The past three months have been relatively unkind to the Pitt football program.
On the heels of back-to-back eight-win campaigns in coach Pat Narduzzi’s first two years at the school, the Panthers have struggled during the 2017 season. Heading into their final two games, they’re 4-6 and barring a bizarre confluence of events, they will miss out on a bowl game for the first time since 2007.
It’s perhaps just a momentary setback, an inevitable down year for a young team with several inexperienced starters. As that maturation process continues, though, so do the lumps that come with it. And on Tuesday night, the program had to endure perhaps its biggest lump of the season — disrespect from a fictional teenager.
Allow me to explain. “This Is Us,” an award-winning NBC drama now in its second season, is a television series centered around three siblings — twins and their adopted brother — and their intersecting lives. The show alternates between the past and present, with the flashback portions of the show taking place in Pittsburgh, the kids’ hometown. One of the Pearson family’s three children, Kevin, was a star football player in high school that seemed destined for a major college career until an often alluded-to injury occurred.
Which brings us to Tuesday night’s episode, “Number One,” and its link to the hometown university.
Kevin, in the midst of a stellar senior season, saunters into the family’s kitchen one night, where his parents are cleaning up and preparing food. Wearing a cropped T-shirt and pajama bottoms, he seems oblivious to what’s going on until his parents have to remind him — he’s receiving an in-home visit that night from the Pitt football coach. They ask him to change his clothes and wear something more presentable, to which he offers an objection.
“It’s just Pitt,” he said.
(Interestingly enough, one of the show’s lead writers and story editors, Kay Oyegun, is a Pitt graduate, though IMDb does not give her a writing credit for last night’s episode.)
They plead with him to change, he again says “It’s just Pitt” with a little extra emphasis, and he ultimately relents and pops on a button-up. When coach Waltering — who, based on his name and the time it took place, is presumably Walt Harris — arrives at their Bethel Park home, he begins his pitch. I’ve seen you play, son, and I believe you could be something truly special. You could be the next star in a proud lineage of Pennsylvania quarterbacks.
With his sights set on Notre Dame, Kevin begrudgingly listens. It’s now that Waltering makes his first mistake. When talking of the all-time quarterbacking greats from the region, the first name he mentions isn’t Dan Marino, who played at Pitt. It’s Joe Montana.
“He went to Notre Dame,” Kevin shoots back.
Instead of responding with “Yeah, well so did Terry Hanratty, Rick Mirer, Ron Powlus and a bunch of other guys who never amounted to anything away from South Bend,” Waltering continues. Each of his ensuing talking points is just as unsuccessful, met with sass from young Kevin until Waltering leaves the house. Afterward, the Pearson parents scold their son, telling him how that man was offering a below-average student a full scholarship to a great university and demanding that he send an apology letter.
Fast-forward to later in the episode and Kevin, playing for fictional McKinley High School, is looking for an open receiver when two defenders hit him, one of whom gets his knee. Kevin is sent to the hospital to undergo tests before his dad reveals to him that the injury is so severe that his football career is probably over. In a desperate final plea, Kevin says there’s a way out, that he doesn’t have to go to Notre Dame and could just go to Pitt, but it’s all for naught. The dream is dead.
Life turned out alright for Kevin, as he moved to Hollywood, married (and later was divorced from) his high-school sweetheart and became a major TV star. As far as we’re concerned, though, the more fun questions come from how all of this would have impacted the mythical Pitt universe.
The Pearson children were born in Aug. 1980, so we’ll go on ahead and say this saga took place in the fall of 1998. At this point, Harris would have been in his second season at the school, having gone 6-6 and taken Pitt to its first bowl since 1989 in his first year at the helm. The Panthers wouldn’t have been an appealing destination previously, as they had gone 15-41 from 1992-96, but there was some sense they were trending upward, which made Kevin’s antics all the more flippant.
Had he ended up at Pitt, he would have competed with the solid-if-unspectacular likes of John Turman and David Priestley before, assuming he ended up there in his scenario, having to scrap for playing time with another local standout in Rod Rutherford. He wouldn’t have been without weapons, either. He would have had the opportunity to throw to future Biletnikoff Award winner Antonio Bryant his first three seasons, and by his senior year, he would have gotten to play alongside Larry Fitzgerald. Had he redshirted to have extra recovery time from his gnarly injury, he would have gotten two seasons with the future Hall of Famer.
And who knows what kind of butterfly effect would have ensued if Kevin ended up in Oakland? Maybe with the news that it has landed a coveted local recruit, the Pitt brass decides it will embark on a wholesale renovation of Pitt Stadium, depriving later generations of a tired on-campus-stadium debate that, like cockroaches, would find a way to survive nuclear holocaust. How would that impact the football program? What would become of the ascendant men’s basketball program without the Petersen Events Center? It shall remain a (fictional) mystery.
If any Pitt fans feel slighted by Kevin’s words, don’t you worry — you’re not alone.
In the present-day portion of the episode, Kevin returned to his high school to accept a distinguished alumni award. While giving his speech, and under the influence of pain killers and alcohol, he noted that he’s not the strong hero others have proclaimed him to be. The other honorees on stage with him — a newspaper publisher and a plastic surgeon who helps burn victims — better fit that description, he says. His praise for the publisher, though, didn’t come without noting that newspapers are “a dying medium.”
The lesson in all of this? If you blatantly disrespect probably-but-maybe-not Walt Harris and the sanctity of print media, you’ll suffer a catastrophic, life-altering injury that will ail you for decades.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.