Each week during the 2017-18 season, Craig Meyer, the Post-Gazette’s Pitt basketball writer, will answer fan and reader questions about the Panthers. And some other stuff, too.

If you want to submit a question, you can email Craig at cmeyer@post-gazette.com or hit him up on Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.

I’ll tackle these one at a time.

I’ve been on record as saying I think Jared Wilson-Frame will lead the team in scoring this season. He was known as a good scorer at the junior college level — at one of the top JuCos in the country, no less — and on a team lacking much of anything in the way of experience, he’s probably the most talented junior or senior on the squad. I think Marcus Carr will be Pitt’s top freshman, but, for as much as he’ll play and handle the ball, he’ll be counted on more as a distributor and won’t have the same onus to score. Shamiel Stevenson and Parker Stewart are talented, but I don’t know if they’ll be playing quite enough to lead the team in scoring. Ryan Luther will play a lot and have a big impact on the team, but I don’t know if he’s that kind of a high-volume scorer.

Advertise with us

As for the Pitt football underclassmen, it seems like Jordan Whitehead and Brian O’Neill are the two most likely targets, particularly Whitehead, whom some outlets have projected as a first-round pick. It’ll be interesting to see how it unfolds.

Regarding Pickett, I’m not totally sure. If you burned his redshirt against Syracuse and somewhat inexplicably put him in the middle of a winnable game against N.C. State, why not give him a few series early on against North Carolina given the way Ben DiNucci was struggling? These coaches obviously know a whole lot more than I do, but I can’t help but wonder about some of the quarterback decisions they’ve made this season. To my untrained eye, it seems like a situation that has been routinely bungled or mishandled.

The odds are much better for Carr, both because of the nature of his injury and his overall importance to the team. Carr twisted his ankle and keeping him out of practice this week seemed like a precautionary measure more than anything, mostly to make sure he was ready for this game and the start of the season. Jonathan Milligan would get a large bulk of the minutes as a ball handler if Carr is out, but I don’t see that happening, even if Carr’s minutes are limited a bit. Davis’ injury is a bit more lingering and given the relative depth Pitt has on the wing, his return isn’t quite as pressing.

This has gotta be the fundamental question of Pitt fandom, right? Even when things have gone well over the past 40 years for both of the major programs, there always seems to be a Scottie Reynolds, Matt Howard, Mardy Gilyard or Barry Goheen waiting to come in and destroy those budding dreams with a blowtorch. I can still remember the 2009 Pitt-Cincinnati football game that was a de facto Big East championship when my then-girlfriend, a student at Pitt at the time, texted me “Wow, I think they’re actually going to win this.” Two minutes later, I got another text from her, this one saying “Nvm” [shorthand for “never mind”].

Pitt has enough going for it. It’s a great school with a nice, underrated campus in a bustling area of a revitalized city that, unlike how it was for those of us who went to college in cities like Boston or New York, is actually feasible for a broke college student to live in. So maybe this is the payback — you get to play in a major conference and have extended bouts of relevance nationally in big-time college athletics, but you can never reach that ultimate glory. They’re like Icarus.

Advertise with us

I may end up being wrong on this, but I say it’s this season (assuming we’re talking about men’s basketball). Just barely.

It’s an interesting question. The analytics revolution that most prominently began in pro baseball has extended its reach to college basketball, perhaps most notably at Butler under Brad Stevens. Most major programs have someone on their staff dedicated to crunching numbers and compiling situational data that will ostensibly help them maximize their win total. Pitt actually has two, as assistants Jason Richards and Matt Woodley both handle analytics responsibilities.

The question of whether Pitt could be doing more and utilizing its status as a top research school is a fair one. Konstantinos Pelechrinis, a faculty member at the school, was actually a finalist at the Sloan Sports Analytics Conference Hackathon for proposing a way to measure an “intangible” stat — team chemistry — using sports data. I can’t say I know whether anyone involved with the basketball program has reached out to him to pick his brain (or that of any other faculty member), but it’s something worth looking into for sure.

I think they can, but not in the way that they’re routinely beating some of those schools for the upper, upper, upper-tier prospects, nor can Pitt be in a position where it tries to sell its game-day atmosphere and overwhelming fan support as a central piece of its recruiting pitch. That’s a battle they’re predestined to lose because a slightly smaller university in major city with several professional teams isn’t going to be the same kind of draw or have the same kind of fervor surrounding them as behemoth schools in small towns do (except in Ohio State’s case; while Columbus is a big city, the Buckeyes are still THE show in town).

What’s the answer for Pitt becoming a recruiting power? I don’t know if I have that answer and if I do, it’s a multifaceted one that would go well beyond a mailbag. But it has to be in finding its niche — whether it’s the relationship with the Steelers, the school’s strong history in producing top NFL players or the allure of trying to build something special — which is most certainly not a pitch about sold-out stadiums that don’t exist.

Advertise with us

I would hope not. I enjoy him too much on TV.

In all seriousness, though, he’s 65 and hasn’t coached in four years. I don’t know if there’s interest in him or if, frankly, he has any interest in getting back in the profession.

I grew up a huge college sports fan, so I really enjoy them both, but I’ll go with basketball. Part of that is self-selective — I primarily cover men’s basketball while merely helping my colleague Brian Batko out on the football end — but I’ve found Kevin Stallings to be a much more open coach who is far easier to work with and have genuine human interactions with.

As a rule, I’ve always found basketball players to be more interesting than football players — for whatever reason that may be —though we’ll see if that’s still the case with the Panthers this year after the likes of Jamel Artis and Sheldon Jeter graduated. At least at Pitt, the environment surrounding the basketball program is a little more relaxed and less regimented. The sports information department does a great job with both programs, but I think it’s partially just the nature and culture of the two different sports.

That seems to be one theory, that Narduzzi thrived while scheming against slower, more conventional Big Ten offenses, but isn’t able to cut it against faster teams with spread looks.

Advertise with us

There’s maybe some merit to it, but I can’t say I agree with it. Most any defensive coordinator or head coach struggles to neutralize some of these offenses, especially in a sport where the rules seem to increasingly favor offenses that continue to discover new market inefficiencies. You would expect Narduzzi’s defenses to be better in year three of his tenure, but you also have to look at the kind of defensive talent he inherited. For all of the good Paul Chryst did from a recruiting standpoint on offense, he seemed to drop the ball defensively. Some of those later recruits of his have started to emerge and even thrive this season — Sean Idowu, Dane Jackson and Elijah Zeise come to mind — but many of Pitt’s defensive starters are freshmen or sophomores.

If these problems still exist in a year or, certainly, two, then there will be reason to really, really question Narduzzi’s defensive acumen. For now, though, I’d give it a little time.

The Industrial Revolution to me is just like a story I know called “The Puppy Who Lost His Way.” The world was changing, and the puppy was getting ... bigger. So, you see, the puppy was like industry. In that, they were both lost in the woods. And nobody, especially the little boy — “society” — knew where to find ’em. Except that the puppy was a dog. But the industry, my friends, that was a revolution.

Did I miss anything? Oh, yeah — Knibb High football rules!

Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG