Each week during the 2017-18 season, Craig Meyer, the Post-Gazette’s Pitt basketball writer, will answer fan and reader questions about the Panthers. And some other stuff, too.
If you want to submit a question, you can email Craig at cmeyer@post-gazette.com or hit him up on Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.
Pitt still has a basketball team?
— William (@wcadamsjr) November 22, 2017
Yeah. They have uniforms and everything.
How good is Malik Ellison and how much do you expect him to help next year?
— Dan Musser (@HasBigTaste71) November 23, 2017
He’s something Pitt so clearly and sorely lacks right now — a truly top-level athlete who has the speed and vertical capabilities that can give opposing teams problems. Anybody who was at the dunk contest at Pitt’s midnight madness event last month could see as much. He lacks a consistent outside jumper — he shot 34.1 percent from 3-point range and 41.9 percent from the field as a sophomore at St. John’s — but he’ll be a huge help, a player about whom coaches rave.
Given those capabilities, I’d fully expect him to be a starter next season, forming a duo on the wing with Jared Wilson-Frame, at least based on what we’ve seen so far this season. It could turn out that Kham Davis or Parker Stewart really emerges and someone could be one of the first players off the bench, but Ellison should get big minutes regardless.
Do you see most of the '17 recruiting class sticking around long term or will we still see significant churn next offseason, assuming Stallings comes back.
— Jesse Pound (@jesserpound) November 23, 2017
I would have to believe a vast majority of the class will be back at least for next season. This, of course, comes with the realization that in a class anywhere close to this big, it’s natural, based on NCAA transfer rates, they lose at least one or two players at some point over the course of their career.
Read More
From the 11-player 2017 class, the Panthers are obviously going to lose Monty Boykins, a grad transfer, after this season. From a physical development standpoint, Samson George, Peace Ilegomah and, to a lesser extent, Terrell Brown seem furthest behind, but that status can obviously change quickly year to year. Kevin Stallings’ story of Festus Ezeli’s rapid progress at Vanderbilt is a useful one. It’s probably not fair to anyone for me to speculate on who may leave, especially since we’re five games into the first season this group has together. But based on the transient nature of the sport and the law of averages, I’d be shocked if all 11 players finish their college careers in Pitt uniforms. It’s the way the game works.
Marcus Carr had his best game since Navy on Tuesday. Do you think playing Milligan with him helps take some ballhandling pressure off the freshman?
— PittCabe (@PittCabe) November 23, 2017
I think there’s something to that. Without Milligan alongside Carr, Jared Wilson-Frame, more of a wing than a point guard, is the only other feasible primary ball-handler on the court with the freshman point guard, so with Milligan out there, it helps ease some of the burden off a first-year player who’s trying to process a lot of new information and situations being thrown at him.
Not to spoil a story I have running on Saturday, but 10 of Pitt’s 60 lineups this season have included both Carr and Milligan, all of which have come in the past two games. Seven of those lineups have a non-negative +/- mark when they’re on the court, a much better mark than is the case for the rest of the Panthers’ lineups. Stallings has expressed his approval for a Carr-Milligan backcourt and it’s easy enough to see why.
What do you make of Vanderbilt’s current recruiting success? Did Kevin Stallings overstate Vanderbilt’s academic restrictions, or is Bryce Drew that good?
— Eric Fischerkeller (@efisch_16) November 23, 2017
It’s pretty crazy, right? Vanderbilt has been a solid and occasionally excellent program the past two decades, but never quite to the point where it was able to land two of the top 11 prospects in their class. We’ve been told repeatedly by Stallings how hard it was to recruit at Vanderbilt given the school’s admissions standards, even for athletes. If that was indeed the case during his tenure, Vandy either loosened those restrictions or these two players have exceptionally strong academic profiles to allow them to get into an institution that, based on Stallings’ comments, often denies players of that stature. Or Vanderbilt isn’t as hard of a place to recruit as Stallings has said.
Whatever the case may be, this otherworldly recruiting success doesn’t exactly look great for Stallings, regardless of how good a coach or recruiter Bryce Drew may be.
How badly do you think 08-09 pitt would beat this current team?
— Jeff Gingell (@jeffging) November 23, 2017
Assuming we’re talking about transporting that 2008-09 team from the end of that season to nine years in the future to play the current iteration of the 2017-18 team, it would obviously have the potential to get ugly. That squad could very well be the best in program history. It excelled in areas that would exploit some of this Pitt team’s most obvious weaknesses, from having the top offensive rebounding percentage in the country to the second most-efficient offense. Imagining the grown man that was DeJuan Blair circa 2009 going up against this Pitt frontcourt is downright scary.
That Panthers team didn’t lose to bad opponents, as their worst defeat was to a 19-win Providence team on the road. While they beat some really good teams by double digits, they also didn’t humiliate some of the worst teams they played within their conference. They played a nine-win DePaul team twice, beating it by a combined 42 points and only bested a nine-win South Florida team playing on the road by 13. I’d guess the 2008-09 team wins by about 25, with Jamie Dixon calling off the dogs in the final five minutes.
How does Stallings start compare to other teams he's coached
— John Salazar (@patentlawky) November 23, 2017
Pitt’s 1-4 record marks the worst five-game start of a Stallings team since his 1994-95 squad at Illinois State. In his 17 seasons at Vanderbilt, six of his teams started 5-0 and six others started 4-1. Only two of those teams had a losing record through five games and one of them — the 2006-07 Commodores — ended up being a last-second shot against Georgetown away from advancing to the Elite Eight.
It’s another sign that this season is effectively unchartered territory, both for Stallings and this program, at least in its recent history.
Robert Morris....best hoops team in the city?
— trim (@trimdaddy33) November 23, 2017
I’m inclined to say no. The Bobs notched a seven-point win over Duquesne last week, which naturally hoists them up higher in these hypothetical rankings, but they’ve experienced almost the same level of roster turnover that Pitt has and they were picked to finish seventh in one of the worst conferences in the country.
If Pitt loses to a Duquesne team with like seven or eight scholarship players in the City Game next week, I’ll reconsider. For now, though, I’ll still say the Panthers hold the honor.
How would you rate Kevin Stallings cul de sac hairstyle on a scale of 1-10?
— Great Ghosts Alive (@GreatGhostsAliv) November 23, 2017
I kind of dig it. My dad has an almost identical hairline, so I’ve always respected people who handle their business that way once they start losing their hair, rather than simply shaving it like weaker souls like myself would do in a similar spot to try to conceal it.
Best Pitt walk on since 2000? My vote is Marcus “Columbia “ Bowman ! #H2P
— David Alderson Jr ® (@H2PDAVID) November 24, 2017
Marcus is a great person, and I’m going to miss getting the chance to see him regularly around Pitt after he accepted a position as the senior associate AD at UNLV earlier this week, but I’ll go with my dude Zach Smith. He’s an insanely nice guy who balances engineering school with the grueling schedule of a Division I athlete and, since it should always be noted, he once worked as a lumberjack.
If you could choose 1 meat for all of America to feast on for Thanksgiving, what would it be?
— Corey Cohen (@CoreyECohen) November 22, 2017
(You could stick with turkey but why would you)
I’ll start off by stating the obvious — if we had a blank slate with this and ignored long-ago-established traditions, it sure wouldn’t be turkey. Aside from the sparse bits of delicious dark meat, turkey is a garbage food that we really only eat one day a year out of a sense of obligation — kind of like fruit cake on Christmas — because we never have it otherwise.
It’d be hard to single on one meat. I love seafood, but a day that celebrates gluttony and feeling stuffed doesn’t seem well equipped for something lighter and flakier like fish. I’d opt for more of a traditional barbecue meal — smoked brisket, ribs and pulled pork.
*sigh* we were told Coach Stallings was an excellent recruiter, using his ability to recruit at Vandy as evidence, however his replacement has already surpassed his recruiting there. So my question is this...what is your favorite thanksgiving side?
— Halvy Buckets (@halvybuckets) November 22, 2017
I grew up in a household that kept it pretty basic when it came to sides — mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce, a vegetable of some kind, a salad and some pies for dessert (for whatever reason, we never really had stuffing). Given those options, I’ll go with mashed potatoes.
In an increasingly fractured country, though, there are many people who have the good sense to include macaroni and cheese among their Thanksgiving sides. In an ideal world where my parents broadened their horizons, I’d absolutely go with mac and cheese. On a day that celebrates comfort food, the best of all comfort food side dishes should be included.
Also, to express an extremely unpopular opinion, that gelatinous canned cranberry sauce is better than regular cranberry sauce.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.