Let's preface this with the very important caveat that star rankings are far from the be-all-end-all of recruiting.

They don't mean everything, they don't mean nothing, and they’re obviously a subjective measure of a player’s worth. But generally, the most successful contemporary teams are also raking in the highest-rated recruits each year.

Now here’s the thing about the crop of building blocks Pitt’s football program brought in Wednesday, when 16 verbal pledges signed their letters of intent to officially become Panthers next year: By the most conventional method of judging the promise of a class, it’s remarkably average. But including eight projected linemen, three defensive backs, two quarterbacks, two receivers and two junior-college transfers, it consists only of players deemed good enough by Pat Narduzzi, and most of them had plenty of prestigious coaches courting them at one time or until the very end.

“Really excited about the class we have coming in; I think everybody gets excited when they come in,” he said Wednesday at news conference to discuss the class. “There’s still a ton of work to do. It’s a process.”

Advertise with us

Pat Narduzzi speaks about Pitt's December signees

That might be especially true with Pitt’s 2018 haul, one that stands out in how solid yet unspectacular it appears to be. Not that that’s necessarily a negative given how much experience returns.

There’s no truly big name — no Paris Ford, no Damar Hamlin, no Jordan Whitehead — and for the first time, Narduzzi has zero signees with four stars to their name on any of the three major recruiting services. Even predating Narduzzi, Pitt had landed at least one four-star prospect in every class since 2004, though Vernon Smith that year didn’t qualify academically.

But Narduzzi’s latest bunch is also devoid of any “reaches,” so to speak. While none of them are four-stars, none are two-stars, either (though junior-college quarterback Ricky Town is unranked by ESPN). According to Rivals.com rankings, Pitt and Colorado are the only programs to land exclusively three-star commitments, though even Colorado has one player awarded four stars by ESPN.

“I don’t know where all the stars are; we just look for players on tape,” Narduzzi said. “But there’s a lot of development that still needs to go into these individuals.”

This is not to say Pitt failed on the trail this year. After all, while four schools outside the Power Five — Cincinnati, Central Florida, Florida International and Western Michigan — managed to land a Rivals four-star coup, eight other major-conference schools are in the same boat as Pitt in that regard. And all of those eight brought in anywhere from two to a half-dozen two-star or unranked recruits. Syracuse even had its lone four-star commitment renege in the morning rather than fax in his signature.

Advertise with us

So consider the Orange one of the first victims of the NCAA’s new early signing period for Division I football, but the Panthers didn’t get out unscathed, either. New Jersey tight end Matt Alaimo, who gave Pitt his word in June, opted not to sign with Pitt just yet as reports from his home state indicate he’s still considering Rutgers. When the reform allowing for earlier signings was approved in May, Narduzzi insisted all his commitments should make it official Dec. 20, and he doubled down on that mentality in remarks just a couple months ago.

“It comes down to relationships in recruiting. We talk a lot about that,” Narduzzi said Wednesday. “The guys that signed with us valued relationships. Maybe some of the ones that didn’t don’t value those as much. We’re OK with that.”

Alaimo hasn’t announced a de-commitment and had in-home and on-campus visits with Pitt’s coaches earlier this month. While Narduzzi isn’t permitted to comment on him, he said he didn’t have any surprises hit throughout the day, and that anyone committed but unsigned will be “re-evaluated.”

By day’s end, Rivals pegged Pitt’s class as the 41st best in the country, seventh best in the ACC. That’s the lowest nationally since Narduzzi’s first offseason, and ostensibly a step back after securing top-40 classes the past two years, though both of those consisted of 20-plus players.

Then again, the stars and rankings only mean so much, and some would say very little. Narduzzi would say very little. It might be light on instant-impact guys, but the goal is for it to lay a foundation for years to come.

Advertise with us

“There’s always gonna be that guy that’s like, ‘Coach, I think I wanna come to Pitt.’ Well, think’s not good enough,” Narduzzi said. “I don’t want a guy that thinks. I want a guy that knows.”

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.