After his turbulent season as Pitt’s on-again, off-again starting quarterback, Ben DiNucci was ready for a fresh start.
So ready that he didn’t ask for anything to be handed to him at his new school — he just transferred to Football Championship Subdivision powerhouse James Madison and decided that he’ll work for whatever he gets.
DiNucci, a former Pennsylvania player of the year after dominating the WPIAL at Pine-Richland High School, now is a member of one of the elite programs at the second level of Division I football. James Madison was FCS national champion in 2016 and runner-up this past season, and DiNucci enrolled there in January as a preferred walk-on who will be immediately eligible with two seasons left because he’s dropping down from Football Bowl Subdivision.
The Dukes are in need of a new starting quarterback as Bryan Schor, the one who led them to those thrilling heights the past two years, has graduated — but they weren’t in need of another candidate. They have a couple of returning scholarship passers on the roster, but DiNucci sought out James Madison upon deciding to leave Pitt in December.
“We told him, ‘You know, we don’t have a scholarship for a quarterback this year,’” James Madison coach Mike Houston told the Daily News-Record in Harrisonburg, Va. “So we ignored it and we weren’t really pursuing that situation. But then he started talking to us more about if we’d allow him to come here and compete for the job, walk on and if we’d give him a fair shake. I told him, ‘Absolutely, we believe in that and that you’re rewarded for your performance on the field.’ “
And with that, DiNucci — who turned down scholarship offers from other teams, Houston added — enters a new competition after a wild 2017 at Pitt. He went from backup to starter to backup to starter to backup again as graduate transfer Max Browne arrived, struggled, re-emerged, then was injured. Freshman Kenny Pickett entered the mix as a result, and his performance eventually sent DiNucci back to the sideline.
DiNucci, who completed 88 of 151 passes for 1,091 yards, 5 touchdowns and 5 interceptions, will jockey with a junior who was last season’s backup and a redshirt freshman in James Madison’s spring practices. And how’s this for coincidence: If DiNucci wins the job, his first matchup will be at N.C. State, against which he was first benched for Pickett last year.
Pitt’s other quarterback transfer this offseason, Thomas MacVittie, will be a redshirt sophomore immediately eligible at Mesa Community College in Mesa, Ariz., looking to have one strong campaign there before bouncing back to a four-year program. Pitt coach Pat Narduzzi said Dec. 20 that he expected only one of the two to leave when they did.
“We felt like Ben would probably stay, try to see through the spring and see how things lie, but at the same time, you understand,” offensive coordinator Shawn Watson said. “Only one guy gets to walk out there. I’ll be honest with you, I think guys need to draw a line in the sand and compete, because I think it really defines later life for you, but you can understand why they want to go out and play. Ben’s on a short clock.”
Pitt’s other transfers to this point will continue at the FCS level, as well:
• Defensive tackle Kam Carter signed with Duquesne.
• Defensive back/linebacker Henry Miller signed with Bethune-Cookman.
• Defensive end Kaezon Pugh committed to Howard.
Defensive lineman Zack Gilbert, son of former Pitt star Sean Gilbert who was ruled a medical non-qualifier because of a heart condition, was granted his release to transfer and will attempt to continue his career elsewhere.
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.