memphis.

Still deciding

Marcus Carr: Arguably the lynchpin of the group. Carr was likely the best of Pitt’s seven freshmen last season, averaging 10 points and four assists per game. At the time of Carr’s release, his AAU coach and family friend Vidal Massiah said Carr was leaning toward leaving regardless of who the coach was, but given Capel’s hire, there are factors to consider. Carr is close with Stevenson (a fellow Toronto native) and Wilson-Frame, both of whom announced their returns almost immediately, and Capel was the primary recruiter for Duke signee R.J. Barrett, who was teammates with Carr at Montverde (Florida) Academy. Still, Carr has attracted the interest of top programs like Villanova, Gonzaga, UConn and Xavier, among others, since his release. The temptation of those options, particularly Villanova, may be too much to overcome.

Advertise with us

Ryan Luther: Pitt’s leading scorer and rebounder before suffering a season-ending foot injury, Luther may be as desirable a player as there is on the Panthers’ roster, due in part to the immediate eligibility he would have as a graduate transfer. He has received interest from Arizona and Maryland, among others, and as more players leave for the NBA draft, the market for him should only grow. Luther is a Pittsburgh area native, grew up a Pitt fan and has wide-reaching Pitt connections across his family. But entering his last season of college basketball, he understandably wants to be in a situation where his team can win. At Pitt, that may depend on who ends up coming back, meaning there could be something of a domino effect at play.

Malik Ellison: A junior, Ellison was repeatedly touted as one of the team’s best players in practice, if not the very best, while sitting out a season after transferring from St. John’s. Keeping him would be huge. The question for Ellison is how much of a choice he really has in the matter. Division I athletes have what is referred to as a “five-year clock,” meaning they have five years to complete four seasons of competition. After playing two seasons at St. John’s, Ellison sat out last season, giving him just two years left to compete. Barring some sort of unexpected exemption or waiver, he would have to sit out at any Division I school he would theoretically transfer to, forcing him to lose a year of eligibility. Returning to Pitt would appear to be by far his safest bet.

Kene Chukwuka: Chukwuka was close with Stallings, so asking for a release wasn’t totally unexpected. By doing so, however, Chukwuka put himself at risk. By being given his release, a player is no longer tethered to a program, meaning a coach has no obligation to bring that player back if he doesn’t want them. For someone like Carr, Luther or Ellison, it’s not a situation they have to worry about. For a player like Chukwuka, who averaged 2.5 points per game last season, the situation is a bit more complicated. It’s one reason, among others, why several people I spoke with after the release requests simply asked “Who in the hell is advising these guys?”

Recruits

Bryce Golden: A four-star recruit, Golden appears to no longer be considering Pitt after being released from the national letter of intent he signed last November. The 6-foot-9 forward was close with assistant coach Kevin Sutton, his primary recruiter, and it’s unsure whether Sutton will be on Capel’s staff. For now, a door back to Pitt appears to be closed. On Monday night, Golden tweeted a picture of himself with the logos of six schools — Wichita State, UConn, Georgetown, Syracuse, Illinois and Butler — along with the message “Blessings in Disguise.”

Advertise with us

Danya Kingsby: A junior-college standout, Kingsby requested his release the day after Stallings was fired and has since received it. Jared Phay, Kingsby’s coach at the College of Southern Idaho, said last week that the recruitment is being handled primarily by Kingsby and his uncle, and that he largely hasn’t been updated on how the process is progressing. Either way, it appears unlikely he will end up at Pitt.

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG