For the second time in three days, the Pitt football program has lost a quarterback, and this time it hits closer to home.
Ben DiNucci, the former Pine-Richland High School star who got his chance under center this season, announced Thursday on Twitter he will transfer. DiNucci follows Thomas MacVittie out the door, leaving Kenny Pickett as the last man standing entering his sophomore year.
Back in September, the safe money likely was on DiNucci having a very quiet year. He’d back up Southern California graduate transfer Max Browne, maybe get some mop-up duty here and there, all the while staying uber-prepared as the No. 2 guy should anything happen on the injury front.
— Ben DiNucci (@B_DiNucci3) December 14, 2017
But even before Browne’s season-ending injury in mid-October, 2017 had already been much more of a roller-coaster for the redshirt sophomore DiNucci than that expected scenario. Coach Pat Narduzzi turned to him as a spark for the faltering Browne multiple times, and DiNucci even started Pitt’s ACC opener at Georgia Tech in Week 4. When he tossed a touchdown pass on the game’s opening drive, it was perhaps easy to think, “OK, this is DiNucci’s time to lead his hometown team for the next three years.”
Instead, things went sideways, first when he was replaced again by Browne at the end of that same game, and then when Browne started and had his best game the following week in a rout of Rice. DiNucci stepped in again after Browne had shoulder surgery but was strangely benched for Pickett in the third quarter of the first game without Browne, against N.C. State.
At the time, DiNucci was candid and said he didn’t see it coming, despite Narduzzi claiming the opposite, that both quarterbacks were aware of the coaching staff’s plan for them. That could’ve been the beginning of the end for DiNucci, but it wasn’t. He went on to start the next the next four games, the first two of which were victories against Duke and Virginia in which Pickett never played.
Read More
“The first time I started, that Georgia Tech week, was a little different for me. Didn’t necessarily know what to expect. A little nervous. It’s natural to have nerves. But I think every week, I just became more comfortable and more confident in myself and the guys around me,” DiNucci said after the two-game winning streak.
But then Pitt was upset by one-win North Carolina, and a week later, the offense sputtered early and often at Virginia Tech, where Pickett finished the game. The freshman got the nod in the season finale, leading the Panthers to an upset of their own against No. 2 Miami, and the rest is history for DiNucci’s Pitt career.
Overall, he completed 88 of 158 passes for 1,091 yards with five touchdowns to five interceptions this past season, his first extensive action other than the Pinstripe Bowl a year ago when he came on in relief of Nathan Peterman.
DiNucci, who held the Pennsylvania high school record for passing yards in a season until Gateway senior Brady Walker broke it this month, has two seasons of eligibility remaining. Like MacVittie, he used his social media note to thank Narduzzi — whose staff flipped him from his commitment to Penn of the Ivy League soon after they arrived at Pitt in 2014 — but said he will enroll at a new school in January. If he transfers to a lower level, such as the Football Championship Subdivision or Divisions II or III, he should be eligible immediately.
The landing spot for DiNucci could be somewhere in the Colonial Athletic Association such as Towson or reigning FCS champion James Madison, per a source.
As for Pitt, there’s no denying the defection places even more pressure on the shoulders of Pickett, whom Narduzzi has already tabbed as his quarterback of the future. But now both of his would-be backups are headed elsewhere, and the only other scholarship player at his position is slated to be incoming freshman Nick Patti. And options for additions would logically be sparse, given that anyone with experience must expect a reserve role behind a younger player should they come aboard.
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.