Each week during the 2017-18 season, Craig Meyer, the Post-Gazette’s Pitt basketball writer, will answer fan and reader questions about the Panthers. And some other stuff, too.
If you want to submit a question, you can email Craig at cmeyer@post-gazette.com or hit him up on Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.
Is it coaching or player talent or both that separates effective coaching changes at places like Duquesne Ohio St LSU vs #Pitt and its terrible year on all fronts?
— PGH Mike (@ThePGHMike) January 18, 2018
Craig: It’s sort of a combination of both. A coach can be a whiteboard warlock, but if he doesn’t have good enough players, there’s only so much improvement there can be. That same adept coach, though, can also take what was a mediocre team he inherited and quickly make it into something much better. We see it happening this year. Ohio State was picked to finish 11th in the Big Ten, but in Chris Holtmann’s first season, the Buckeyes are atop the conference. At Washington, Mike Hopkins has the Huskies at 17-7 after they went just 9-22 last year, and that was before losing the eventual No. 1 overall pick in the NBA draft. Locally, Duquesne is in position to win 20 games for just the second time since 1981 in its first season under Keith Dambrot.
There are a few factors at play. Holtmann inherited a potential first-team All-American in Keita Bates-Diop, though it took a coaching change for Bates-Diop to put up the kind of ridiculous numbers he has been. Duquesne played one of Division I’s weakest non-conference schedules and is benefiting from what looks like a pretty depleted Atlantic 10, though what Dambrot has been able to do with that team even with those variables is remarkable. He’s quickly turning Jim Ferry into college basketball’s version of Jeff Fisher. With only 12 scholarship players, it’s easier to engineer a quick turnaround in college basketball. A handful of players, or even just one player, can make a huge difference, which makes pleas for six-year rebuilding plans all the more unrealistic or even laughable.
As it relates to Pitt, it’s not feasible for a team of seven non-blue-chip freshmen to compete for much of anything. But the early success other coaches experience certainly doesn’t reflect well on Kevin Stallings, especially when you look back on how poorly last season’s team fared. Were Jamel Artis and Mike Young the best teammates? No. But you also have to go better than 16-17 with a team featuring two of the ACC’s seven leading scorers and a player who’s the third-leading scorer on a North Carolina team that was ranked in the top 10 as recently as two weeks ago. What was a chance for an unpopular hire to build some sense of goodwill was squandered.
Stallings is a polarizing figure in the Pitt sports landscape. What has it been like covering him as a beat writer? How does he compare to Dixon and other coaches you have covered in terms of accessibility and perceived ability? Is he getting a fair shake from the Pitt fanbase?
— David A. Meyer (@dameyer) February 8, 2018
Craig: I really like Kevin, both from a personal and professional standpoint. He has a reputation he has earned from several high-profile incidents — mostly being caught on hot mics saying regrettable things — but I’ve found him to be a genuine, open and honest person. He’s more accessible than other coaches I’ve covered at much smaller schools, which I think says a lot. As a media member, you can’t ask for much more. It’s certainly a break from Jamie Dixon, who, while a kind person, was always defensive and sort of paranoid with the media (though I started covering the team two months after he left for TCU).
Read More
I don’t think Kevin has gotten a genuine chance from certain groups of Pitt fans, which have seemed to disengage from the program and almost root for him to fail from the moment he got hired. But I also can’t blame a lot of the fans who are frustrated, disappointed and downright angry with where the program is. It’s remarkable how far and how quickly Pitt has fallen, and part of that is on Kevin.
Two questions for you this week. Is it just me or is the concept of the pick and roll completely lost on Chukwuka, Ilegomah and to a lesser extent Terrell Brown? So many times I see Carr or Milligan get doubled and they don’t flow to the basket like they should.
— Dan Musser (@HasBigTaste71) February 8, 2018
Craig: I really noticed it Thursday night in the Clemson game. What you see so often from the Pitt big men is that when they move out to set a screen, one of two things happens. They’re either too slow to set the screen and basically telegraph the play, allowing a defender to adjust, or they aren’t strong enough in setting the screen. Because of that, you’ve seen very, very little from the Panthers on the pick and roll this season, which has really hurt their offense. I think the bigs understand the concept; they’re just not very good at executing it.
Will Pitt give Louisville a game? You think Padgett will remain coach?
— Reggie Smith (@reggiesmith1968) February 9, 2018
Craig: I don’t think Pitt will give Louisville a game, even if Deng Adel doesn’t play due to an injury. Louisville is simply too long and too talented for Pitt to contend. As for David Padgett, it’s a tricky situation. Under normal circumstances, Louisville is one of the top six or seven jobs in college basketball, but with a final NCAA ruling about to come down on the prostitution scandal and whatever punishments may come from the FBI investigation, there may be too much uncertainty to lure a coach befitting of the program’s standing. It may be worth it to hang on to him for another year or so.
As of right now Pitts best win is arguably against UC Santa Barbara. Milligan played a crucial role in that game while Kham filled in as needed on D. Is the Luther injury the reason for no Carr/Milligan pairings?
— Ritchie Valens’ Brother (@beltpgh) February 8, 2018
Craig: I don’t think so. Prior to Thursday’s loss at Clemson, 17 of the 88 lineups (19.3 percent) Pitt has used in ACC play featured Milligan and Carr together, which is down slightly from the 32 of 111 they used in non-conference play (28.8 percent). I think it has more to do with the fact Milligan is simply overmatched against better opponents.
If davis isn’t going to score and pitt runs a zone then why should Davis get so much time?
— Barry J (@BarryJ23) February 9, 2018
Craig: He’s still, by far, the team’s best perimeter defender, which is something Pitt desperately needs, even in a zone look that may mitigate just a little bit of what he does. As long as he is out there with multiple capable scorers — Marcus Carr, Jared Wilson-Frame or Parker Stewart — I think he’s a valuable asset, especially since he recognizes his offensive limitations and doesn’t try to do too much.
There are just 5 cities with championships in all Big 4 sports. Pittsburgh is one away, would an NBA team work in PGH? And how would you build a championship-winning roster?
— Corey Cohen (@CoreyECohen) February 8, 2018
Craig: I’d love to see one, but I also don’t think it would work all that well short of a special set of circumstances. Pittsburgh is the smallest city with at least three professional teams, so the market is arguably oversaturated even at this point. While it would undoubtedly change a bit with a team of their own, I’ve also always been astounded by the anti-NBA sentiment that seems so widespread here. That’d be tough to overcome.
If there were a team here, though, I would counteract that by acknowledging the first few years were going to be awful regardless, so I’d load the team up with ex-Pitt stars who are still playing or, in the case of some, even those who aren’t. That, and I’d take T.J. McConnell with the first pick of the expansion draft.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.