Whatever chance Pitt had to beat No. 15 Miami Saturday vanished just more than 16 minutes into the contest.

It was then that Panthers freshman guard Marcus Carr, leading a break off a steal, made a cut to his left near the top of the key, only for Chris Lykes, the Hurricanes’ diminutive point guard, to draw a charge. It was the kind of bang-bang play, a questionable call, that alters the balance of a game. For Carr, it was his third foul in just over 11 minutes of court time, and for Pitt, it was the end of whatever fleeting opportunity it had to keep pace with a top-15 opponent.

The 67-53 loss to the Hurricanes was an abrupt but not entirely unsurprising welcome to conference play, a jolt felt by perhaps no individual player more than the Panthers’ budding star at point guard.

In the loss, Carr was the most restrained and ineffective version of himself. After averaging 14.6 points per game over Pitt’s previous seven games, the Toronto native was hampered by foul trouble against Miami and played just 22 minutes, his lowest total since Nov. 15. Though he contributed with five assists and three rebounds, he was, for the first time in his college career, held scoreless.

Advertise with us

On a day in which the Panthers’ offense lagged in a way it largely hasn’t all season, Carr embodied and, in some respects, accelerated those struggles.

“It was made a lot worse today without Marcus in the game,” Pitt coach Kevin Stallings said. “Marcus is sort of the facilitator of our offense without [injured forward] Ryan [Luther] in the game. That made it seem worse today because of the lack of time he was in.”

Carr’s statistical absence made such an impact because of the spark he provided throughout much of non-conference play, a span in which he averaged 11.8 points per game and 4.1 assists per game while shooting 48.7 percent from 3-point range.

But against Miami and Division I’s seventh-most-efficient defense, he, like his team, languished. The Hurricanes played tight and aggressive on Pitt’s guards, often shifting to a smaller lineup to match — and outdo – the Panthers’ speed. In the process, they took away Carr’s most valuable weapon, as he attempted just one 3.

“When we’re competing against someone who’s such a good 3-point shooting team, there is a strong emphasis on not giving them open looks,” Miami coach Jim Larranaga said.

Advertise with us

The importance and the lingering effects of his third foul in the first half can’t be overlooked. Carr had two fouls in the game’s opening 10 minutes, after which Stallings pulled him out briefly. After only being sidelined for about two minutes, though, he was reinserted into the game because, as Stallings said, “we needed him back in.” But even with Carr, Pitt’s offense was lethargic, managing only two points, a layup by Shamiel Stevenson that was assisted by Carr, in the nearly five minutes he played between checking back in and picking up his third foul.

Once he was flagged for that crucial foul and had to return yet again to the bench, the game turned. Pitt trailed by just one, 19-18, when Carr exited the game with 3:42 remaining in the half. By the time the halftime horn sounded, it was down by 11, 30-19.

Although he started the second half, Carr was a more limited version of himself defensively for the remainder of the day, forced to play more conservatively because of his tenuous foul situation, particularly once he was whistled for his fourth foul with 14:19 remaining. It altered the Panthers’ defensive switches to make sure Carr wasn’t tasked with guarding a ball-handler coming off a screen.

Those adjustments helped Miami improve its points per possession from 0.97 in the first half to 1.06 in the second half and its 2-point field goal percentage from 41.2 to 62.5.

“I didn’t get that done in time,” Stallings said. “That’s my fault.”

Advertise with us

Carr picked up his production late in the game, recording three of his five assists in the final 4:33, but at that point, the result had long been decided, with Pitt trailing by 21 when the run began.

He finished the game with two turnovers, a relatively low number, but he was careless at times against a Miami team that occasionally pressed. It’s an unsettling trend, with Carr recording 24 turnovers in Pitt’s past five games against pressing teams, an average of one turnover every 6.4 minutes he is on the court.

This week, those challenges won’t let up. While not as effective at forcing turnovers as it has been in previous years, Louisville still utilizes a press and could very well use it more Tuesday against a Pitt team with a sometimes vulnerable freshman as its primary ball-handler.

Over the course of a season, underwhelming performances are inevitable, particularly for a freshman. The Miami loss provided a glimpse of what the Panthers are without even an average iteration of Carr, meaning the team as a whole, along with its freshman standout, has room to grow.

“If we focus on us and get better, we’ll be fine,” junior Jared Wilson-Frame said. “We’ll be able to put a full game together. I don’t think we put a full game together today.”

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG