The start of conference play marks a new chapter in any college basketball season, but it also provides an opportunity to look back on how everything transpired during the non-conference portion of a schedule. Games against largely non-descript opponents can be written off for some teams, but for a Pitt squad about which we knew virtually nothing entering the season, the past seven weeks have provided a valuable peek at a remade roster and a group of players around which Kevin Stallings will hope to build for years.
So what did we learn in that time?
Most valuable player: Ryan Luther
Luther was going to have a big role on the team almost by default given his size and experience, but I was curious whether he would be able to carry a team and if he’d be able to maintain the same efficiency he had coming off the bench last season.
In 10 games, he answered those questions and some. At the time he went down with a stress reaction in his right foot, he was one of three ACC players averaging a double-double, with 12.7 points and 10.1 rebounds per game. He was the team’s most consistently reliable scorer and, by far, its best rebounder, all while providing a steadying veteran presence. How the Panthers struggled at times in his absence, having trouble putting away McNeese State and nearly losing to Delaware State, speak to his importance.
Most valuable freshman: Marcus Carr
Read More
Carr was the highest-rated of Pitt’s recruits coming out of high school, and he has lived up that billing. He is first among Pitt’s seven freshmen in minutes per game (28.8), points per game (11.8) and assists per game (a team-high 4.1). He has been the kind of creator the Panthers sorely lacked last season. He’s among the top 70 players nationally in assist rate and has been an even better shooter than advertised, with a 48.7 percent mark from 3-point range and an effective field goal percentage of 60.5.
There are, of course, areas for improvement. The Toronto native can disappear for long stretches, lacking the kind of aggression to take it to the basket, and he makes his fair share of mistakes, as he averages 3.1 turnovers per game. He’s still just 13 games into his college career, though, so there’s plenty of time for those shortcomings to disappear.
Most pleasant surprise: Kham Davis
Davis was lightly recruited, his commitment came as something of a surprise and there was next to nothing about him online as a prospect. You would hear from coaches about how productive he was in practices and how he always made his team better, even if he wasn’t contributing statistically, but it was fair to wonder how that would translate to games. Thirteen games in, it has. With an expansive wingspan, he has been the team’s best perimeter defender and has, most surprisingly, been a valuable offensive player. He is averaging 5.2 points per game and leads the team in 3-point percentage (52.2 percent) and effective field goal percentage (75 percent). Pitt, at least as it appears so far, may have very well unearthed a gem.
Most concerning development: Rebounding
This is a concern that exists independently of Luther’s foot injury. Among those playing at least 10 percent of available minutes, only two players — Luther and Shamiel Stevenson — have a defensive rebounding percentage higher than 14 percent. As a team, Pitt is neither getting offensive rebounds nor preventing opponents from doing the same. The Panthers are grabbing 26.9 percent of possible offensive rebounds (237th among 351 Division I teams) and are allowing their opponents to snag 32.6 percent of their misses (66th-worst mark in Division I).
And this has come against a non-conference schedule that is among the 75 easiest in the country. With or without Luther, it’s a facet of the team’s game that is going to need to improve drastically in the ACC.
Best win: Towson
The UC-Santa Barbara win has aged nicely, as the Gauchos are 10-3, but Towson was 10-2 entering the game and received a vote in the most recent AP poll. It was far from a pretty win, as both teams combined to shoot 37.3 percent, but without its best player in Luther, Pitt was able to gut out a win against its most challenging foe from outside a major conference.
Worst loss: Penn State
The losses to Navy and Montana came against opponents from smaller conferences, but there was something somewhat understandable about each of those setbacks. The same can’t be said for Penn State. The 85-54 blowout is bad enough, but it very easily could have been worse. Pitt was down 26 at halftime, 38 not even 31 minutes into the game and 42 with five minutes remaining. Most people expected the Panthers to lose to Penn State; very few expected them to get so thoroughly demolished and demoralized in the process.
Biggest takeaways
1. This team can compete with some of the best and also lose to the worst
A fact best summed up by the fact it got within single digits of a top-20 West Virginia four days after needing overtime to put away a Mount St. Mary’s team that KenPom had at 298 (of 351 teams) entering the matchup. Much of that comes from youth, but a team so heavily reliant on 3s and mediocre at making them (34.1 percent, 201st in Division I) is bound for such inconsistency.
2. There’s a core for the future
What Pitt needed, if nothing else, from this season was a feeling it has three or more players in this freshman class around which it can build. It appears to have that. Carr has the look of a future star. Stevenson, while inconsistent and occasionally reckless, is averaging close to 10 points per game. Davis and Parker Stewart look like, at least, future role players on a good team. Terrell Brown has shown intriguing flashes, and Peace Ilegomah looks like he could one day be a rim-protecting force.
3. This team is in trouble without Ryan Luther
Some of their struggles without Luther this season have been addressed, but once he graduates, an already thin Panthers frontcourt becomes even thinner. Brown and Ilegomah have looked intriguing, but both still have a ways to go. Kene Chukwuka is tenacious, but has been remarkably unproductive given how much he has played. Samson George has played just 15 minutes this season. Bryce Golden, a 2018 recruit, could fill that void, but then a still-young team would be counting on another unproven commodity.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.