After reeling in 17 new Panthers back in December, Pitt football coach Pat Narduzzi summed up what it was like to enter the uncharted waters of a second national signing day.

Round 2, as he put it.

“There was only a couple fish out there, and there was a lot of sharks looking for that little fish,” Narduzzi said Wednesday as he discussed how he and his staff put the finishing touches on their now 22-man class of 2018.

Pitt wasn’t one of the biggest sharks of the second signing period, a new wrinkle in college football’s recruiting calendar, but Narduzzi said the Panthers hit on nearly all of their targets — including their highest-rated prospect of the bunch, four-star running back Mychale Salahuddin.

Advertise with us

Pat Narduzzi talks about his five recruits on signing day

In addition to Salahuddin, who picked Pitt over Syracuse around noon, Narduzzi also secured a commitment and letter of intent in one swoop from three-star defensive end Habakkuk Baldonado, an Italian import via Florida who chose the Panthers over Central Florida and Michigan State. Three-star verbal pledges Erick Hallett, a cornerback from Texas, and Kaymar Mimes, a defensive end from New Jersey, faxed in their signatures, as did Kent State graduate transfer Stefano Millin, the immediate favorite to start next season at left tackle.

“We got the tailback we wanted and the tailback we needed, but if we didn’t get Mychale, we weren’t gonna take one,” Narduzzi said. “We got a great offensive tackle of need, with Brian O’Neill leaving one year early [for the NFL]. … We needed one more corner, we got that down in Texas, and then we took two more big athletes — I don’t think you can ever go wrong taking big, athletic guys.”

As it turns out, for as different as the recruiting process was with an extra signing period, Wednesday was sort of like deja vu. Just as they did a year ago with A.J. Davis and Jaylen Twyman, the Panthers earned two day-of commitments from a four-star running back and an intriguing defensive lineman. And incidentally, Twyman was from the same H.D. Woodson High School in Washington D.C. that produced Salahuddin, a longtime friend and teammate.

While that connection helped land a former Southern California recruit, Narduzzi and his assistants mined plenty of other ties to bring together these final pieces of the puzzle. Millin, a late-bloomer who became a three-year starter at Kent State, was recruited by James Patton, Pitt’s offensive quality control coach who went on the road because the Panthers are still looking for a new offensive line coach. Hallett became a realistic option from a state Pitt doesn’t usually visit, but is a well-known area to new defensive coordinator Randy Bates. Mimes is the younger brother of Oakland Raiders linebacker Shilique Calhoun, who was coached by Narduzzi at Michigan State. And Baldonado, with his fascinating backstory, was first visited at his Florida high school by linebackers coach Rob Harley, then became a big fan of his future position coach, Charlie Partridge.

“We continue to build our reputation as people and as a football program based on how we do our business,” Narduzzi said. “It’s a work in progress, but you’d be amazed. Bringing in guys who just wanna be a priority walk-on, they’re like, ‘Hey, I’ve been to five or six of these [visits] and there’s no place like this.’ That’s how you build your reputation as a program.”

Advertise with us

One of Narduzzi’s only regrets in the class, which bumped up from 41st overall to 35th in Rivals.com’s team rankings, was not bringing in a “pure tight end,” but he added that he didn’t want to settle for just anyone. A prospect who fit that mold was Matt Alaimo, but he opted to not sign with Pitt in December, then de-committed and ended up at UCLA.

Pitt is now two spots over the scholarship limit, so there will have to be more attrition from last year’s roster. But Narduzzi never seems too concerned with that total, and last year he even brought in Texas graduate transfer Brandon Hodges to bolster the offensive line just before training camp. So while Wednesday mostly put a bow on Pitt’s additions for 2018, he didn’t rule out changes between now and September.

“It’s always a fluid number. If we plan on 14 [recruits], and all of a sudden we need 22, then we’ve got a problem,” Narduzzi said. “We’ll just continue to evaluate that.”

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.